Claire's POV
Daniel had landed at O'Hare. Behind his voice, I could hear our daughter talking excitedly.
“Lottie's been asking for Mommy all the way here,” he said, his voice warm. “We'll come straight to the mall.”
At last, I could relax. “Okay. I'll wait here.”
I lowered the phone to find Nathan studying me, suspicion written all over his face.
“You heard the call. My husband is coming,” I said. “The suit you're holding is his.”
I put out my hand for it. Instead of returning the bag, Nathan laughed.
“Is there anything you won't say, Claire? Enough with the act. You aren't married. You arranged that call to make me jealous.”
Where could I even start with something that stupid?
“Think what you want. Just hand over the suit.”
I tried to take the bag. He jerked it out of reach and kept his grip on it.
For a moment, we pulled in opposite directions. A sharp snap broke the shop's quiet. A button fell onto the wooden floor, rolled, and came to rest near my shoe.
I stopped moving.
Finding those hand-polished horn buttons had taken weeks. I'd commissioned them from a small craftsman in Florence for this particular suit.
Nathan waved it off. “One button. She can repair it. This is perfect, actually. I'll wear it to Soph's birthday party next week.”
I couldn't listen to him anymore. In a fury, I pulled back my hand to slap him.
I never saw Sophie coming from beside him.
“If you need to hurt somebody, hit me, Clary!”
My hand was already in motion. It connected with her cheek instead of Nathan's, a loud crack filling the shop.
She screamed and collapsed onto the floor.
Nathan drained of color. “Soph!”
He dropped to his knees and cradled her while my parents hurried back inside.
“Sweetheart, why did you step in front of her?”
Then their furious faces turned toward me.
“Claire, how could you? She's pregnant!”
I'd never intended to touch Sophie. For a second, I couldn't make myself speak. “She got in front of me.”
Sophie clutched her belly with both hands and contorted her face as though she were in agony.
“Don't blame Clary, Mom. Please, Dad,” she whispered through tears. “She's hurting because of what I did. If she feels better now, that's okay. I couldn't stand by and let Nathan get hurt over something that's my fault.”
Nathan looked devastated. “You can't do that, Soph. You're more important than I am.”
He scooped her up. As he carried her past me, he looked at me with disgust.
“This is too much, Claire. I'm taking her to the ER to make sure the baby's okay. Bring her a dozen red roses and apologize. You know she loves them. It's the least you can do.”
I didn't answer.
He'd dropped the suit in a heap. Feeling sick, I gathered it up and handed it to Mrs. Hartley.
“I'll be back to order a replacement. Would you please throw this one away?”
“Of course, dear,” she answered quietly.
Mom came after me when I left the shop. Before I could escape, she grabbed my wrist and dug her fingers in.
“I gave you that kidney so you'd leave your sister's happiness alone, Claire. You have part of me inside you. How can you still be trying to destroy her life?”
My free hand curled into a fist.
When she'd agreed to donate, I'd spent days crying with gratitude. I'd thought my mother was saving me out of love, asking for nothing. It took years for me to realize she planned to use it against me as long as I lived.
I made myself answer.
“Her happiness? Mom, she was having an affair with my husband. That's where all of this began.”
Mom slapped me hard enough to whip my head to the side.
