Chapter 1

We played Truth or Dare around the table, laughter lifting over the low hum of voices.

Caleb was my fiancé. We had five years behind us, and our wedding was nine days away.

Someone spun the empty bottle across the wood.

It skittered, slowed, and came to rest with its neck pointing at Vanessa Brooks.

“Truth,” she said.

Owen and the others called out, “Okay, tell us something about you and Caleb that Audrey doesn't know.”

Vanessa turned her glass, watching the wine shift. She looked at me, then at Caleb, perfectly steady.

“Caleb and I just celebrated our seventh wedding anniversary.”

The laughter stopped. I held her gaze. My voice was tight.

“Don’t joke about this. When did you two get married?”

Rachel, sitting beside Vanessa, answered before she could.

“You weren’t here for it, Audrey. That ceremony was seven years ago. We were all there.”

A chill went straight through me. Caleb said nothing.


No one spoke. The only sound was ice clinking against someone's glass.

Owen broke eye contact first. Vanessa settled against the back of her chair and took a sip as if nothing had happened.

“Audrey, we've all been drinking. It's just a game. Don't make a scene.”

I kept looking at her.

“Your seventh wedding anniversary? What does that mean?”

Caleb set his phone face down on the table, hard, before she could reply.

“Stop. Everyone's had a few. Do you have to cross-examine every little thing anyone says?”

My eyes dropped to my engagement ring.

It had been on my hand for two years.

Our wedding was nine days away.

I'd sat through four dress fittings and rearranged the seating chart three times. I'd made dozens of calls to sort out hotels and rides for the guests flying in from out of state. My gown was hanging in the guest bedroom at home. The designer and I had hand-picked every pearl on its skirt.

And my fiancé was annoyed with me for spoiling everyone's fun by asking about a “wedding anniversary.”

I couldn't believe this was happening. He was the one giving me every reason to be suspicious, and somehow I was the one being made to look childish in front of everyone.

“Then explain the anniversaries,” I said.

She laughed softly. “Oh, that goes way back. Right after college, a bunch of us took a trip to Vegas. We got drunk and did a fake wedding at one of those little chapels, just for the photos. It wasn't a legal marriage. We joke about it every year, and Caleb takes me to dinner. Nothing more.”

She smiled, as if it were nothing at all. “I can't believe seven years have gone by.”

Seven years.

Caleb and I had been together for five.

And every one of those five years, he'd also made time to celebrate a “wedding anniversary” with someone else.

I picked up my bag and left.

He reached me at the doorway and caught my wrist. “If you storm out now, it's going to be awkward for everyone. We're getting married. Can you please act like an adult about this? Vanessa's been my friend for more than ten years. She talks without thinking. Rachel just had a breakup; she's a wreck. Why do you always have to think the worst of people?”

I worked his fingers loose, one at a time.

“Audrey,” Vanessa called from the table.

I looked back.

She held up her glass and smiled at me.

“Caleb loves you. He does. Out of everyone, after all these years, you're the one he's marrying.”

Nobody seemed troubled by what she'd said.

One of them even chimed in to help.

“Exactly. Everybody's got a messy past, Audrey. He's marrying you. That means he knows who he wants to settle down with.”

That was when I finally understood.

As far as these people were concerned, Caleb could ignore every boundary there was, past or present, and it would never count as cheating. And if I was the one standing next to him at the altar, I was supposed to be grateful he'd picked me.

He followed me to the elevators. “Let me drive you home.”

“I'll manage.”

“Audrey. Enough.”

I stepped through the open elevator doors.

He got in behind me, looking grim.

“Your parents are driving down from Maine tomorrow. I'd rather they didn't get to Boston and find us in the middle of a fight.”

I watched the floor numbers count down. My head was pounding.

“Caleb, did you sleep with Vanessa?”

Three seconds passed before he spoke.

“No.When are you going to let this go?”

His phone rang before he'd finished.

Vanessa's name lit up the screen.

He took the call. Whatever she said, his voice went soft at once. “Where did you leave your stomach medication? Sit down. Don't go anywhere. I'll be right there.”

After hanging up, he avoided looking at me. “It's her stomach again.”

“And?”

“Call an Uber. I need to make sure she's okay. Half an hour, then I'll be home.”

At 1:17 a.m., I was home in our apartment, scrolling through my phone, when Vanessa's latest Instagram post popped up.

A steaming bowl of chicken soup filled the frame. At the edge of the shot was a man's hand.

I recognized his watch. I'd bought it for Caleb for our anniversary the year before.

I laid my phone screen-down on the dining table. For the first time, the thought came to me clearly, without a shred of doubt: we didn't have to go through with the wedding in nine days.

Next Chapter