Chapter 2 ~ Lights Off

{Violet's POV}

I had prepared for him to say yes. 

I had prepared for no, and for the version of no where he laughed first. I had even prepared for him to get up and leave without a word, which is honestly what I would have done in his position.

I had not prepared for him to look at me for ten full seconds and then say, low and flat, "You're sure."

It wasn't a question. It was the way you'd read someone's order back to them.

"Of course I'm sure," I said, a little offended. "I made a list. It has a budget."

"How old are you."

"Eighteen. I have ID." I was already digging through my purse, past the emergency BRIDE TRIBE. "Do you want to see my ID? That kind of defeats the purpose of the mask, but I'll show you—"

"No."

Just no. He didn't explain, and I didn't ask, because I was still elbow-deep in my purse and had just realized how much of it was receipts.

He looked at me a little longer. "Your rules."

So I said them again, slower this time, and in the right order. No names. No phone numbers. Lights off the whole time. I pay half. I leave first. I left out the murder one. It felt like we were past it.

"Okay," he said.

Then he stood, dropped a bill on the table, and walked to the door without checking whether I was behind him. I was. Somewhat shocked, I abandoned my ginger ale, and on the way out, Gus called after us, "Enjoy your night, ma'am."

I'm going to be bitter about that for the rest of my life.

**

The Starlite Motor Inn was ten minutes away, and the man behind the desk never looked up from his phone, which was lucky, because between the two of us we were dressed for a very specific kind of party. 

The stranger paid in cash. That should have been a red flag. Instead it felt like good manners. I counted thirty-eight steps from the lobby to room 14, and when the door shut behind us, the click went all the way down my spine.

The room was motel clean, which is to say I decided not to think about it. Blackout curtains. One lamp. An ice machine right outside the window, buzzing like it had something to prove.

He didn't take off the cap or the mask. He just looked at me, and at the lamp, and waited.

Right. My rule.

I turned it off myself, really nervous now. 

I wanted this but it didn’t take away the fact that I was still cautious and a bit hesitant. Plus, although he didn’t look harmful, this was still a complete stranger which makes this moment add to my list of STRANGER THINGS.

People do this all the time at the clubhouse— strangers taking each other away to go have ‘fun’, but for me, this would always be a first. 

The dark in that room was the total kind, where you can't tell if your eyes are open or closed. I found the bed with my shins and said "ow" very quietly, out of politeness. Then I lay down on my back, still in my dress, and stared up at a ceiling I couldn't see.

This was the part where I'd planned to be brave. Instead my whole body locked up like someone had plugged me into a wall. I heard him moving, the soft sound of fabric, something set down on the dresser, his shoes hitting the carpet one at a time. Then the mattress dipped. 

Then I could feel him over me, close, his weight on his arms, not touching me yet.

I breathed in through my nose for four counts and out for four. Then in again. It's a trick from a YouTube video about panic attacks. I'd watched it eleven times that week, which probably tells you everything.

"You know what's funny," I said to the ceiling. "I'm not even nervous. This is just how I breathe now."

He didn't answer, and he didn't move. He stayed above me, perfectly still, until my breathing settled on its own. I think that was the moment I stopped being scared of him. Not of the rest of it. Just of him.

His hand found my knee first. Then the hem of my dress.

"Okay?" One word, low and oddly gentle. 

"Okay," I muttered, and it came out steadier than anything else I'd said all night.

I'd love to tell you I made a joke here. I had several ready. But they all left.

He kept the mask on. I knew because when he bent his head to my neck, I didn't feel lips. I felt cotton, and his breath coming warm through it, and somehow that was worse, in the best possible way, than anything I'd imagined. 

He never kissed me. Not once, the whole night. I decided it was his rule, the only one he had, and I liked him more for having one.

He took my dress off like there was no hurry anywhere in the world, and in that room there wasn't. His hands learned me in the dark: my arms, my hips, the area just above my groin— places nobody had ever touched me before 

And when his hand slid between my thighs, it stayed there, patient, until I forgot to be embarrassed about anything at all. I stopped counting. I stopped narrating. For maybe the first time in my life, there was nothing in my head.

All I could think of was the warmth taking over me and how needy I was becoming. It was strange in a good way.

Then his thumb found the scar and I went stiff. 

I had forgotten, for one whole minute, that I had anything to hide. His thumb moved along it slowly, the full length of it, like he was reading something.

"Pretty," he said.

In eight years, the only reviews that scar had ever gotten were "What the hell happened?" and, once, from my cousin Tyler, "Gross."

When it happened, it hurt. Not a lot, but enough to surprise me, a sharp catch I wasn't ready for, and he stopped completely. He didn't move again until I did. After that it stopped hurting, and then it turned into something else, something slow and building that I don't have a joke for. 

But now, I had gotten a totally different comment; one my mind didn’t dwell on because it was now focused on the next thing.

Which was him moving past that point and touching me there.

I mean there…

My entire body responded— sparks racing around the entirety of me as his fingers warmed me. He leaned into me then with his weight and the rest was something words failed at describing.

Only sounds did…

**

Several minutes after, I lay there in the dark with my heart going like I'd run somewhere, and I had nothing to say. 

Then I opened my mouth and said, very politely, "Thank you," the way you'd thank someone for holding a door, after which I wanted to crawl under the bed and live there. 

Beside me, he let out one short breath through his nose. It might have been a laugh. I've never decided.

I didn't sleep after that. I listened to him breathe until it went slow and even, and at 5:10, by my phone, which I held face-down against the sheet so the light wouldn't touch him, I got up. 

I found my dress by feel and my shoes by stepping on them. I folded two twenties and left them on the nightstand, or on what I really hoped was the nightstand. I put my mask back on.

When I opened the door, a slice of gray parking-lot light fell across the bed. He was on his side, turned toward the wall, and the mask was still on. He'd slept in it.

I could have taken three steps back into that room and seen whatever was under there. I'm not going to pretend I didn't think about it. But I made the rules, and I wasn't going to be the one who broke them.

I closed the door like it was made of glass, took the mask off in the parking lot, and caught the 5:40 bus home in my wedding-slash-funeral dress, which by then had seen everything.

  • * 

[Nine days later]

My whole life fit into four cardboard boxes and a laundry bag, which was either very minimalist of me or very sad, and I'd decided not to think about which.

Darren turned out to be real. He was in our kitchen making what he called a chef's tasting menu, which was four kinds of Arby's sauce in four little bowls, and my mom was watching him like he'd invented fire. I wished them both well. I mostly meant it.

Meanwhile, I felt different. Not like the internet promises. 

I didn't wake up glowing or wise or suddenly good at eyeliner. I just felt lighter, like I'd put down something I'd been carrying with both arms for a year. 

Whatever happens at Wrenfield, it wasn't going to be my first time anymore. Nobody had watched me be bad at it, and nobody ever would.

The only problem was that the night kept showing up uninvited. 

I'd be folding a towel and feel cotton against my neck. I'd be in line at CVS and suddenly remember a thumb moving slowly along the inside of my thigh, and I'd have to stare very hard at the gum. 

Every time, I shoved it back down. It was one night. It was a rehearsal. You don't keep thinking about the rehearsal.

Cleaning out my purse, I found the backup mask, BRIDE TRIBE still glittering across the front. I held it over the trash can for a long time, then I put it in the box marked COLLEGE, because it was technically worth fifty cents and I'm not made of money.

Later, after packing, I sat on my bare mattress and texted James. “can't wait to see you”.

I deleted the period because it looked too serious, then put it back because without it I looked unhinged.

He answered in under a minute. “me neither. already picked out which waffle machine to show you. the good one. There's a bad one, I'll explain…”

I smiled at my phone like an idiot until the screen went dark and then I got up, ready to leave this town and kickstart my new life as a smug university student. 

Somewhere in this city, a man with no face had forty dollars of mine and a night that was never going to come up again. That was the deal. I was never going to see him again as long as I lived.

I want it on the record that I truly believed that.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter