The One He Chose

Ethan had always been the golden boy nobody could quite reach. Around other people, he kept a careful distance from me. He barely let his eyes rest on my face.

At home, though, he could be so gentle.

He remembered how bad my cramps got and made me something warm to drink. If I stayed late at work, he came to get me. He held me close and murmured that everything would be okay.

Outside, I was the girl he graciously tolerated. Alone with him, I could almost believe in us. Sometimes our marriage seemed like something I'd dreamed up.

My eyes blurred as the laughter and teasing continued. Across the room, my husband stood beside Olivia, taking every drink someone offered her. “She's had enough. I'll take that one.”

He leaned close and said something that made her laugh. I knew him too well to believe he was only pretending.

Then she wobbled. Her knees gave way, and she went down.

Everyone started talking at once. Ethan went pale. He lifted her into his arms and hurried toward the door.

I got up and followed without thinking. He took the keys out of my hand. “Caroline, I'm getting Olivia to the hospital. I'll use your car. Ask someone for a ride home.”

The whispers started before he was gone.

“Did you see his face? He was terrified.”

“He cut his hand on the glass and didn't even notice. Look, he's bleeding.”

I looked where they were pointing. Blood fell from his fingertips, but his attention never left Olivia.

I couldn't move. The hurt was so sudden and sharp that taking a breath seemed impossible.

It was after midnight. He knew exactly how these people treated me. Still, he left me there and carried her away.

He'd told me so many times that he would tell everyone about us when the time was right. Until then, I was expected to watch him play the devoted boyfriend to someone else.

I couldn't stop the tears.

“Oh, you're crying? I figured you'd be used to it by now.”

I walked out without answering.

…

Outside, I took out my phone. “Mr. Wallace, please draw up the divorce papers.”

Then I opened a page I'd bookmarked long ago, for the place where I'd wanted to spend our honeymoon. I took a deep breath. My hands were shaking, but I booked one ticket. Just mine.

He still wasn't home at dawn. At 5:10 a.m., I opened Facebook. Olivia's post was at the top of my feed, only two minutes old.

“You stayed up all night taking care of me and even hurt yourself because of me. How am I ever going to thank you?” In the photo, Ethan slept beside her hospital bed. His bandaged hand still held hers.

Comments were pouring in.

One person added a picture of him carrying her out of the restaurant's private dining room.

“There's your proof. Just look at them.”

“This is adorable! I've thought they were perfect for each other since high school.”

“Please get married already. Your wedding gift is waiting!”

A few of the comments found time for me, too. “Ethan was bleeding and all he cared about was Olivia. He didn't even see Caroline.”

Someone answered, “I'd have enough pride to leave if I were her, instead of standing between two people who are clearly meant to be.”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter