Chapter 4
Mom stared at me. “You're not? But you and Nathan agreed—”
I gave her a small, reassuring smile before she could finish.
“Mr. Miller talked to me a while ago. I applied to CU Boulder without making a big deal about it, and I've confirmed my place.”
I was surprised by how level my voice sounded. “My record wasn't strong for the Boston schools on that list. But it was a good fit for the programs I wanted in Colorado.”
I left her standing there and went to my room.
As soon as the door closed, I slid down against it and landed on the carpet.
Colorado and its mountains were almost two thousand miles from Boston.
I wouldn't have to keep following Nathan, watching him walk ahead as if I wasn't there.
A few weeks earlier, when the acceptance email arrived, Mom had stared at “Congratulations” on my screen with trembling hands.
“Claire, you got into a great public university!”
She'd reached for her iPhone to tell our relatives on Facebook. I covered the screen before she could post.
“Not yet.” I kept my eyes down. “Can we wait until I'm there? Until the semester starts?”
Now she knew I intended to go.
For several days after that conversation, I hardly went outside.
Mom could tell how unhappy I was. She kept suggesting an early campus visit, something to get my mind away from home.
Before summer was over, I finally agreed. I packed a bag and headed for the airport.
I hadn't expected to see Nathan and Audrey in the terminal.
Their casual clothes matched. From across the concourse, they looked like a couple leaving on a long vacation.
Nathan spotted me coming toward them with my suitcase. For an instant, he looked pleased.
Then his face tightened. “What are you doing here? I thought you weren't speaking to me.”
I stopped. Suddenly I remembered the trip he'd planned before AP exams, when he'd wanted to give me something to look forward to.
After the tests, he'd said, we'd go to Miami.
Today was the departure date.
Audrey bit her lip and gave me an apologetic little smile. She stepped back.
“If Claire's coming, she can have my place. I'll stay.”
Nathan frowned and pulled her beside him again. “Of course you're coming. You've worked on this trip for days. All that research and planning—you don't have to give it up.”
I felt a sick twist of bitterness.
He was defending the effort she'd supposedly made. The itinerary in their hands was the one I'd stayed up for nights putting together on TripAdvisor after exams.
I started to tell him not to bother. He was already looking up flights on his phone, his expression closed off.
That left Audrey and me facing each other in silence.
Her sweet expression faded. “You should understand this, Claire. There are gaps you can't close just by trying harder.”
“He needs someone who belongs beside him at an Ivy League school. Not somebody he has to drag along.”
She tucked her hair back, smiling smugly. “After prom, I asked him if he'd try dating me for real. Do you want to know what he said?”
My nails dug into my palm until the skin broke. I made myself keep looking at her calmly.
“If you want him that much, you can have him.”
Her practiced sweetness faltered. She pressed her teeth into her lip.
Nathan went to the airline's service desk, then returned and dropped a printed itinerary in front of me.
“There wasn't much left at the last minute. This is a red-eye in six hours, with a connection overnight.”
“Audrey's back hurts if she sits too long, so I paid to put her in first class on our flight. You can take this one.” He looked me over before adding, “Seems about right for your grades. Get used to the real world. You can sit in economy.”
He checked his Rolex and steered her impatiently toward the priority security line.
“We're going to the lounge. See you in Miami.”
Audrey glanced back at me with a triumphant smile.
I looked at the thin sheet he'd left in my hand.
He'd never checked the reservation I already had. My own ticket wasn't for Miami at all.
It was a one-way flight to Denver. I was going to Colorado for an early orientation session.
I balled up the useless itinerary and threw it in the nearest bin.
Then I went to catch the flight I'd chosen for myself.
A few days later, orientation ended and I flew home. Before going to the house, I collected the mail that had been held for me while I was away.
I had barely climbed out of the Uber and reached our front yard when Nathan stepped into my path.
He marched up, furious, and seized my wrist hard enough to hurt.
“Where's Audrey's acceptance packet?”
I winced. “What packet?”
He gave a short, contemptuous laugh.
“Don't act like you don't know.”
“Her mailbox is broken. She had Harvard send it to my house so it wouldn't get lost. Tracking says it arrived days ago, but it isn't there.”
“You never came to Miami. You've been hiding here the whole time. Who else would have taken it? If you're angry with me, then be angry with me. You don't get to ruin her future.”
I stared at him, hardly recognizing the boy in front of me.
Audrey got out of his car behind him. Her eyes were puffy and red.
“Claire, if this is because I got too close to Nathan, I'll apologize in front of everyone at school.”
She choked on the words, looking utterly hurt. “I'll leave him alone in Boston. I promise.”
“Just please give me my Harvard packet. I worked so hard for it. It's my whole future.”
I was trembling with anger. Tears burned in my eyes. “I haven't taken anything.”
“I just flew back. I came straight here.”
Nathan didn't seem to hear me.
He noticed the thick envelope in my arms instead—my own acceptance package from CU Boulder.
He snatched it away.
I lunged after it, terrified. “Nathan, stop! That's mine. Give it back.”
He held it over my head, far beyond my reach. Looking down at me, he made his threat without a trace of uncertainty.
“I'm counting down from three. Give me Audrey's package, or I'm tearing this garbage up.”
I grabbed at his arm. “I didn't touch it. Please listen.”
“Three.”
“I've been at the airport. In a car. Check the doorbell footage—ask my mother!”
“Two.”
“Nathan, please. Give it to me—”
He didn't hesitate.
“One.”
Paper ripped. He opened the envelope and pulled out the embossed acceptance letter.
Then he took it in both hands and tore it apart.
Pieces of the gold-foil letterhead and welcome card drifted down around my dusty shoes.
I couldn't move. I could only stare at the scraps on the ground.
For a moment, I felt nothing at all. I couldn't even cry.
Nathan drew breath, apparently ready to say more.
A hesitant voice interrupted from behind him.
“Nathan? Sorry, but is this what you're looking for?”
