Chapter 2 The Chapel That Watches Back
The walk to the chapel should have been simple. Down one flight of stairs, across the east corridor, through the courtyard, and into the old chapel with the tall stained-glass windows that everyone acted like they didn’t notice.
Except at Blackthorn, nothing ever felt simple.
Anil followed a small stream of students past lockers and bulletin boards with curling notices. Hand-painted schedules. A flyer for the autumn solstice festival. A list of art elective sign-ups.
Nothing magical. Nothing menacing.
But something about the air felt charged—like static, or like the pause before lightning strikes.
She told herself she was tired. She told herself she was imagining things.
She kept walking.
Around her, people talked about normal things.
“Do you think dorm 4C is actually haunted?”
“Mr. Everly cancelled track because someone found bones on the field.”
“Stop lying, they were chicken bones from the cafeteria.”
Students giggling, mock-arguing, scrolling through their phones, draped in scarves and badges and normalcy.
This, she told herself, was just a school.
Even if it smelled a little too much like old churches and rain-soaked stone.
Even if the bell still hummed faintly somewhere inside her like an echo that wouldn’t die.
When she stepped out into the courtyard, the wind clipped cold against her cheeks. Late autumn had already crept across the grounds—leaves clinging to skeletal trees, grass damp and uneven, fog clinging stubbornly low to the ground.
And the chapel—
it stood at the far end of the courtyard, tall and narrow, like it had grown out of the earth rather than been built.
Students entered through its double wooden doors—some chatting, some laughing, some quiet. None of them seemed nervous.
Except, Anil noticed, for the older ones.
The seniors.
They walked differently. Not hesitant exactly, but aware. Like they knew the building was listening.
Mira wasn’t there yet. Probably still trying to find lip gloss or content.
So Anil walked in alone.
The chapel smelled like wax and stone and something faintly sweet—lavender, maybe—from some unseen censer.
Candles lined the walls, thin white ones and thicker sculpted beeswax ones. Their flames were steady. Too steady. No draft flickered them, though the air smelled faintly like wind.
The stained-glass windows towered over the pews, arching upward like reaching fingers. They didn’t show saints the way normal churches did.
They showed wings. Not quite angelic. Not quite human.
And between them—monsters.
She blinked.
No.
Not monsters.
Not quite.
She stared again.
One of the windows showed a woman—cloaked, faceless, standing between two winged figures. One of the figures’ wings glowed gold; the other’s were charcoal-black, feathers frayed at the edges.
Her pulse thudded.
Lucien’s words rang in her memory.
You’re late to your own story, Anil.
She forced her gaze away.
She spotted Mira near the back, practically horizontal across one pew, dramatically sighing at the ceiling.
“You look like you’re mourning the concept of mornings,” Anil said, grateful for normalcy.
Mira groaned. “Why are religious buildings always so cold? Is holy heat not a thing?”
Anil sat beside her. “You look like you haven’t slept.”
“I was editing my podcast,” Mira said. “Do you think ‘Angels Are Just Inconvenient Roommates’ is a good title for an episode?”
“Please don’t mess with angels,” Anil muttered. “Even hypothetical ones.”
“Hypothetical?” Mira raised an eyebrow. “You saw something last night, didn’t you?”
Anil hesitated.
She didn’t want to lie.
She also didn’t know how to explain that she met a barefoot, uninvited boy in her dorm hallway who claimed they’ve had conversations across several lifetimes, and—
He knew her scar.
He knew her friend.
He knew her.
“Well,” she said slowly. “I think I saw someone. He—”
The doors at the front of the chapel opened.
Conversation stilled.
A man walked in.
He didn’t look like a headmaster.
Not exactly.
Headmaster Vale—she assumed—was not old in the fragile sense. His age was more like old photographs, or carved wood—aged into something sharp and deliberate. His coat was long and dark, his collar cut high at the neck. His hair was silver—not white, not gray, but silver, like it had been intentionally gilded by time.
When he stopped, the chapel seemed to get quieter.
Even the candles held their breath.
“Welcome,” Headmaster Vale said. His voice didn’t echo, but carried, as though the walls leaned forward to hear him. “To Blackthorn.”
He didn’t smile.
He didn’t need to.
He looked straight at the students. Not warmly, but not unkindly either.
Then his gaze landed on Anil.
It didn’t just land.
It stayed.
A beat too long.
As if he recognized her.
Something inside her chest went very still.
Mira looked between them, eyebrows lifting in slow realization.
Vale finally broke the gaze.
He spoke about tradition. About legacy. About academic excellence and behavioral expectations. About Blackthorn’s mission to preserve both knowledge and character.
It all sounded like a speech given a hundred times before.
But sometimes—his eyes drifted back to Anil.
He was not surprised she was here.
He seemed almost… relieved.
Even though she’d never seen him before.
When the speech ended, candles flickered back into motion. Heads turned, people sighed, someone whispered about how strict he looked.
Students began rising, collecting bags.
“Okay,” Mira muttered. “He was dramatic.”
Anil didn’t reply.
She kept watching the headmaster.
Or rather—
She watched the way he avoided the stained-glass windows.
Students filed out.
Sunlight—or something like it—shifted through the colored glass.
That same panel caught her eye.
The cloaked woman.
The golden-winged boy.
And the dark-winged one.
One of the senior girls passed and saw her staring.
“Pretty windows, right?” the girl said lightly.
Anil nodded. “What are they supposed to be?”
The girl paused just a hair too long.
“Oh,” she said. “It depends who you ask.”
“Ask who?”
The girl smiled like someone humoring a child.
“The chapel remembers different things for different people.”
And then she walked away.
Mira was already tugging Anil toward the door. “Let’s go stake out seats in the cafeteria before the soccer girls steal all the window tables.”
But as they walked out into the pale courtyard, Anil looked back one last time.
For a second—
Just a second—
She thought she saw a silhouette standing inside the chapel.
Not Cael.
Not Lucien.
Someone else.
Watching.
But when she blinked, the window reflected only her.
They spent lunch in the cafeteria, where the sunlight poured through tall mullioned windows, making the steam from the food glimmer.
It was almost normal.
Almost.
Students ate and argued about late homework and whether Blackthorn’s history teachers were “cult-leader weird” or “normal-teacher weird”. A group at the next table debated whether the ghost in Dorm 4A was a nun, a banshee, or a depressed pigeon aristocrat.
Mira introduced Anil to Ruby, a soft-spoken girl who knitted during math lectures, and Bryn, who swore she saw something with wings in the third-floor window last night.
“Could’ve been laundry,” Ruby offered.
“It growled!” Bryn hissed.
“Wet laundry?” Ruby tried.
Normal things.
Stupid things.
Things that should’ve made Anil laugh.
But her mind kept drifting.
To the corridor.
To the way Lucien’s voice had sounded—like memory and smoke and warning.
And worse—
to the bell hum that still vibrated faintly somewhere behind her ribs, like a note waiting to finish.
Afternoon classes grounded her a little.
History of Sacred Architecture.
World Literature.
Mathematics in Symbolic Design.
She focused on the chalkboard. She took neat notes. She answered when called on.
Normal.
Until the last period.
Introductory Mysticism.
The word still made her nervous.
The classroom was set in one of the oldest wings of the academy. The stone here was darker, older, almost soft with age. There were no smartboards, no tech, just desks and shelves full of books too worn to be replaced.
Professor Ashworth—narrow-faced, quiet-voiced—didn’t explain what mysticism meant.
He simply began writing.
On the blackboard, he wrote four phrases:
Memory is not history.
Feeling is not proof.
Recognition is not understanding.
But all of them are real.
Then he turned to the class.
“Most of you,” he said, “have been told magic is about power.”
A few students nodded.
“You’ve also been told it’s about belief.”
A smaller number nodded.
Professor Ashworth shook his head.
“Magic,” he said softly, “is about response.”
Silence.
“You do not control it. You do not summon it. You do not barter for it. You move—and if the world remembers you—”
He paused, eyes drifting across the room.
His gaze landed on Anil.
“—it answers.”
She went still.
Something shifted around her, as though the air recognized her somehow, as though the light paused to examine her.
Professor Ashworth seemed to notice.
He hesitated.
Then, for the first time, he looked uncertain.
“Some of you,” he said, quieter now, “have been answered before.”
Nobody moved.
“One of you…”
He didn't finish.
He set down the chalk.
The rest of class passed like a dream she was only half inside.
When the final bell rang and students began filing out into the dusky halls, Mira linked arms with her.
“Okay,” Mira declared, “either that class was profound, or I need lunch number two.”
“Probably both,” Anil said.
They walked back through the courtyard as the first hints of evening pressed against the sky. The wind smelled like cold stone, faint smoke, and a hint of something sweet blooming in the distance.
“Do you feel weird?” Mira asked suddenly.
Anil hesitated. “Yes. But I don’t know what kind of weird.”
“Magical weird?” Mira asked. “Or ‘I think my senses are lying to me’ weird?”
“Both.”
“Fun.”
They crossed the courtyard. Light spilled through the chapel windows, turning the arches warm and amber.
Anil glanced up at them.
Her steps slowed.
One of the windows—
had changed.
She froze.
Mira followed her gaze.
“What are you staring at?”
Anil squinted, heart thudding.
In the glass—
was a girl.
Dark hair.
Standing between two figures.
She blinked hard.
Gone.
Just glass. Just color.
Just normal.
But her blood had already decided otherwise.
“Probably just seeing yourself,” Mira said gently. “It’s reflective in certain angles.”
“Yeah,” Anil said, even though she was almost certain it wasn’t.
By the time they reached their dorm, the sun had faded. The old brass hallway lights had flickered on, casting soft halos against stone.
Mira tugged her door open and tossed her bag onto her bed.
“You coming to dinner?”
“Maybe later,” Anil said.
Mira eyed her, but didn’t push. “Okay. But don’t overthink everything. I know that face. You’re building conspiracy charts in your head.”
“It’s nothing,” Anil lied.
“Cool.” Mira paused at the door. “Also, if you start glowing again, text me. I monetize that.”
“Mira,” Anil groaned.
“What? Supernatural things deserve exposure.”
She left.
Silence.
Soft. Heavy.
Anil sat on the edge of her bed.
The music box waited on her desk.
Quiet.
Still.
She stood.
She approached it.
Her fingers hovered above it—but she didn't touch it.
Instead, she said aloud, to no one:
“I don’t want to remember. I just want to understand.”
Her voice didn’t echo.
But the box thudded once.
Not like a normal sound.
Like a heartbeat.
Then stilled.
And something—
in the hallway outside—
stepped once.
Barefoot.
Waiting.
