Chapter 1

My boyfriend moved me to the edge of our yearbook photo and pulled Audrey beside him.

“We’re the valedictorian and salutatorian. It makes sense.”

When the photographer asked if they were dating, Nathan smiled at her.

“We just get each other.”

I’d spent all night choosing my dress.

He hadn’t even saved me a place.


At the yearbook photo shoot, the photographer grinned and waved the couples closer together.

Nathan put a hand on my shoulder and moved me all the way to the end of the group. Then he drew Audrey into the space beside him.

“We're the valedictorian and salutatorian,” he said. “Putting us next to each other makes sense. It'll work better on the yearbook page.”

He'd shut me out before.

When I asked him about problems I'd missed in AP Calculus, he gave the page a passing look and told me I needed to learn the basics before wasting his time.

Audrey was second in our class. Yet when she pretended to struggle with elementary algebra, he never questioned it.

He stayed on FaceTime with her until two a.m., walking her through the solution one patient step at a time.

If I suggested studying together at the library, he frowned. Apparently, I kept him from concentrating.

But let Audrey lose two points on a quiz, and he'd blow off track practice to take her to the beach until she felt better.

Just before taking the picture, the photographer teased them. “You two dating? I could see you winning prom king and queen.”

Nathan turned toward Audrey with an affectionate, proud smile. “We just get each other.”

She lowered her face, blushing, while his teammates whistled and cheered.

I stood apart from them, clutching my phone until my knuckles whitened. The camera app I'd opened while I waited had long since closed itself.

In the blank screen, I could see the dress I'd spent last night choosing and the curls I'd kept redoing until they were right.

I felt like such an idiot.

He'd never been saving that place for me.

And I didn't want it now.


I tucked my phone into my pocket and walked away from the laughter on the lawn.

Inside the school, our college counselor, Mr. Miller, gave me my final transcript and patted my shoulder.

“You kept your GPA up, Claire. Take this home and go over your college choices carefully.”

He hesitated before continuing in a more serious voice.

“I know you wanted a school near Nathan in Boston. But limiting yourself to that area isn't doing you any favors. The schools you've been aiming for are competitive, and your options elsewhere are stronger. Don't make this decision around somebody else's future.”

Holding the transcript against me, I thanked him.

Nathan and Audrey were right outside his office. Both stopped when they saw me.

Audrey came forward first, all warmth and smiles. “There you are.”

She offered me a drink. “We stopped for coffee. Nathan told me to get you something too.”

I looked at the cups in their hands. Two iced coffees, labeled in black marker with “Nate & Aud” and a big smiley face.

The cup she held out to me was pink. A Strawberry Frappuccino.

Strawberries could put me into anaphylactic shock. My allergy was that severe, and Nathan knew it.

I managed a smile, accepted the cup, and dropped it hard into the hallway trash can without saying anything.

It landed with a thump. Pink liquid spattered, and every conversation nearby stopped.

Audrey's smile vanished. Tears filled her eyes as she turned to Nathan, looking bewildered.

He frowned at once. “Claire, what's wrong with you?”

There was a warning in his cold voice.

“Is this about the picture? I decided where we stood. Don't punish Audrey for it.”

“I explained this already. The valedictorian and salutatorian needed to be together for the layout.”

“And I said we'd take pictures of our own afterward. Didn't I?”

I stared at him. I couldn't find the energy to fight.

He'd promised me pictures afterward, but my Instagram feed had spent the past hour filling up with classmates' Stories.

There he was in their videos, holding Audrey around the waist for group shots. Then he was taking her to the café on the corner. Now they were collecting their transcripts together.

An entire hour, and not one message to me. He'd forgotten I was waiting.

Things had started changing after Audrey transferred in. Once their names appeared together at the top of the class rankings, my ordinariness seemed to irritate him more every day.

Lately, he could hardly look at me without showing it.

I should have understood sooner. Whatever Nathan and I had been, it was over.

My silence wore through the last of his patience.

“Fine. We'll take it right now. Will that make you happy?”

He took my phone before I could answer and handed it to Audrey.

Then he stood beside me, leaving a conspicuous space between us.

I didn't change my expression. He barely faced the camera before turning away again, taking the phone from Audrey, and pressing it back into my hand.

“There. Can you stop now?” he asked, plainly annoyed. “Wait here. I'll help Audrey get her transcript, and then we can leave.”

He opened the office door and guided her inside.

Alone in the hallway, I checked my photos.

The latest one was a blur. There was nothing but pale gray tile and the swinging edge of his jacket as he walked off.

For a second, I looked at it. Then a small smile came to my face.

I deleted the picture and emptied the Recently Deleted folder.

Next came his contact. I blocked his number, with no intention of undoing it.

I folded the transcript and put it safely in my backpack.

Outside the school's heavy glass doors, I slipped my hands into my pockets and kept walking.

Not once did I turn around.

I wasn't waiting for him anymore.

Next Chapter