Chapter 2

On the third day of Evan's week as substitute husband, the Whitmores suddenly arranged a family dinner. Claire's mother, Patricia Ellis, sent me the time and told me to bring the Whitmore signet ring. In their family, that ring marked a man's place as a son-in-law.

Patricia had given it to me herself when Claire and I married. Even then, I knew she considered me beneath them. Without Claire's insistence, I'd never have been given that token of belonging.

I remembered my first visit to the Whitmore estate. In front of the entire family, Patricia announced that someone from my background wasn't a suitable match.

Claire held my hand. Her voice was steady. “Nathan's the man I love. I'll marry the person I choose. That's not a decision anyone else gets to make for me.”

Thinking about it now left a bitter taste. I held the ring box tighter. After dinner, I would give the ring back for good.

When I arrived, Evan was already in my usual chair. Nobody had left a place for me. A housekeeper found another chair and squeezed it in at the far end of the table.

Patricia smiled. “Evan's filling in as Claire's husband this week. We might as well include him at dinner. You're a grown man, Nathan. Don't make a fuss over something so small.”

Claire had even asked the kitchen staff to change the menu to suit him.

I had a serious peanut allergy. After seven years of marriage, the family still put peanut brittle on the dinner table. At first Claire would remind them about my allergy. Eventually she only told me not to eat it.

Evan, meanwhile, disliked cilantro. That was enough to get it banned from every dish. If Claire saw a single fleck in his soup, she sent the bowl back and asked for a fresh one.

“Even the smell makes Evan sick.”

At last year's dinner, they'd given him my chair for the first time. I'd walked out. Claire followed, telling me a seating arrangement meant nothing.

“That place will always be yours, Nathan.”

This year, there wasn't even room for me beside her.

Before the family photo, Patricia looked at my right hand. “Let Evan wear the ring for a minute. Claire's husband should have it on in the picture.”

“I couldn't possibly,” Evan said. He was already reaching for it, his attention fixed on the ring.

Before I could respond, Claire caught my hand and worked it off my finger. It scraped my knuckle raw. She didn't notice; she was inspecting the engraved face for scratches.

She slid it onto Evan's right index finger herself.

“You'll get it back after the seven days, Nathan. It's a ring. There's no reason to turn this into a scene.”

Evan stood beside her for the photo. Her father, Richard Whitmore, sat in front with Patricia. They placed me at the outer edge, barely inside the frame.

The photographer asked us to close the gaps. Claire linked her arm through Evan's, then glanced back at me. Once again, she seemed to be waiting for me to object.

I addressed her mother instead. “He can keep it.”

Patricia's expression changed. “We were having a little fun, and now you've spoiled it. You shouldn't embarrass your family like that, Nathan.”

A relative who hadn't heard about the arrangement soon shared the picture in the family chat.

“We finally got everyone in one photo this year!”

Replies poured in about what a lovely couple Claire and Evan made. Several relatives asked whether wedding plans were underway.

Patricia didn't correct a single one. She added a heart reaction.

I'd been in that group for seven years. I looked at the screen for a moment, then tapped “Leave Group.”

Claire noticed almost immediately.

“You're really selling it this time,” she texted. “How many more days do you think you can keep this going, Nathan?”

She still didn't understand.

I wasn't pretending. I was removing myself from the Whitmore family, one connection at a time.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter