Mara's POV
In our family, Elise got first choice. Nobody even questioned it.
The last piece of cake, the only toy, a new dress—it all belonged to her.
“You're her big sister,” Mom and Dad always said. “Set an example. Let her have it.”
They brought the same attitude to my relationship with Julian. Once we were dating, my parents still expected us to take Elise along when we went out to dinner. I couldn't say when he started looking at her a little too long, or when he began tilting his phone away every time a message arrived.
But there was no mistaking what I saw on my parents' balcony. They were kissing. I was furious enough to slap both of them.
Elise wasted no time afterward. She got together with someone she'd known in college, and within weeks they'd married.
Julian got on his knees and begged me to stay. We'd been together five years. I couldn't bear to give that up, so I ignored what he'd done and let him back into my life. I was a fool.
As soon as Elise's marriage fell apart, everyone rushed to make her happy again. Mom was willing to use a kidney donation to force me to give up Julian for her favorite daughter.
And now we stood outside Fletcher's. Mom's hand was still raised, and my cheek still burned where she'd hit me.
I laughed bitterly. “Have you ever counted, Mom? How many times have you slapped me because of her?”
“You won't let her be happy!” she shot back. “He's only a man, Mari. Why do you have to fight your sister over him?”
On that one point, she was right. He was just a man, and I'd wasted years on him.
“I'm not fighting her for anything. You can relax,” I said. “I've got a husband of my own.”
Mom stared as if I were talking nonsense. She didn't believe me, and I no longer cared. I'd finished explaining myself.
I'd learned earlier that day that Adrian's aunt was in the hospital. After leaving the mall, with Adrian and Josie still making their way through airport traffic, I stopped for flowers and a box of pastries. I wanted to get there early and sit with her.
I came out of the hospital elevator carrying the bouquet and bakery box. Julian was right there, walking Elise out of an examination room.
The hard look he'd worn at the mall disappeared. He noticed what I was holding and smiled smugly.
“Ready to say you're sorry at last?” He approached me. “You know Ellie doesn't like lilies. She likes peonies.” Then he frowned at the box. “And she's been sick all morning. Don't give her chocolate croissants or cinnamon scones.”
I looked from him to my sister. They really thought I'd brought all this for her.
Elise adopted her patient, forgiving expression without a moment's hesitation.
“It's all right, Mari,” she said, taking my hand and looking earnestly into my eyes. “If you understand what you did wrong, I can let it go.”
She tightened her grip on my fingers.
“Julian and I have worked something out. After the baby is born, you can have it. You and Julian can raise it together, and I'll visit on weekends. Then people won't talk about you not being able to have children anymore.”
I raised an eyebrow. Somehow, they'd managed to become even more absurd.
Julian straightened, pleased with the offer. “See how much Ellie thinks about you, Mara? You ought to be grateful. Maybe even a little ashamed. You weren't careful, and we lost our baby. The doctor said you probably wouldn't get pregnant again. This takes care of the whole problem.”
My hands started shaking.
That was enough. I threw the flowers and the pastry box straight into his face.
“Do you have any conscience at all?” I yelled. “You left me beside a highway in a flash flood, Julian! You drove off to save her. If you hadn't, my daughter would still be alive!”
Saying it brought back everything. I still woke up in the middle of the night crying for the little girl I'd never held.
We'd been so careful about trying for a baby. Julian stopped smoking. I stopped drinking coffee, watched what I ate, and made sure I got enough sleep. Finally, I was pregnant.
Then came our second wedding anniversary. Elise called in hysterics, saying her husband was mistreating her and threatening to throw her out.
Julian made his choice immediately. In the middle of that downpour, he stopped the car, made me get out on the gravel shoulder, and told me to order an Uber. No driver was going to come for me in weather like that.
A stranger eventually stopped and took me to the emergency room. By then, I was drenched and running a high fever. They couldn't save my baby.
When Julian finally arrived, there were no tears. He stood beside my bed and frowned.
“I had to make sure Ellie was safe. I'd do the same thing again,” he'd said. “We'll have another baby, Mari. Don't blame your sister.”
