Chapter 5
Evelyn's POV
I finally took a proper look at the car.
It wasn't his almost ten-year-old used sedan with the taped-on mirror. This one was black and expensive, polished enough to show my face. Rain beaded on the surface and slipped away.
Maybe he assumed I knew so little about cars that I wouldn't notice.
Or maybe he was tired of pretending and no longer cared.
He began closing the window. I caught its edge.
“Can I speak to Oliver? Just a minute. Please.”
Nathan looked ahead as though I hadn't spoken.
“It won't take long. I'm working again tomorrow. I don't know when I'll have another chance to see him.”
After a long pause, he stepped out, opened the rear door, and lifted Oliver onto the pavement. He took a compact umbrella from the car and threw it down beside my feet.
“Keep him covered. Don't let the rain hit him. You've frightened him enough for one day.”
I opened it and held it entirely over Oliver, then crouched until our faces were level.
“From now on, do what Daddy tells you, okay? And even if you're angry, you must never throw scissors at anyone. Do you understand?”
His gaze stayed on my blood-soaked sleeve. He pressed his lips together several times but said nothing.
I started to reach for his hair, wanting to stroke it the way I used to at bedtime. Before I touched him, I remembered how long he'd hated my bleach-scented hands.
I lowered my hand and smiled. “You can get back in now.”
He hesitated with both hands around the umbrella handle. Nathan took one of them and guided him to the car.
Oliver would never have to endure that smell again. Perhaps that would make him happy.
The door closed, and the car sped off. Its tires hit a curbside puddle, flinging dirty water into my hair and across my face.
I stayed in the rain with wet hair stuck against my cheeks. My sodden jacket weighed heavily on my shoulders. I must have looked as bedraggled as a stray cat chased away from shelter.
Slowly, I sank into a crouch. Rain thinned the blood on my arm and carried it over my fingers into the mud.
When Nathan and I first met, we had almost no money. We'd avoid the bus fare whenever we could, counting the stops as we walked.
When I grew tired, he'd carry me the rest of the way on his back. Between breaths, he'd say, “Hang on, Evelyn. We're going home.”
His back had felt warm and solid beneath me. I used to think I could live without taxis forever if he kept carrying me like that.
Those walks had been part of his performance, too.
It was time to return to the home that was truly mine.
I took out my phone and blocked Nathan. Then Sloane. Then the hospital's billing number.
Third-Person POV
Nathan caught a flight to New York that evening.
Once a month, he met his childhood friends for dinner at the rooftop restaurant of a private Manhattan club. He never missed it.
“You arrived last, so you're paying. Same rule as always.” One of the men lifted his glass.
Nathan smiled, sat down, and filled his own glass without replying.
Julian Ashford laid aside his cutlery and smiled, a rare sight. “My cousin will be home in a few days. We're having a family dinner at the end of the month. You're all invited.”
Talking about her brightened his entire expression.
They knew how fiercely Julian loved his cousin. In all the years they'd known him, he'd never shared even a photograph of her.
The Ashfords had been prominent in East Coast banking for generations. Nobody in this circle wanted to get on their bad side.
One of the men turned to Nathan. “Maybe your cleaner wife would get along with Julian's cousin.”
Several others chuckled.
They knew about his arrangement. He'd spent years posing as a poor man, sharing an apartment with a woman who cleaned office toilets and letting her wages support him. None of them expected the Whitmore family to welcome such a woman.
At first, they'd assumed the experiment would be brief. Behind his back, they'd placed bets on whether he'd make it six months.
Then six years of marriage passed. There was a child, too. He'd kept the whole thing going.
“When do we get to meet her?” someone asked.
Nathan's smile vanished as he looked across the table. “Don't count on it. She wouldn't fit in here.”
The laughter stopped.
He couldn't say why, but speaking those words made him feel faintly ashamed.
Julian checked his phone. Suddenly pale, he pushed back his chair and stood.
“I'll cover dinner. Stay as long as you like.”
“What's happened? Where are you going?”
Without answering, Julian left.
The man beside his empty chair spoke quietly. “I saw the picture on his screen. Someone's arm was bleeding pretty badly.”
“Could it be his cousin? Did something happen to her?”
Nathan paused with his glass raised, unable to drink.
He remembered Evelyn stepping away from him that afternoon and the complete absence of affection in her eyes.
She'd never rejected his touch in their six married years.
Surely she was home now.
As he wondered, a message from the hospital director appeared on his screen.
“Mr. Whitmore, Ms. Mercer hasn't paid. Should we continue contacting her? We can't reach her by phone.”
Nathan read it again, unease growing into something closer to fear.
