Chapter 1
My husband had just finished having sex with another woman in our bed when he looked up at me.
“Bee, my wife’s home. Say hi.”
Then my phone lit up.
The messages were from Ethan—the Ethan of five years ago, who was still trying to convince me to date him.
“I love you, Avery. I would never do this to you.”
I told him Brooke wasn’t the first. Before her, he’d brought home the girl who bullied me at school.
On my birthday.
His voice broke over the phone.
“I must have planned something for you, at least. A surprise.”
I smiled.
Even after everything I’d told him, he still thought there was a kinder explanation.
Avery's POV
For twenty minutes, there was nothing. Then my phone erupted.
“That can't be true!
“I'd never do that. I'm not that kind of man!
“I love you, Avery. You're the one I want to spend my life with. Don't you remember how we—”
I stopped reading.
In the bedroom, my husband and the woman in our bed had finished having sex.
Ethan Mercer pushed his damp hair off his forehead, then tousled hers.
“Bee, my wife's home. Say hi.”
Brooke Dawson turned toward me with a sweet little greeting.
She looked straight at me, openly pleased with herself.
I didn't take the bait. I walked out.
Brooke appeared about ten minutes later, fully dressed. As she passed me, she lowered her voice.
“Imagine having to get out of the way so your husband can screw someone else. How pathetic.”
I didn't answer. My face stayed blank. By now, that numbness was familiar.
There were ninety-nine messages on my phone from the Ethan of five years earlier.
The last one sounded like he was coming apart.
“Please make her leave. Avery, please. Don't watch them. It's disgusting.”
I typed back without hurrying.
“She isn't the first woman you've brought home. She won't be the last, either.
“If I chased out every woman you slept with, I'd never get a moment's rest.”
The younger Ethan begged me to explain.
“How could it get this bad? I've spent five years trying to get you to go out with me. Hurting you is the last thing I'd ever want.
“I would never put you through this. Never.”
I looked up at the man coming out of the bathroom, then returned to my screen.
“Do you know who you were cheating with before her?”
No reply came for a while. He seemed to be struggling to bring himself to ask.
Finally, a message appeared.
“Who?”
“Kelsey. The girl who bullied me at school.”
A moment later, my phone started buzzing again and wouldn't stop.
I answered his call. His voice cracked through the speaker, almost breaking into tears.
“There is no way I'd ever touch Kelsey. Avery, I hate her more than anyone.
“When I got you out of that equipment room, you were shaking. Do you have any idea what it did to me to see you like that?
“I wanted to kill her.
“How could I end up in bed with someone I despise?”
I let him finish. Then I told him what had happened.
“After graduation, you found her in an alley outside a bar. Someone was beating her up.
“You felt bad for her and brought her home.
“I remember the date perfectly. April 27.”
For a time, I heard nothing on his end.
When he spoke again, he sounded desperate to find one good thing in what I'd told him.
“Your birthday. I must have planned something for you, at least. A surprise.”
I smiled.
“Oh, you surprised me, all right.
“You spent the night with Kelsey. In our marriage bed.”
