Chapter 1

On the day my husband was promoted, a stranger AirDropped me a Live Photo.

His hands were on his ex-girlfriend’s waist. Her fingers were in his hair.

He called it treatment.

I didn’t argue.

If Nathan wanted to keep his first love, that was his choice.

He wasn’t the only one who had one.


On the day Nathan was promoted to senior attending, an AirDrop notification appeared on my phone from someone I didn't recognize.

The file was a Live Photo.

In a treatment room at the rehabilitation clinic, the hands that had once put a wedding band on me were wrapped around his ex-girlfriend's waist.

He held her gaze for a long moment, then leaned his weight into her.

The little moving image played again. Her fingers threaded through his hair. Her eyes closed, and a quiet gasp escaped her.

I didn't take a screenshot or send him a furious text asking what the hell I was looking at.

I turned my phone over on the table.

He came home late that night, smelling of orange-blossom massage oil, and woke me.

“Babe, that trigger point was hard to reach. I needed a particular angle to put pressure on it. The camera just made it look strange.”

I drew the covers up over my chest.

“Okay. Get some rest. You've still got her pelvic floor therapy tomorrow.”

He looked taken aback. “You're not upset?”

I shook my head.

If he wanted to hang on to his first love, fine.

He wasn't the only one who had one.

Nathan settled beside me on the mattress, drying his newly washed hands with a towel.

Those same hands had been holding Vanessa's hips in the photo. His forehead had nearly touched her shoulder. Whatever he called that treatment, the position was far more intimate than it needed to be.

They looked like two people holding each other.

I had recognized the sender afterward: a resident in the rehabilitation department. We'd joined the hospital around the same time, and she still worked with him.

She'd sent only a short message.

“Claire, I don't want to cause trouble, but Dr. Mercer has done this every day for six months.”

Nathan moved closer and tried to smooth my hair.

“Claire, Vanessa's old back injury isn't straightforward. An ordinary massage won't reach the tissue that's bothering her. I have to work close to her for the myofascial release.”

“She's a patient. That's all this is.”

I turned my head before his hand reached me and looked up at the ceiling. “Sure.”

“Rehearsals have been rough on her lately. Her back keeps going into spasm. I don't trust anyone else to get it right.”

“Sure.”

“You know how good I am at this. Nobody does it better.”

At last, I faced him. I managed a small smile.

“Of course, Dr. Mercer. Always putting the patient first.”

He stopped talking for a moment. Then he looked as though I'd accused him of something.

“Do you still have feelings for her?” I asked.

“We broke up a long time ago. We're barely more than friends now.”

I let that sit between us.

I knew how much of his life that supposedly finished relationship still occupied.

Vanessa had returned to the United States two years earlier. Since then, there had always been a reason for her to need him: a strained muscle at rehearsal, an old injury acting up, a sleepless night that apparently required him to drive over and massage her.

At eleven on the night we got married at the courthouse, she'd sent a text.

“Nathan, I know tonight is special for you and Claire, but my back just seized up. It hurts so badly. I'm sorry to bother you. I didn't know who else to ask.”

He'd barely taken off his jacket before he read it and started putting his shoes back on.

I caught his arm. “Can't it wait until tomorrow?”

“She's by herself at her apartment. There's no one there to help her.”

I sat down on the bed and stared at my lap.

He bent over and tucked the blanket around me.

“I won't be long. We have our wedding pictures in the morning, remember?”

It was three in the morning when he finally returned.

There was a trace of orange-blossom oil on his collar. He said it had gotten there while he was putting a warm compress on her back.

I didn't shout. I didn't cry.

I remembered the date.

Any time I mentioned Vanessa, he gave me the same answer: “I'm her doctor. Taking care of her is my responsibility.”

If she sounded helpless, he grew gentler. If she asked for something outrageous, he found it harder to refuse.

Our friends talked about them as if their breakup were merely a technicality.

I was the wife, but somehow I was the one watching their love story from the sidelines.

Nathan started to speak again. His phone vibrated on the bedside table before he could get the words out.

I wasn't trying to read it. The message simply lit up in front of me.

Vanessa: “Are you still awake? Everywhere you touched me feels warm. I'm so nervous about tomorrow's performance…”

He saw the notification. Something changed in his face, and he muted the phone.

“She's probably anxious about the show.”

I closed my eyes. “You should answer. If she doesn't sleep, she'll have a terrible rehearsal tomorrow.”

He left it alone. Instead, he flipped the phone over and put his arms around me.

“You're reading too much into it. That part of my life is over.”

I kept my hands where they were.

Then a sudden cramp caught low in my belly. It was sharp enough to make me frown, a twisting pain that seemed to start deep inside.

I said nothing.

Next Chapter