Claire's POV

Sophie always got to choose first in our family. No one ever thought to question it.

The last slice of cake, a toy there was only one of, a new dress—whatever it was, she got it.

“You're the older sister,” our parents would tell me. “Be a good example. Let her have it.”

That rule didn't change when I started seeing Nathan. Even our dinners out were supposed to include Sophie. I couldn't pinpoint when he began watching her too long, or when he started angling his phone away from me whenever a message came in.

But what happened on my parents' balcony was impossible to misunderstand. I found them kissing. I was so furious I slapped them both.

Sophie moved on quickly after that. She started seeing a man she knew from college and married him within weeks.

Nathan knelt in front of me and begged me not to leave. We had five years together behind us. I couldn't bring myself to throw that away, so I overlooked his betrayal and took him back. What an idiot I'd been.

When Sophie's marriage broke down, everyone scrambled to put her life right. Mom was prepared to hold a kidney donation over me to get Nathan for the daughter she loved best.

Now, outside Hartley's, her hand was still in the air. The cheek she'd struck was burning.

I laughed, bitterly. “Do you ever keep count, Mom? Of all the times you've hit me for her?”

“You refuse to let her be happy!” she snapped. “He's just a man, Clary. Why are you fighting your sister over a man?”

There, at least, she had a point. He was nothing more than a man. I'd already wasted far too much of my life on him.

“I'm not fighting her over anything. Stop worrying,” I said. “I have my own husband.”

Mom looked at me as though I was babbling. She didn't believe a word, and it no longer mattered. I was done trying to convince her.


Earlier that day, I'd heard that Daniel's aunt was in the hospital. Daniel and Lottie were still stuck in traffic coming from the airport when I left the mall. I bought flowers and a box of pastries, hoping to reach the hospital early enough to sit with her for a while.

I stepped out of the elevator with my bouquet and bakery box. Nathan was there, escorting Sophie out of an exam room.

The anger he'd shown at the mall vanished. His eyes dropped to the things I was carrying, and he gave me a self-satisfied smile.

“Finally ready to apologize?” He walked over. “Soph doesn't like lilies. You know she likes peonies.” He frowned at the pastries next. “She's had morning sickness all day. Chocolate croissants and cinnamon scones are the last things she needs.”

I glanced between them. They honestly believed I'd bought everything for Sophie.

She immediately put on a forgiving smile, the picture of patience.

“It's okay, Clary,” she said, taking my hand and gazing earnestly at me. “As long as you know you were wrong, I can forgive you.”

Her fingers tightened around mine.

“Nathan and I talked it over. You can have the baby after it's born. You and he can raise it, and I'll come see it on weekends. That way, people won't keep talking about how you can't have children.”

I lifted an eyebrow. I wouldn't have thought they could sound any more ridiculous.

Nathan stood a little taller, obviously proud of the proposal. “Look how considerate Soph is, Claire. You should thank her. You should probably be ashamed of yourself, too. We lost our baby because you weren't careful. The doctor said you probably couldn't conceive again. Now you don't have to worry about it.”

My hands began to tremble.

I'd heard enough. I hurled the bouquet and the pastries into his face.

“Do you have a shred of decency?” I shouted. “You dumped me on the side of a highway during a flash flood! You left me there to go rescue her, Nathan. My daughter would still be alive if you hadn't!”

Once I'd said it, the memories flooded back. I still woke in the night, crying for the little girl I'd never gotten to hold.

We'd taken such care while trying to conceive. Nathan quit smoking. I gave up coffee, ate carefully, and got enough sleep. At last, I became pregnant.

Then, on our second wedding anniversary, Sophie called him in a panic. Her husband was treating her badly, she said, and threatening to kick her out.

Nathan didn't hesitate. With rain pouring down, he pulled over, ordered me out onto the gravel shoulder, and told me to get an Uber. No driver would have come out in that storm.

A stranger finally stopped and drove me to the ER. I was soaked through and had a high fever by the time we arrived. The doctors couldn't save my baby.

When Nathan showed up, he didn't cry. He frowned down at me in the hospital bed.

“I needed to know Soph was safe. I'd do it again,” he'd told me. “We can have another baby, Clary. This isn't your sister's fault.”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter