Chapter 2
The Ethan on my phone—the one from five years ago—couldn't say another word.
I set the phone down and lowered myself onto the couch, exhausted.
Fresh from his shower, my husband walked past, rubbing a towel through his hair. He glanced at me.
“Who were you talking to?”
I didn't respond, and he didn't press me.
Instead, he came closer and crouched until we were face-to-face.
“What's wrong? Are you upset?”
He took my hands and gave me a gentle smile.
“All this time, and you're still not used to it?
“You can't go on being miserable like this. You'll make yourself sick. You know how much that would hurt me.”
I looked at him in silence. I didn't even have the energy to pull away.
My phone vibrated with more messages from his younger self.
“Avery, how did we end up like this?
“We were happy. Did something happen? Please tell me.”
I'd asked myself the same thing more times than I could count.
How had we gotten here?
We'd known each other from an early age. I was supposed to be the person he cherished most.
He used to hate seeing me hurt. Even my unhappiness was more than he could bear.
On graduation day, I'd smiled at him and asked, “If I don't need to lean on you anymore, does that mean I've grown up?”
He looked right into my eyes.
“No. It means I've let you down.”
My father died four years ago. That day, I cried in Ethan's arms until I lost consciousness.
“I don't have any family anymore,” I told him.
He stroked my hair. His own eyes filled as he held me.
Again and again, he said I still had him. I could always count on him, for the rest of my life.
He meant it then. He held me so firmly, as if he could keep me safe simply by refusing to let go.
And I believed him.
Then, on the day we were supposed to visit my father's grave, I found him in bed with my best friend.
I remembered it as clearly as if it had just happened.
She sat cross-legged on the bed, laughing.
“You don't have much else going for you, but I'll say this: you know how to pick a man.”
Ethan went pale.
He rushed to explain. He'd had a drink. Things had gotten out of hand. One thing had led to another.
My best friend crossed her arms, completely untroubled.
“Why are you panicking? She's not leaving you.
“I know her better than you do. She's a stupid, gullible loser. If she divorced you, she'd probably lose the will to live.”
Ethan kept shaking his head.
He begged me to stay. Pleaded for me not to leave him.
Looking down at his terrified face, I weakened. I gave him another chance.
To him, that proved she was right: I couldn't survive without him.
I was still hoping some part of him loved me. Meanwhile, he kept sleeping with her, crossing the same boundaries over and over.
We fought all the time.
Once, when I was crying so hard I could barely control myself, he said something I'd never be able to forget.
“Avery, you don't have anybody else. If you leave me, who's left?”
After that, he started bringing other women home.
There wasn't a corner of the place his cheating hadn't touched.
He grew less careful about it, then stopped trying to hide it at all.
Four years of that had worn away the last of my hope.
On the video call, the younger Ethan was sobbing.
“I knew how much losing your dad hurt you. I knew you had no one left but me.”
Perhaps that was exactly why he had felt free to treat me so cruelly. I had nowhere to go.
He believed I would never leave.
He was sure I couldn't.
I pulled out the divorce agreement and smiled at the screen.
“You're studying law right now. Would you read these terms for me? Tell me if they're fair.”
He hesitated, then nodded. Something in his expression dimmed.
He began going through the pages carefully.
As I watched that familiar face, I remembered the day he'd told me he loved me. He'd been so nervous.
