Chapter 3

Droplets gathered on the glass while another cramp tightened low in my stomach.

I left the Coke untouched. With a stiff hand, I slowly pushed it back across the table.

The rejection was impossible to miss. Conversation faltered, and Nathan frowned.

“Claire, are you going to do this all night?”

I shook my head and swallowed the sob pressing at my throat.

I wouldn't break down in front of everybody. I couldn't sit here watching him take care of another girl either.

“Move. I need to get out,” I said to the tabletop.

“What?”

“Let me out. I'm sick. I want to go home.” I picked up my bag and forced myself to rise from the corner.

Nathan stayed planted in the aisle seat.

Instead of moving, he set the Coke down with a hard thump. His face was cold.

Audrey's smile disappeared. She looked uncomfortable now, almost embarrassed.

She caught her lower lip between her teeth and glanced at me. “Is this my fault? Is Claire upset that I'm here?”

“Leave her alone,” Nathan told her, cutting in before she could say more. “She's being a drama queen. Turning nothing into a scene and wrecking everyone's evening.”

The students around us exchanged uncertain looks. Nobody seemed to know what to say.

I put a hand over my eyes. I didn't want them watching me anymore.

Without waiting for permission, I squeezed through the small gap between his legs and the table.

My shin bumped his knee. He muttered a curse and started to reach for my arm.

I moved before he could catch me.

I pushed a chair out of my way and hurried out of the noisy diner without looking back.

Drama queen.

The sneer in those words hurt almost as much as being struck.

Once, the smallest frown from me had sent him searching his bag for medicine.

Tonight I could barely straighten up, and he'd treated my pain as entertainment.

We'd known each other for ten years. When someone stops caring after all that time, apparently they don't even have to say goodbye.

I cried on the walk home, letting the cool air blow against my face until my eyes were swollen and my throat hurt.

Mom was watching television on the couch when I came through the door. She muted it as soon as she saw me.

“Did you and Nathan fight again?”

“He just texted me. Wanted to know why you blocked his number.”

For a moment, I didn't answer.

I almost laughed. It had taken him until the end of the day to realize he couldn't reach me.

“What else did he say?” My voice was rough.

“Just that I should make sure your college plans are on track. He said not to forget the schools around Boston when you make your final choice.”

Then she went on, in the familiar way she always did.

“He's a nice boy, Claire. You've grown up together. He's always taken care of you.”

“It's a shame your grades aren't stronger, and you've never been one of the popular girls. I suppose I understand why he doesn't think of you romantically. Otherwise, I'd love to see you two together.”

I looked down and stayed quiet.

She hadn't noticed anything amiss. “We can't really help with essays and applications, you know. You should have asked Nathan. He's good at that sort of thing.”

“I heard he pulled several all-nighters helping his girlfriend with her Harvard essay back during application season. Dating doesn't seem to distract those two from anything.”

I curled my fingers into my palms. My chest tightened.

“I took cookies to his family yesterday,” Mom continued. “The printed drafts were still on his desk. He'd written notes and corrections all over them.”

“He told Audrey he'd made every sentence perfect. With her record, he didn't want a single detail letting her down.”

I stood there, unable to move. Drawing a breath hurt.

Nathan and I had promised years ago that we'd go to college together in Boston.

But the schools I wanted there were a reach. Even a public university in the area hadn't been a sure thing with my grades.

When my SAT results came in, I'd jokingly asked him to read my personal statement.

He'd kept scrolling on his phone instead of looking at me.

“I don't know much about applications to those schools. Your score's barely competitive for the public ones you're looking at. Just find something outside Boston.”

“Your major probably won't make much difference anyway.”

At the time, I'd explained it away for him.

Of course someone like Nathan cared only about the most demanding programs at elite universities. Why would he know about applying anywhere ordinary?

I couldn't make that excuse anymore.

Mom remembered something else. “Oh, your counselor called today. He says you've been narrowing your choices too much with those Boston schools. He asked me to talk to you, so—”

I interrupted her.

“I'm not going to Boston.”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter