Chapter 4

Ophelia's POV

The production team booked us first class. The seating arrangement was interesting: Natalie and I side by side, Bennett and Mark paired up, Emily and Jesse stuck together in the last row. The director probably figured the setup had good reality-TV energy, like it might spark something.

Bennett disappeared the second he stepped on the plane — didn't even get his carry-on stowed before he made a beeline for the back of the cabin, stride so purposeful that everyone on board knew exactly where he was headed.

I buckled my seatbelt, took the snack Natalie passed me, and settled back.

It started with a strange silence I happened to catch.

Emily's voice, pitched a little lower than usual, like she was letting someone in on a secret: "Jesse, I've seen so much of your work — your performances have this incredible depth to them, real layering. I've been wanting to collaborate forever, just never found the right moment."

Jesse didn't respond, probably because he had no idea how to, given that — as far as I knew — he was a musician, not an actor. But Emily had always been wired differently from most people; where someone else might take the silence as a cue to drop it, she treated it like an invitation to keep going. She seemed to think persistence read as warmth. It did not work on Jesse. He cut her off pretty quickly, voice flat and even, the tone you'd use to correct a minor factual error: "I'm a singer — I'm not an actor. The only thing I've ever been in is my own music videos. I've never filmed anything else." A beat. "I'm sorry — are you maybe thinking of someone else?"

The cabin went the specific kind of quiet that happens when a teacher cold-calls and the student has nothing. The camera operator slid half a step forward, expression heroically neutral.

I couldn't hold it. The laugh came out before I could stop it — not loud, but in that silence there was absolutely nowhere for it to go. Natalie turned toward me with a face that said I am also dying but I am holding on, Mark caught her eye and they both immediately looked away, neither one willing to be the first to acknowledge what had just happened.

Emily cut a look in my direction, eyes burning. How many years has she been running that line on actors? Just never figured out it only works on actors. Lucky break that the livestream wasn't up yet.

The recovery attempt was, if anything, more entertaining than the original crash.

Emily tugged the corners of her mouth back into something approximating a smile. "What I mean is, your presence in your music videos reads as genuine performance — the commitment level is there. I genuinely thought you were doing both."

Jesse went quiet for even longer this time. He'd been working for years, and his music-video acting was something the entire internet had a standing consensus on — not his strong suit, and he'd never had any illusions about it. No one had ever, to his face, told him his on-screen work was something to aspire to.

He considered it for a moment, then bowed — a full, deliberate bow, entirely sincere. "I hope I haven't done anything to offend you, and if I have, I'm genuinely apologizing right now."

That landed and just sat there. The air in the cabin sort of stopped moving.

Emily's smile stayed exactly where it was, frozen.

Natalie and I both opened our snack bags at the same time.

Bennett came out of the lavatory and paused in the aisle, scanning the general vibe of the cabin, one eyebrow shifting almost imperceptibly. What did I miss? Why is Ophelia laughing like that?

Mark drifted past him and filled him in under his breath. Bennett listened, said nothing for a moment. Is Emily actually okay? Every single thing out of her mouth lands directly on someone's nerve.

Don't believe everything you read online. I answered him in my head, keeping my face completely still.

After that, the flight went quiet for a good stretch. Emily sat by her window looking at nothing in particular, holding herself together with the particular stillness of someone barely managing it — worse, somehow, than if she'd just reacted. Mark made a few attempts to get a conversation going; they went nowhere. Natalie scrolled on her phone, glanced back at Emily once, and let it go. The director sat up front running through what appeared to be an extended internal monologue of regret.

Eventually the plane touched down in Bozeman, and the livestream came back online.

The air outside was genuinely something — high-altitude blue sky, mountain ridgeline sharp against it in the distance, the whole atmosphere a different texture than LA. Everyone exhaled. Whatever had been building in the cabin over the past few hours thinned out in the open air almost immediately.

The comments started rolling in:

[We're finally in Montana!! The landscape is INSANE!!]

[The energy between these six people feels… loaded?]

[Emily looks a little rough today]

[Bennett Voss I need you to look directly into the camera and smile, please and thank you]

Emily stepped up to the camera at the terminal exit, and the switch was instantaneous — smile back, voice bright, greeting the audience like none of the last hour had happened. She pulled in a deep breath, expression blissful. "We made it, oh my god, the air out here is incredible —"

Right then, a pickup truck rolled through the lane beside us, exhaust pipe pointing directly her way, putting out a solid black plume that hit her full in the face mid-inhale.

Bennett, standing two steps to her left, took one quiet, instinctive step backward. Is she serious right now? She's into exhaust fumes?

I watched this happen and felt that it would genuinely be a disservice to the moment to let it pass. "Right? Getting a full hit of tailpipe like that — honestly, we don't judge, everyone's got their thing…"

Natalie full-on lost it, hand over her mouth, backing up half a step. The comment section detonated:

[Bennett's little step back I have watched it six times]

[Ophelia I am BEGGING you to stop talking (crying laughing)]

[Leave Emily ALONE she was literally just breathing!!]

Then Emily's fanbase mobilized:

[Ophelia is being so disrespectful right now, Emily didn't do anything]

[This is straight-up bullying, she's just jealous]

[Emily ignore her, we've got you]

The rest of the audience had limited patience for it:

[Did y'all coordinate to show up and control the narrative or]

[She inhaled exhaust and that's jealousy somehow. Okay.]

[Emily stans calm down it's not that deep, genuinely]

Emily turned toward me, expression making the full journey from blissful to wounded. "Ophelia, I feel like that was kind of disrespectful." She paused, then pivoted to Mark. "Mark, don't you think?"

Mark took the question like a dodgeball to the face. Jesse quietly shifted his weight two steps sideways, removing himself from the blast radius with impressive naturalness.

Mark cleared his throat, visibly committed to goodwill. "I think we're all out here working hard and it's better when we support each other, you know —" He thought about it, then added, "And honestly, being into unusual smells is completely normal. My wife craved gasoline fumes through her whole second trimester, would stand at the pump until I dragged her away. It's just a sensory thing."

Silence.

From Emily's expression, she had not felt supported.

I looked down for a second, looked back up, face serious. "You're right, I'm sorry — that came out wrong. Everyone's got something, and it's not my place to make it weird."

Emily's mouth moved slightly. She didn't say anything.

Bennett stayed a few paces back through all of this, watching with the air of someone observing a documentary about a species he'd never encountered. His entire inner monologue had collapsed to a single line: This is supposed to be a travel show.

I glanced over at him — completely unbothered, perfectly positioned outside the fallout zone, just taking it in. For a second I almost did it, almost turned to the camera and said Bennett, what do you think? just to watch him figure out how to answer that on live television — but the production van pulled up right then and hit the horn twice.

Moment gone. Next time.

Back in the van, the comment section had fully abandoned the original thread and gone somewhere else entirely:

[Wait does Emily actually like exhaust fumes?? Asking genuinely]

[Who else smells fresh-printed paper whenever they can, it's the best]

[Same!! Also new books!! That sweet slightly chemical smell]

[Let's all share our weird smell things so Emily feels less alone]

Emily's fanbase was working overtime:

[She was BREATHING, it is not a "thing," please stop]

[Stop trying to make this into something, she literally did nothing]

Everyone else:

[The harder you deny it the more it sounds true lmaooo]

[It's too late, Exhaust Girl has entered the chat and she is here to stay]

Emily sat in the van, perfectly composed, knuckles white around whatever she was holding, watching years of carefully constructed America's Sweetheart branding absorb a full day's worth of damage from a misidentified musician and an unfortunately timed pickup truck.

Outside the window, Montana opened up wide — sky so blue it looked unreal, grassland running out to wherever the horizon decided to stop.

Seven more days.

I mean, honestly? Good.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter