Chapter 3
Arthur Haverford, the iron-willed patriarch of the Haverford empire and the man who held the keys to Haverford family trust, had given me a choice: marry Nathan or Caleb.
We had grown up together, the three of us inseparable in the Upper East Side bubble.
Both brothers had made their feelings for me clear since we were teenagers.
But the decision to choose Nathan hadn't been a whim; it was a debt I felt I owed.
When I was eighteen, a business rival of the Stirling family kidnapped me.
Just as I was about to be silenced for good, Nathan appeared, taking a knife wound to the shoulder to save my life.
I woke up in the hospital, saw Nathan’s bandage, and signed the papers.
The day of our wedding was supposed to be the day he was named CEO of Haverford Holdings.
But I had already paid that debt with my life in my previous existence.
In this lifetime, we were square.
As footsteps echoed toward the suite door, I slipped out.
I pulled my phone out and dialed a number.
"I need a favor," I whispered. "Get me a private meeting with Arthur Haverford. Tonight."
That evening, Caleb didn't board the private jet to Kazakhstan as Nathan had ordered.
Instead, he showed up at our master bedroom.
I was curled up on the velvet sofa, a glass of bourbon in my hand, when he walked in.
I blinked, feigning indifference, and poured a second glass. "Drink?"
Caleb took it, his gaze dropping to the trace of amber liquid lingering on my lips.
His eyes darkened.
"I’m looking for something a little stronger than bourbon," he murmured, his voice a low, gravelly rasp. "Rosie."
He didn't wait for permission. He leaned down, capturing my face in his hands, and pressed his lips to mine.
The bourbon left a burn, but his touch left a fire.
Driven by defiance and the reckless pulse of the night, I didn't pull away.
I buried my fingers in his hair, pulling him closer, desperate to feel the solid weight of him against me.
Caleb groaned, a raw sound of surrender, and swept me into his arms.
We moved in a blur of friction and breathless heat, hitting the bedroom door before it even swung fully open.
Every touch was frantic, a frantic undoing of buttons and restraint.
He was everywhere—his hands, his mouth, his heat—tracing the map of my body as if he’d been starving for me for years.
But just as he was about to make us truly one, he froze.
He cupped my cheek, his eyes searching mine with a mix of fierce intensity and restraint. "Rosie... tell me, who am I?"
I hooked my arm around his neck, pulling him down until my lips brushed his ear.
"Caleb."
That was all he needed.
He collapsed against me, the moonlight catching our silhouettes as they merged into one.
The hours that followed were nothing short of a revelation.
Caleb was intense, attentive, and devastatingly skilled.
As I lay there, feeling the lingering ache of his prowess, a scandalous thought drifted through my mind: Maybe, just maybe, this substitution was the best decision I’ve ever made...
The silence didn't return until the first gray light of dawn bled through the floor-to-ceiling windows.
The next morning, I was jolted awake by the vibration of Caleb's phone on the nightstand.
"The project manager just called me. You never boarded the flight to Kazakhstan," Nathan’s voice barked through the speaker, tight with fury.
"Caleb! Where the hell are you?"
Caleb rubbed his temples, his voice thick with sleep and dark amusement. "Where do you think I am, Nathan? It’s my wedding night."
"Caleb, this isn't a joke! Get on a plane, now!"
"I’m on a yacht in the Caribbean," Caleb drawled, eyes still closed. "Signal's spotty. We’re losing connection."
I groaned, burying my face in the pillow. "God, tell him to shut up."
The line went dead silent for a heartbeat.
Then, Nathan’s voice dropped, trembling with a sudden, sharp realization.
"Was that... Rosie?"
A pause.
"Is she with you? Did you... did you sleep with her?!!!"
