Chapter 1

For four years, I’d followed my boyfriend wherever he wanted to go.

For our graduation trip, Ethan finally promised we could go somewhere I chose.

I booked a seaside hotel and bought a white dress for our beach photos.

Then my childhood friend Brooke suggested a mountain road trip.

“Don’t kill the mood,” Ethan told me. “I’ll take you to the beach another time.”

I canceled my reservations and planned their trip instead.

On departure day, Brooke was already in the passenger seat.

“She gets carsick,” Ethan said, opening the rear door for me.

So did I. He knew that.

Once, he’d given up his own seat to take care of me.

Now he was asking me to give up mine for her.


Ethan Reed and I had already decided what our graduation trip would be.

For four years of college, I'd gone wherever my boyfriend wanted to go: snowy peaks, rocky canyons, deserts baked dry by the sun, highways that seemed to run forever. Every destination had been his choice.

Before graduation, I finally asked for something different.

“Ethan, could we go to the beach this time? Somewhere quiet, away from the crowds. We could sleep late, eat seafood, sit in the ocean breeze. We wouldn't have to rush anywhere.”

He hadn't even hesitated. “Absolutely. You get to pick our graduation trip.”

I stayed happy about that conversation for days.

I drew up three possible itineraries. I found a hotel near the old waterfront neighborhood, with a small balcony overlooking the harbor lights. Without telling him, I bought a white dress. I wanted pictures of the two of us on the beach to remember graduation by.

Then, a week before we were supposed to leave, my childhood friend Brooke Bennett dropped a map into our group chat. It was a driving route through the Blue Ridge.

“Come on, we should do something adventurous for graduation. The beach will always be there. How often do we get a stretch of good summer weather up in the mountains?”

Ethan answered almost immediately. “That's a great route.”

I stared at the conversation with my fingers poised over the keyboard. It took me a while to type, “I thought we'd agreed on the beach?”

Brooke replied right away. “Natalie, are you planning a graduation trip or a retirement vacation? We're in our twenties, not our sixties!”

The chat filled with laughing emojis. One person said the mountains would look incredible on camera. Another said beach trips were boring. Someone else said Ethan and Brooke couldn't pass up the chance to make a road-trip film together.

Ethan didn't say a word in my defense. He sent me a private message instead.

“Don't kill the mood. Bee's right. I'll take you to the beach another time.”

Another time. He always had another time for me, and all the time in the world for somebody else's plans.

Reading his message hurt. I typed “Okay” anyway.

I canceled the coastal hotel reservations and began again. I researched the mountain route, reserved rental cars and places to stay, looked up elevations and forecasts, calculated expenses, and bought travel insurance.

Brooke's entire contribution to the group chat was, “Nobody plans a trip like Natalie,” with a clapping emoji.

I couldn't tell whether I was supposed to feel appreciated or insulted.

…

When Ethan picked me up on departure day, Brooke was already in the passenger seat. She wore sunglasses, had her long legs stretched toward the open window, and held an iced latte.

She lifted her chin as I wheeled my suitcase over. “Hey, Natalie. Mind sitting in back? Riding up front helps with my carsickness.”

I got carsick too. Ethan knew that.

Before I could say anything, he opened the rear door.

“Just hang in there. Bee was editing until three this morning, so she's feeling pretty rough. You've got more space back here. You can take a nap.”

He sounded so matter-of-fact that I remembered our first trip freshman year. I'd gotten terribly sick then too. He'd given me his front seat and squeezed into the back, passing me water and tissues the whole way.

“So what if my girlfriend needs a little extra care?” he'd said. “Blame me. I spoil her.”

Now he loaded my suitcase into the trunk and turned to Brooke.

“Seat belt. Let's go!”

I stood beside the car with a small, unhappy smile. I could remember exactly how it felt when he used to put me first.

Next Chapter