Chapter 2

I'd imagined blocking Nathan would be enough to remove him from my life.

That was a ridiculous hope with graduation underway and all of us moving through the same high school circle.

An hour later, I made myself go to our usual diner. My friends had planned a senior dinner, and I didn't want to spoil it for them.

I slid into the very back corner of a booth. For once, I thought, I'd found somewhere he couldn't get to me.

We were halfway through dinner when one of the girls stared at her phone and gasped, almost sending her Coke over.

“Oh my God. Did Audrey just make it official?”

She flipped the screen toward us and pushed her phone into the middle of the table.

Audrey's new Snapchat Story showed two movie tickets. Above them, she'd written one word: [Official.]

A boy's wrist appeared along one edge of the picture.

He was wearing a black scrunchie.

My eyes burned as I looked at it. I wasn't hoping for him anymore. I was thinking of the girl I'd been, begging him to do one small thing for her.

Some guys at our school wore their girlfriends' scrunchies. A little public sign that they were taken.

I'd asked Nathan over and over to wear mine. I told him it would make our relationship feel more real. Every time, he dismissed it as childish and refused.

Recently, though, he'd begun wearing one.

I'd been quietly delighted. I thought he'd finally changed his mind.

Looking at the photo now, I couldn't believe I'd let myself think that.

Around me, the girls leaned toward the phone, eager for details.

“That's a hard launch, isn't it? Who is he? Someone from school?”

“She's always with Nathan. I honestly thought they were already together.”

I answered without raising my voice.

“It's Nathan.”

They paused, then all looked at me.

“Claire, are you crying?”

I picked up a sauce-covered Buffalo wing and took a bite, keeping my eyes on my plate.

“The hot sauce got me.”

The door opened almost as soon as I said it.

Nathan entered first, with Audrey following. Her Goyard tote was over his shoulder, and he held her varsity jacket as casually as if it belonged to him.

Seats stood empty by the entrance. He looked past them, spotted our booth, and came directly over to squeeze in beside me.

A server approached to take their order.

Audrey studied the menu with a sweet smile. “The sampler's a better value. Why don't we get that?”

The teasing started immediately.

“Come on, Nathan, admit it. We knew something was happening with you two.”

He smiled easily. “Good thing we got here, then. There's enough for everybody.”

He was so comfortable, so completely untroubled, that I almost felt I'd invented the tension between us myself.

Our classmates weren't letting the question go.

“So are you and Audrey actually dating?”

He glanced at the Story and chuckled.

“That post? She was kidding. It just meant our movie plans were official.”

Settling back, he looked past the others at me. His expression was faintly amused. “You didn't fall for it, did you?”

Audrey flushed and looked down. She didn't correct him.

The conversation grew louder. I couldn't join it. I was staring at the trace of glossy shimmer on his lips.

He didn't wear lip gloss.

Under the table, he reached for my fingers with the same familiar ease he used to have.

I pulled my hand away.

He stopped, his hand suspended between us. Then his expression hardened.

He withdrew it and shifted toward Audrey instead, close enough for their arms to touch.

She gave him an even brighter smile.

For the rest of dinner, everything anyone said seemed to come back to them.

Somebody joked about the two brilliant students going to Boston and becoming an Ivy League power couple. Apparently their future was settled already.

I stayed wedged in the corner, doing little more than occupying space.

I wanted to go, but Nathan had the aisle seat. There was no way out without getting past him.

I stared at my fries while cramps rolled through my stomach.

When their food arrived, Audrey complained that her hair kept getting in the way.

Nathan slid the black scrunchie from his wrist without a word. He gathered her hair and tied it back for her.

His hands moved with an ease that made me feel sick. He'd clearly done this before.

Watching him, I remembered all the times I'd asked.

“Claire, don't waste my time with childish stuff,” he'd told me.

Audrey lifted the ice-filled Coke for a drink. Before she could sip it, Nathan frowned and took it away.

“You took two Midols half an hour ago. You told me cold soda makes your stomach feel worse.”

For a beat, everyone stared. Then the booth erupted.

“He even keeps track of when you take your meds!”

“Sure, there's absolutely nothing going on.”

Audrey went scarlet and gave his shoulder a light swat.

Nathan laughed with the others, then glanced at me as though he'd just remembered I was there.

“You're flushed. Was the sauce too hot?”

He slid Audrey's cold Coke toward me. Water ran down the glass and left a wet streak across the tabletop.

“Here. This should help.”

I looked at the ice floating in it and tried to smile.

I couldn't decide whether I wanted to laugh or cry.

My period had started that morning too.

I'd suffered awful cramps for years. They left me chilled all over, and an icy drink only made me feel worse.

Nathan used to know that.

He'd kept reminders on his phone and bought pain medicine in advance to carry in his bag. He'd never once forgotten.

Until now.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter