Chapter 2

As soon as the words left my mouth, Aunt Linda stopped crying. 

Aunt Susan who'd been comforting her fell silent.

The other relatives cut their gossip short. 

Even my dad looked up from his phone. 

Everyone just stared at me. 

It was like I had just dropped a bomb right in the middle of the family gathering.

After a few seconds of dead silence, Aunt Linda burst into a huge smile.

Her tears vanished instantly. She reached across the table and grabbed my hand, looking absolutely thrilled. 

"Oh, sweetie! I knew you'd finally understand!" she said, her voice dripping with relief.

"Looks and money? That stuff really doesn't matter in the long run. As long as a man is hardworking and treats you right, that's everything."

I nodded, playing the part of the perfect, obedient niece. 

My sudden compliance earned a few mocking shakes of the head from the relatives around us.

But the tension was broken. The Thanksgiving dinner went back to being loud and messy. 

By nine-thirty, the pumpkin pie was gone, and the gathering finally wrapped up.

Everyone said their goodbyes and headed out to their cars. 

On the drive home, my phone buzzed in my purse. 

It was a new friend request on Facebook. 

Before I could even process it, a message from Aunt Linda popped up on my screen. 

"I gave Gary your profile! You two have a good chat. I can't wait to see you guys walk down the aisle!"

So, this was Gary Thompson. 

I clicked on the friend request and stared at his profile. 

His profile picture was a low-quality, blurry photo of a bald eagle. 

His bio just said "Lone Wolf." 

Honestly, it looked exactly like the kind of boomer profile my dad would have, just with slightly more aggressive energy. 

I hit "Accept." 

Almost instantly, a message came through on Messenger. 

"Evening, little lady. It's Gary."

I stared at the screen. 

Little lady? 

My stomach did a slow, uncomfortable flip.

I forced down the nausea and typed a polite reply. 

"Hello, I'm Emily. Are you free tomorrow? We should meet up."

A voice memo popped up in response. 

I dug my earbuds out of my purse, plugged them in, and hit play.

A deep, raspy voice filled my ears.

He was trying way too hard to sound smooth and seductive. 

"When a pretty girl asks, how could I say no? Go ahead and admit it, you couldn't resist my charm."

Two sentences. 

It sounded like a guy who had been smoking a pack a day for forty years was trying to whisper with a throat full of gravel. 

Goosebumps erupted all over my arms. 

Suddenly, I felt the intense urge to douse my phone in hand sanitizer. 

I quickly typed back. 

"Let's meet tomorrow at 2:30 PM. The Java Hub on Main Street."

A few seconds later, Gary sent another voice memo. 

There was no way I was listening to that.

I just clicked the auto-transcript button. 

"Thinking about seeing you tomorrow... I won't be getting any sleep tonight."

Gag.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter