Chapter 3
I'd felt sorry for Daniel and given him the job. It was why I started bringing an extra meal to the store, too.
He'd always told me he'd pay me back someday.
Now that he could, he was frightened I might expect him to.
I couldn't help a bitter little smile.
The snowfall grew heavier. I was nearly numb when the club doors finally opened.
—
Daniel stepped outside with a group of wealthy young men dressed as well as he was. His designer suit fit him perfectly. He looked confident and happy.
There was nothing left of the broke young man in bargain clothes who shared that cramped apartment with me.
“When are you getting rid of the old woman, Daniel?”
“Seriously. You have to look at that face every night. Doesn't it give you nightmares? How much longer are you going to pretend?”
He looked annoyed and flicked a hand at them.
“Enough. Talking about her makes me think of that stale, broke old-woman smell. I'd have ended it ages ago if I wasn't afraid she'd cause a scene.”
I was close enough to hear every word. My fingernails pressed into my palm so hard I nearly broke the skin.
I wanted to run up to him and demand that he explain himself.
I'd taken two steps when a red Porsche stopped in front of the group. A beautiful young woman got out and hooked her arm through Daniel's.
He turned to her with a look I knew by heart, tender and full of affection.
He'd once looked only at me that way.
She pouted and complained that her hands were freezing.
He took them at once, warming them between his own before putting them in his coat pocket.
“Why didn't you wear something warmer?” he murmured.
She wore expensive clothes and an easy, radiant smile. The two of them looked as though they belonged together.
I looked tired and worn out. Fine lines had already appeared beside my eyes.
Watching them in that bitter wind, I felt the hurt so sharply I could hardly breathe.
He'd warmed my hands the same way. He'd fussed at me for not looking after myself.
Someone in the comments had asked whether he'd ever loved his girlfriend.
His answer had been, [Of course I did. You spend eight years with someone, you're going to love them.]
When had that stopped being true?
I was cold all the way through. Suddenly, I didn't want to speak to him at all.
Then he spotted me.
His tenderness vanished. He looked startled, then irritated.
“Natalie? What are you doing here? Did you follow me? Why do you always have to be so paranoid?”
I could only stare at him.
Paranoid.
I remembered all the other times he'd used that word.
Three years earlier, I'd offered to meet him after work. He'd snapped, “Can you stop hovering over me like some paranoid lunatic?”
I'd asked about a pair of expensive shoes he'd come home wearing. Another night, I'd heard him calling me an old hag while he played games with his friends, and I'd asked why.
Each time, he'd said I was unreasonable. Paranoid.
Had he stopped loving me that long ago?
He went on berating me until he finally noticed the tears on my face. Then he stopped abruptly.
I looked at him and made myself speak slowly.
“You finished paying your debts a long time ago, didn't you? And you want to leave me.”
He hesitated and looked away, as though he couldn't get the words out.
I gave a quiet laugh and spared him the trouble.
“I know. I read your post.”
He breathed out deeply, looking suddenly relieved.
“Yes. I want to end this.”
There was relief in his face, but cruelty, too.
“Natalie, being with you every day is torture.”
Torture.
When he was twenty-two, he'd looked at me with love in his eyes and told me, “Every day with you is wonderful, Natalie.”
At thirty, he called it torture.
He took a black debit card from his wallet and held it out, like a handout to someone he pitied.
“There's a million dollars in this account. Take it. That should make up for the years you spent on me.”
