Chapter 2

"What did you say?"

James let out a short laugh, he stared at me like he couldn't believe his ears.

"Abby, are you seriously still being petty about the ring? Sloane said she was sorry. It got stuck. It happens."

No. It wasn't the ring.

The ring was just the latest thing. I'd gotten used to losing things a long time ago.

When we were kids, Sloane was always taking credit for what I'd done.

If I won the essay contest, it was because she'd let me. If I got good grades, it was because she'd taught me. And every time, I told myself it didn't matter. That's what best friends did.

When we got older, every time I reached for James's hand, Sloane happened to drag him away. A photo she needed him for. A story she had to tell him. My hand would be left hanging there, and my hopes would fall flat all over again.

James would just smile and ruffle my hair. "Abby, we're all just messing around."

He always said it so easily, like that was the whole explanation and I was supposed to accept it.

But I didn't want to be the one they messed with anymore.

I didn't say anything. I just looked at him, long enough that he shifted his weight and glanced away.

"If it bothered you that much, you should've said so," he said. "I'll buy you another one. A better one. Why'd you have to act like you didn't care in front of Sloane?"

He let out a breath, like I was the one making this difficult.

"Abby, I'll give you some time to cool off. Until your episode passes. But don't forget, the wedding's in three days. Think about it. Don't do something you'll regret."

He shot me a warning look and walked out.

I stood there in the mess on the floor and started to laugh, quietly at first. He was still talking about the ring. Then louder, until my voice cracked, until I was laughing so hard I was crying.

I kept going until the sun came up. By then, I was calm again.

After that, I was a different person. I didn't cry. I didn't argue with myself. I just started doing things, one after another.

At every meal, James had always made a point of having a hair tie ready for me. It was a small thing, and I'd loved it. The one I'd kept was worn out by now, but I'd taken good care of it.

I threw it away without feeling a thing.

The only photo of the two of us was at the very back of a drawer, where I kept the things I treasured most. I tore it in half, then in half again, without hesitating.

It took me two hours to pack my bags. Two hours to wrap up eight years of us.

I was heading out the door with my suitcase when my phone rang.

"Ms. Hale? Sorry to bother you. I'm calling to confirm something about your gown. Would you like us to change the measurements?"

I wasn't sure I'd heard right. "What do you mean?"

"A Ms. Marlowe came in a little while ago and gave us a new set of measurements. She asked us to alter the gown to match them. We always confirm with the bride, so I'm just checking."

"Your wedding is in two days, and we only have time for one round of alterations. So whatever we do now is final."

At that very moment, a new message lit up James's laptop. I stopped and read it.

Sloane: Okay, who wants to guess what Abby's face is gonna look like at the wedding when she can't fit into the dress? It's gonna be so good 😂

Graham: She'll just cry. Can't be taken anywhere.

Miles sent a smirking emoji.

Miles: I'd rather see her face when she finds out it fits Sloane perfectly.

Miles: Honestly, the dress and the ring are both Sloane's size anyway. Once Abby storms off, you two should just keep the wedding going. She can't blame us. She's the one who ran out on it.

James typed just two words.

James: Can't wait.

I stared at those two words. Not a joke, not an emoji. Just two words, typed like he meant them.

They hurt more than everything else in that chat put together. More than Sloane laughing. More than Graham's one-liner. More than Miles's plan.

Marrying him was a future we'd dreamed up back when we first got together. He used to hold my hand as we walked down the street, and he'd tell me what we'd look like when we were old and gray. He said we'd still be exactly the same. I'd believed him.

And now? What was he looking forward to?

Me storming off, running out on the wedding, so he could laugh at me?

Or walking down the aisle with Sloane?

I didn't know. I didn't even know which one would be worse.

And I didn't want to keep agonizing over it anymore.

"Go with the new measurements," I said evenly.

"Are you sure, Ms. Hale?"

"I'm sure."

I wasn't going to be anybody's joke at that wedding.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter