Chapter 3
Claire
She screamed and dropped to the floor.
Derek's face went white. "Nat!"
He hit his knees and pulled her into his arms. My parents rushed over, panicking.
"Are you out of your mind?!" Dad yelled. "She's pregnant!"
I didn't even try to hit her. "I wasn't aiming for her," I said flatly. "She threw herself in the way."
Natalie clutched her stomach, gasping like she was dying.
"Don't yell at her, Dad... please," she whispered, forcing tears into her eyes. "She's just upset. If hitting me helps her let it out, it's okay. I just couldn't let her hit Derek."
Derek looked at her like she was a saint. "Don't ever do that again, Nat. You and the baby come first."
He scooped her up into his arms. As he carried her past me, he glared.
"You crossed a line today, Claire. I'm taking her to the ER to get the baby checked. When you come to apologize, bring red roses. You owe her that."
I didn't say a word.
The custom suit was crumpled on the floor. I picked it up and handed it back to the tailor.
"Just trash it," I told her. "I'll order another one later."
"Of course, dear."
Mom chased me out of the shop. She grabbed my wrist hard, digging her nails in.
"I gave you my kidney to buy your sister's happiness!" she hissed. "You are walking around with my organ inside you. How can you still do this to her?"
My free hand curled into a fist.
When she first offered to be my donor, I cried for days. I thought it was pure, unconditional love. It took me years to realize it was just a chip she planned to hold over my head forever.
I looked right at her.
"Her happiness? Mom, she was sleeping with my husband. That's how this whole mess started."
Smack.
Her slap whipped my head to the side.
Natalie always came first. That was the rule. If there was one piece of cake left, it was hers.
"You're the older sister," they'd say. "Be the bigger person. Give it to her."
Even when I started dating Derek, nothing changed. They expected me to bring her along on our dates. I don't know when he started looking at her differently, or when he started tilting his phone screen away from me.
But when I caught them kissing on my parents' balcony, I didn't need any more clues.
I slapped them both.
Natalie moved on immediately. She found some guy from college and married him weeks later. Derek got on his knees and begged me to stay. Five years together felt like too much to throw away, so like an idiot, I forgave him.
But the second Nat's marriage blew up, my family scrambled to fix her life. Mom literally bartered her kidney just to hand my husband over to her favorite daughter.
Now, my cheek burned from another slap.
"Do you ever keep count?" I asked, laughing bitterly. "How many times are you going to hit me for her?"
"Because you won't let her be happy!" Mom snapped. "It's just one man, Claire! Why do you always have to compete with your sister?"
I was exhausted. "I'm not competing for anything, Mom. Drop it. I have my own husband."
She rolled her eyes. She didn't believe a word of it, and I didn't care to prove it.
Nathan's aunt was in the hospital that morning. Since Nathan and Nell were stuck in traffic from the airport, I stopped by to buy flowers and some pastries, wanting to keep his aunt company until they arrived.
I stepped out of the hospital elevator, holding the bouquet and the bakery box.
Right down the hall, Derek was walking Natalie out of an exam room.
The second he saw me, the anger from the mall was gone. A smug, satisfied smirk took its place.
"Figured you'd come around," he said, walking up to me. "But Nat hates lilies, you know that. She likes red roses." He eyed the box. "And chocolate? Seriously? She's got morning sickness."
I just stared at them. They actually thought I was here to grovel.
Natalie immediately put on her flawless, forgiving face.
"It's okay, Claire," she said, grabbing my hand. "As long as you admit you were wrong, I forgive you."
She squeezed my fingers.
"Derek and I actually talked it over. When this baby is born, we're going to let you raise it. With Derek. I'll just visit on the weekends. That way, people will finally stop whispering about how you can't have kids."
I raised an eyebrow. The delusion was almost impressive.
Derek stood taller, looking incredibly proud of himself. "You should be on your knees thanking her, Claire. Honestly. After how careless you were with our baby... the doctors said you were completely done. Now she's handing you a second chance."
My whole body started to shake.
Careless?
I didn't even think. I hurled the bouquet and the box of pastries right into his chest.
"Careless?!" I screamed, my voice echoing down the sterile hallway. "You think I lost that baby?!"
Derek stumbled back, stunned.
"How dare you put that on me!" I yelled, tears of absolute rage stinging my eyes. "You know exactly what you did that day! You made your choice! My little girl would still be alive if you hadn't sacrificed our baby just to save her!"
