Chapter 3
This wasn't the man Caleb had been when we started dating.
Five years earlier, my dad had a heart attack in the middle of the night and was rushed to the ER. Caleb was away on a work trip in another state. After I called, he drove more than three hours through the dark to get back to me.
At four that morning, he sat beside me in the hospital corridor and draped his jacket around my shoulders. “Audrey, you're not alone. I'm here,” he told me.
I held on to those words for the next five years.
When Dad went into surgery, Caleb took three days off. He helped me deal with the insurance paperwork, picked up prescriptions, and drove my mom to and from the hospital. On the day Dad came home, Caleb took both heavy bags in one hand so he could hold mine with the other.
I had no doubt back then. He was the one I wanted beside me for the rest of my life.
That memory was what I reached for every time he let me down. I'd remember who he used to be, and make excuses for who he'd become.
For one of his birthdays, I reserved a table at his favorite restaurant a full month ahead.
I sat there from early evening until ten. He didn't come.
Vanessa had just been dumped, he said. She was crying in a bar restroom so hard she couldn't get to her feet. “She doesn't have anyone she can really count on,” he told me over the phone. “What if something happens because I don't go?”
I ended up blowing out the birthday candles by myself. Then I boxed up the cake with his name on it and took it home.
Our worst fight ever had been about Vanessa, too.
She'd kissed him while she was drunk.
Nobody told me. I'd driven over to pick Caleb up and caught them in the parking lot. Her arms were looped around his neck, and they were kissing.
The moment he noticed me, he shoved her away as if she'd burned him.
When we got home, he spent two hours explaining. “She was completely blacked out. She didn't know what she was doing. She caught me off guard. You just happened to see it before I could push her away. Audrey, if I wanted her, why would I be dating you?”
I only asked him for one thing. “Can you stay away from her from now on?”
He agreed immediately. “Of course I can.”
The next day, he took me apartment hunting.
In one empty living room, he came up behind me and put his arms around my waist. “Once we have a place of our own, you'll feel more secure. You'll see.”
I forgave him again.
We bought that apartment.
After we moved in, though, Vanessa got a spare key. Rachel had both the garage code and the code for our door. Owen and the rest of them dropped by for drinks whenever they felt like it, without calling first.
I'd come home late from work to find seven or eight people in my living room. One would be wearing my slippers. Another would be using my coffee mug. Takeout containers would be strewn across the dining table I'd wiped down that morning.
Vanessa liked to stretch out on the couch I'd taken two weeks to choose, tuck a cushion against her, and grin at me. “Audrey, I love your couch. It's so comfortable.”
Caleb always jumped in. “What's mine is yours. We're family. You don't need permission to make yourselves at home.”
Everybody laughed.
I stood in the doorway, feeling like I'd walked into someone else's apartment.
I was already worn out by then.
But whenever I came close to losing my temper, I pictured Caleb beside me in that hospital at four in the morning.
He was just too loyal to his friends, I told myself. He couldn't say no to anyone. He needed to learn some boundaries. That didn't mean he didn't love me.
Then, seven days before our wedding, I found the box.
I was searching the study for my passport and birth certificate. We were going to city hall to apply for our marriage license the next day. Tucked at the very back of a drawer was a velvet jewelry box.
I assumed he'd hidden a wedding gift for me.
Inside was a receipt and an appraisal certificate for a diamond tennis bracelet.
I'd seen it before.
Back in February, Vanessa had posted a photo of herself shielding her eyes from the sun. That bracelet had been on her wrist.
I stayed in the study for a long time, holding the open box.
When Caleb got home that night, I put it in front of him.
He glanced at it and frowned. “You've been digging through my things?”
“You bought this for her?”
“I did.”
“For Valentine's Day?”
“She was going through a lot.”
“Where did that leave me?”
He shrugged off his jacket, as if he couldn't understand why this mattered. “You don't need gifts like that. She was posting every day about how she didn't see the point of anything anymore. I got her something to cheer her up. Why are you making this into a big deal?”
“You told me you were going to keep your distance.”
His patience ran out. “How long ago was that? Funny how you remember all this, but never anything good I've done for you.”
I stopped arguing.
He put the box away. At the bedroom doorway, he paused and turned. “Leave Vanessa's wedding seat alone. She asked me today whether you even want her to come.”
I sat on the couch while it slowly got dark outside.
Much later, I texted Molly.
“Could you send me digital copies of all our contracts, payment receipts, and cancellation policies?”
She answered almost at once. “Are we changing the timeline again?”
The folder with my engagement ring's insurance papers sat on the coffee table. I looked at it as I typed my reply.
“Yes. Possibly quite a bit.”
