Chapter 2
For my birthday, Nathan gave me the bouquet and necklace.
The two things I'd already heard him agree to buy.
Shipping had bent the plastic petals. I eased them back into shape as he looked on.
In the cab afterward, he said, "You don't feel like I went cheap on you?"
Stale cigarette smoke clung to the seats. Since getting in, he'd avoided breathing through his nose.
I lowered the window and let the cold air brush my face.
"No. I put the flowers in a vase. With my desk lamp on, they look nice."
I meant it.
He looked over. "I figured you'd be disappointed."
"I'd like to have a good birthday."
He held my hand, stroking my knuckles with his thumb. He kept examining me, as though I might reveal the answer he expected if he looked closely enough.
He didn't believe me. I wasn't giving him anything complicated enough to believe.
I'd once enjoyed evenings like this. A private driver and a fancy dinner weren't what made me want to be with him.
But now I'd heard the jokes. Sitting close to him in a taxi couldn't undo them.
We pulled up to a diner between a laundromat and a closed pawnshop. Finding a place this inexpensive must have taken him more effort than choosing one he wanted to eat in.
I put my hand on his arm.
"Dinner's on me."
"On your birthday?"
"Yes. I'd like to pay."
"No." He sounded insulted. "I promised you dinner."
I let it go.
He paused over the torn vinyl booth before finally sitting down. When our menus arrived, he made sure his arms didn't touch the tabletop.
I glanced toward the kitchen. The pass had a buildup of grease, and the ketchup bottle needed wiping. Nathan was inspecting a dirty streak on his fork.
It still beat our first date.
He'd chosen a food truck next to a muddy parking lot. Raised on meals in private dining rooms, he perched on a folding stool with his shoes lifted away from the dirt.
Smoke drifted off the grill, and he put a hand over his nose.
I'd counted the cash in my wallet.
"We could go somewhere else and share a meal," I'd said. "If you don't like it here."
He'd crossed his arms.
"Here is fine. I was clear about what you could expect from me."
He'd left all his food untouched. Even the bottled water stayed sealed.
At the diner tonight, he cleaned his fork and knife with a napkin, then asked which burger included fries.
He was learning how to play the part.
Our server asked if we had something to celebrate.
Nathan answered before I did. "No. Just eating."
I settled my paper napkin across my lap.
While he was in the restroom washing his hands, she brought pie and another spoon.
"No charge," she told me. "I noticed your flowers."
I thanked her. I hadn't expected that small kindness.
When Nathan came back, he looked at the dessert.
"You asked for pie?"
"She gave it to us."
He loosened up and slid the extra spoon my way.
"You always want the crust. You can have my share."
I wished he hadn't remembered. I wished remembering didn't still make me happy.
I took my time eating. It was hard to understand how I could resent him and feel pleased in the same unremarkable evening.
With my chin propped in my palm, I watched him.
Before, I would have thought getting used to something meant it was where he belonged.
