What I Kept Excusing

I stared at my phone, aching. Even after all those years, people still couldn't picture Ethan and me together.

In college, he'd been at the top of his class, president of the student council, the professors' favorite.

I was an ordinary girl with respectable grades and my head in a novel. Nobody paid much attention to me.

Once we started working, he earned three promotions in three years. He was the company's rising star. I was an office clerk trying to earn a paycheck.

Everyone we knew thought Olivia was generous.

She liked Ethan, too, they said, but she wouldn't date him because she cared about my feelings. That made me the delusional girl who wouldn't stop chasing him.

We didn't act like a couple around anyone else. Yet he'd looked out for me. Once, a man attacked us, and Ethan was cut while protecting me.

The police arrived before it could get any worse.

That night he looked at me as I cried. “Caroline, don't go out walking by yourself at night anymore.”

I'd taken that concern as the answer I'd been waiting for. We started dating, then married quietly. I thought we had finally found our way to a happy ending.

Then Olivia came back.

She went to work for a competitor and took a project he'd spent six months pursuing. Afterward, she said she felt bad and sent some major clients his way to make it up to him.

One favor led to the next. Soon they were in touch nearly every day.

Our old classmates started saying they were the couple that should have been.

At first, Ethan held me and said, “They're kidding about high school. Don't let it bother you.”

Then his nights at work got longer. He came home smelling of perfume I didn't wear. He started going to the gym and shopping for clothes from labels he'd never cared about.

His car's center console was full of strawberry lollipops and dried mango. Olivia's favorites.

But what I couldn't get past was the miscarriage three months earlier.

At the worst moment of my life, I couldn't get him on the phone. I kept calling, and he didn't answer.

Later I learned he'd been away on business with Olivia. An executive at his level didn't even need to handle that project in person.

I pleaded with him to come back. He answered in that gentle voice. “Be reasonable, Carrie. This is an important project. And Olivia's an old friend. We ought to help if we can. I've arranged for someone to help you at home. Rest and get better. Once you've recovered, we'll have our wedding.”

He dismissed what I was going through, and I let the promise of a real wedding quiet every question I wanted to ask.

I acted as though nothing had happened. As though I couldn't see the way he treated her.

I looked at dresses and reception venues. I imagined us standing together in front of everyone. Only now could I admit what had been happening.

Other people's opinions weren't what kept us apart. Whenever Ethan had to choose, he chose someone else. I was never the person who came first.

He didn't get home until evening. When he saw me looking at him, he tucked his injured hand behind his back.

Then he came over and crouched in front of me. “I was protecting Olivia last night, and a broken bottle cut me. It's not serious. That post was just her way of thanking me. There isn't anything else to it. Don't make it into something it isn't.”

I moved away from his hand. Before I could answer, the front door opened again.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter