Chapter 4 Campus Possession
༒ Mia ༒
Morning came, but I hadn't slept a wink. I had spent the entire night replaying Sarah's Instagram story. By dawn, my heart was burning with fury and unanswered questions. Unable to take it any longer.
I stormed across campus to his dorm, heart hammering. Tyler opened the door, shirtless, sweatpants low on his hips. His eyebrows rose when he saw my face.
“Mia? Jake’s not back yet…”
“I don’t care,” I cut him off, pushing past him into the room. My hands were shaking.
Tyler closed the door slowly. “You okay?”
“No.” I laughed bitterly, the sound cracking. “I’m done pretending.”
He watched me for a long moment, then stepped closer. “This about the picture with Sarah?”
I spun around. “You saw it too?”
“Hard to miss. The whole group chat’s blowing up.” Tyler rubbed the back of his neck. “Look… I’ve been trying to stay out of it, but Jake’s been different lately. More distant. And Sarah’s been around a lot more than he admits.”
The confirmation made my chest cave in. I sat on Jake’s bed, the same bed where I’d ridden him just nights ago, whispering that his cock was mine. Now it felt poisoned.
Tyler sat beside me, close enough that our thighs touched. The silence stretched. Then, quietly, he said, “You deserve better than this back-and-forth, Mia.”
I looked at him. His eyes were dark, hungry in a way Jake’s had never been, even at his most possessive. The memory of that morning he’d watched us flashed through my mind.
“You’ve wanted me for a while, haven’t you?” I whispered.
Tyler didn’t deny it. Instead, he reached out and brushed my hair behind my ear. “Yeah. And I’ve wanted you multiple times. You know that.”
The words hung heavy. I should have felt guilt. Instead, all I felt was anger—at Jake, at myself, at how good Tyler had made me feel the fantasy of fucking him behind his roommate’s back.
“Show me again,” I said, voice breaking. “Show me how much better you are.”
Tyler didn’t hesitate. He pulled me into a rough kiss, the kind that demanded everything. Within seconds my shirt was off, his mouth on my neck, then my breasts. He pushed me back on Jake’s bed and stripped me completely, his hands confident.
When he pushed inside me, I moaned louder than I ever had with Jake. Tyler fucked differently. Deeper. Harder. More relentless. He knew exactly how to angle his hips, how to rub my clit while pounding me straight to my G-spot, how to talk filth in my ear that made me clench around him.
“Fuck, Mia… this pussy is so wet for me,” he growled, gripping my thighs and driving in harder. “Jake never made you feel like this, did he?”
“No,” I gasped, tears mixing with sweat. “Never like you.”
He flipped me over, pulled my ass up.
The head was enormous. I cried out as he forced it past my tight ring. The burn was intense, and overwhelming. He held still, rubbing my back, praising me.
“Such a good girl taking my cock like a good little slut.”
Inch by inch he sank deeper until his hips met my cheeks. I felt impossibly full. Stuffed. Owned. Tears of overwhelming pleasure rolled down my face.
He started moving slow, deep punishing strokes slamming in and out of my cunt brutally. The friction was insane. My pussy clenched around nothing, leaking steadily. He reached around and rubbed my clit.
“Come with my cock in your ass, Mia.”
He kept stroking harder, turned me onto my back, and folded my hands behind me. His body pressed down on mine, his right hand clamping over my mouth as he fucked me like a whore.
His mouth was close to my ear.
“What's my name?”
“Tyler.”
“What's my fucking name?”
“Tyler…mmmm.”
“Oh come on,” he rasped, still buried deep inside me. “Spell that shit for me.”
His hips gave a hard thrust, making me cry out.
“T—Y—L—E—R.”
“Yesss.”
“Now tighten that asshole.”
After thirty minutes of rough pounding, he placed me in a 6-9 position, his cock in my mouth while my pussy hovered over his. Rimming and sucking both holes like a treasure.
The orgasm hit me harder than anything before. My asshole spasmed on his mouth, milking him. He groaned and flooded my mouth with hot juicy cum.
We lay there afterward, breathing hard. Tyler stroked my back almost gently.
“I’ve wanted to do that on his bed for weeks,” he admitted.
The door clicked open.
Jake stood in the doorway, a gym bag dropping from his hand. His eyes moved from my naked body, to Tyler’s arm still draped over me, to the obvious mess between my legs.
“What the fuck?”
The silence was deafening.
I sat up slowly, not bothering to cover myself. “I saw the picture, Jake. You and Sarah.”
His face twisted. “So you fuck my roommate? On my bed?”
“Yes.” My voice was cold, but my chest ached. “And he’s better. He actually makes me cum better ”
Jake looked like I’d punched him. Pain, rage, and betrayal flashed across his face all at once. “How long?”
“Long enough the moment you came in and witnessed the first day,” Tyler answered for me, calm and almost smug.
Jake’s hands clenched into fists. For a second I thought he might swing. Instead, his eyes filled with something worse.
“I thought you were jealous because you loved me,” he said quietly. “But you’re just… this.”
"Oh, spare me that shit," I snapped. "You didn't think about our love when you betrayed me, so don't expect my sympathy now. Stop playing the victim. This is nothing more than the consequence of your own choices.”
“Hmmm…Maybe I did love you. But loving you hurts every single day.”
Jake stared at us for a long moment, jaw tight, eyes glassy. Then he laughed—a broken, hollow sound.
“Get the fuck out of my room.”
I gathered my clothes slowly. Tyler pulled on a shirt. As I walked past Jake.
"Ohhh... ohhh... ohhh... poor little you," I drawled, clapping slowly. "Should I cry for you? Maybe write a love letter? Because last time I checked, you didn't spare a single thought for the love we shared when you were busy giving your cock out for charity to someone else. Did you?
“Don’t start. “Just go. We’re done.”
Tyler walked me towards the door in silence.
“lest I forget. The tests that had been conducted by the university health center for all female students just dropped, and rumors say that Sarah has HIV.”
Shock exploded across his face, his eyes widening as though the ground had just vanished beneath him.
“I'm so... so happy that you're finally cumming yourself back to your Creator.”
