Chapter 5: Five Hundred Dollars and Thirty Thousand Dollars

Evelyn's POV

My brows pulled together without my permission.

The first word Kelsey ever learned was sis.

Not mom. Not hi. Sis.

She used to drag the s out at the end, her mouth still learning how sounds worked.

I remembered standing in the doorway of her kindergarten classroom, watching her hold up a crayon drawing for the teacher.

Two girls, hand in hand, one taller with a yellow blob for hair she'd given me even though my hair was brown.

It won a ribbon. Kelsey taped it to our shared bedroom wall herself.

We were genuinely close, once.

Then there was the night I overheard Diane and Greg at the kitchen table.

I was eleven. I had gotten up for water. The light was still on under the door, and through it I heard Greg say the system would take her back if we filed the right paperwork. Diane said let me think about it.

Neither of them said my name. They didn't need to.

The next morning, Kelsey wouldn't let go of my hand the whole walk to school. She didn't know what she'd stopped. She just held on.

I didn't forget that for a long time.

Then came the year the shift happened. One evening her Instagram went private. A notification told me I had been removed.

When I went back to Brooklyn for Thanksgiving, she looked at the wall behind me when she talked. By Christmas she had stopped talking much at all.

I told myself she was just growing up.

Later, I noticed something was off.

The clinic records showed her diagnosis — a mild allergic purpura flare, marked resolved, no further follow-up required — dated fourteen months before my last payment.

Fourteen months. I had kept sending the transfers every month after that. Six hundred dollars, steady as a subscription, into an account I had no view of.

The month I stopped the transfers, her messages also stopped.

Not just the updates. The word sis. All of it.

Now her name was on my screen again. Three thousand dollars a month in living expenses from Greg and Diane, and she still needed five hundred more.

I took a breath. Then I typed.

Two options. Send me this month's itemized statements — every transaction — and I'll consider it. Or tell me what you want to eat and I'll load a week of delivery directly onto your account.

I pressed send and set the phone face-down on my knee.

I already knew which way this was going.

Three messages came back in under two minutes.

Why do you need my statements? That's literally my private financial information.

You don't get to audit me like I'm some kind of employee.

You make a few thousand dollars a month interning in Manhattan and you're making this a whole thing over $500? That's embarrassing.

I read them once.

I picked the phone back up.

Yesterday, I had blocked everyone else in the Miller house, one by one, without hesitating.

Kelsey's number was the only one I kept. I thought there was still something left between us — some last thread of what we used to be.

I pressed the three dots in the top right corner.

Block. Remove. Confirm.

Done.

That's it. That's the last one.

I set the phone down and stared out the car window for a moment.

Huh.

Then I breathed out — slow, long — and my shoulders came down.

The panel flickered to life on its own.

Miss, Winston said, I have detected a dip in ambient mood metrics. I have taken the liberty of preparing a small supplementary offering.

I sat with that for two seconds. Then I heard myself speak.

"Thirteen years of family," I said, "and they can't hold a candle to something that isn't even human."

Two seconds of silence.

...I heard that, Miss.

"Sorry, Winston. You know what I meant."

The air between us held that for a moment. Winston cleared his throat.

The gift is as follows: I have temporarily lifted the account restrictions on Miss Kelsey Miller's Instagram. Ten minutes, starting when you open the app.

I could get in? I looked up at Winston, genuinely surprised. "You always find a way to catch me off guard."

I had been curious for as long as she had kept me blocked — whatever she was hiding in there, I wanted to know.

"Open it now."

It's ready for you, Miss, Winston said.

I opened Instagram and searched her name. The profile was there. Public now, for ten minutes.

The first post was pinned at the top.

A Birkin. Golden tan, gold hardware, sitting in what looked like a hotel armchair. The caption read: My first Birkin — all thanks to Mom and Dad.

A short sound came out of my mouth. It was almost a laugh.

I scrolled.

A selfie in a business class lounge. Hong Kong airport, based on the signage. She was feeding a pigeon by a floor-to-ceiling window. The caption said: Spontaneous weekend, don't mind if I do.

Below that, Paris. The Eiffel Tower visible through a café window, a slice of mille-feuille on a white plate, light hitting it perfectly. Afternoon tea at 267 meters with my dear Blair.

I set the phone down on my lap.

Six years. Total: $35,000.

Twenty thousand of that was medical costs. Real invoices. I had checked them one by one at the time.

The remaining fifteen thousand was scattered transfers, the monthly six hundred I had sent as her medical allowance.

Even if Kelsey had access to every dollar of that fifteen thousand, she would have had half at most.

$7,500.

I stared at the bag in the photo.

"Winston. What does that bag cost?"

Hermès Birkin 30 in Gold Taurillon Clemence with gold hardware. Retail before tax is around $12,500.

To buy this piece new, you need an established purchase history with the brand. For this colorway, the pre-spend threshold is roughly one to two times retail, which puts the real cost somewhere between $25,000 and $40,000.

The item in the photo shows no signs of wear. It’s confirmed new boutique stock — never carried.

My thumb stopped on the screen.

Thirty thousand dollars.

Where did Kelsey get thirty thousand dollars?

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter