Chapter 4

“Aren't you exhausted from pretending?”

“None of that's true!” I shouted.

Mercer came toward me, furious.

“With me, Brooks.”

He led me to the far side of the field. For ten minutes, he stood with his arms folded and lectured me.

“Get your attitude under control. This program is about learning to work together. If you only care about yourself, you drag the whole group down.”

Then he assigned extra drills: five sets of squats, three sets of push-ups, and two laps of squat jumps.

Over the next several days, nobody questioned Chloe at all.

She only had to say, “I heard her complaining to herself,” and everyone would turn on me.

Once she knew they believed her, she stopped holding back.

Mercer lost whatever patience he'd had left and kept giving me extra exercises.

Again and again, I stood out on that blazing field, my clothes soaked through and my legs aching. I couldn't even explain myself without being dismissed.

The other students avoided me on purpose. They moved away when I approached, whispered to one another, and stared as though I'd done something disgusting.

I couldn't get away from the rumors. They followed me through the day and stayed with me at night.

Even my academic adviser called me into her office to talk about my attitude.

“Hannah, orientation is a shared experience. You need to make allowances for other people. Whatever you're thinking privately, all this negativity and resistance isn't helping.

“Chloe must have a reason for saying these things. Take a good look at your behavior. Your classmates, Coach Mercer, your faculty—we're all expecting better from you.”

Every word assumed I'd done something wrong. Nobody wanted my side of it. Nobody believed me.

I felt helpless.

I'd felt this before, in the life I'd already lost. Now that same despair was closing in again.

What was the point of a second chance if nothing changed?

I'd prepared this time. I'd stayed alert. I'd hidden the candies before Chloe could use them against me.

So why did every attempt to fight back land me in the same place?

I curled up in bed with an ache in my chest and kept turning over, unable to sleep.

Then my phone buzzed. Grandma was calling from her small town back home.

I answered, and her familiar voice came through.

“How's orientation going, honey? I mailed you some of those cookies you love. They should get there tomorrow.”

That was all it took. Tears started falling, though I tried to keep her from hearing them.

“I'm not tired, Grandma…”

“When you were little, you'd come home upset, tell me you weren't tired, and then cry half the night.” Her voice stayed gentle. “I can tell how you're doing just by hearing you. If it's too much, come home. You know I'll be here.”

I was about to answer when something finally clicked.

I remembered a detail I'd never thought to question.

Now I knew how Chloe had been reading my mind.

On the eighth morning of orientation, all the freshmen gathered on the field while university administrators gave their speeches.

The university president, Dr. Reed, was only halfway through his remarks when Chloe raised her hand.

“Dr. Reed, there's something you should know!”

She pointed at me.

“While you're giving this important speech, Hannah's making fun of it in her head. She thinks it's all empty ceremony. She doesn't respect you at all.”

I looked up at the girl who kept trying to grind me down and let out a short laugh.

“Funny you should mention that.

“I just heard your thoughts, too. Why don't we let everybody hear what you're really thinking?”

People looked at one another, confused. Then Chloe's voice came through my phone's speaker, loud enough for the students around us to hear.

“What a bunch of idiots. They're so easy to fool. I've been playing them this whole time, and they still think I'm a good person. It's pathetic.”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter