Chapter 2
Mason sent a message to the group the next morning.
Mason: Graduation photos. Library steps at eleven. Don't be late.
I'd nearly forgotten the photo session. Between finals, graduation plans, and everything that had happened yesterday, I hadn't slept much.
I put on my navy gown and cap, grabbed my bag, and headed across campus.
All four of them were waiting outside the library.
Caleb, Mason, and Lucas wore white button-down shirts with khakis. Paige stood between them in a white sundress, a matching ribbon tied in her hair.
I stopped a few feet away.
Apparently, there had been a dress code.
“Emma!” Paige looked surprised. “You wore your graduation gown?”
“I thought we all were.”
Mason rubbed the back of his neck. “We decided on white last night. Guess we forgot to mention it in the main chat.”
I knew exactly where they'd mentioned it instead.
Caleb took in my outfit. “It's fine. We'll get pictures in the gowns later. Let's do these first.”
The photographer Mason had hired waved them toward the steps. “All right, you four. A little closer together.”
I stayed where I was.
As Paige stepped into position, the wind tugged her ribbon loose. She tried fixing it, but it wouldn't hold.
Before I thought about what I was doing, I reached into my bag and pulled out two bobby pins.
“Here.”
Caleb took them from me and carefully secured the ribbon in her hair.
He smiled. “See? What would we do without Emma? She's ready for anything.”
Next Lucas asked for wipes to clean Paige's shoes. Mason wanted my portable charger.
I handed over both without thinking.
They'd apparently forgotten why I carried half this stuff. Somebody always lost something, forgot to bring it, or realized at the very last minute that they needed it.
“Give me a smile!” the photographer called.
The four of them drew together.
Paige stood in the middle with Caleb's arm across her shoulders. Mason and Lucas leaned toward her, laughing at something she'd said.
They looked great.
After several shots, Caleb glanced at me. “Coming over, Emma?”
The photographer checked his screen. “Just let me finish this arrangement. Then we'll get all five.”
“Okay,” Caleb said.
But when that setup was finished, Paige wanted to go to the fountain. Then she suggested the trees blooming outside the student center.
She held out her phone. “Could you take some candids? You always get our good sides.”
I took it.
For the next half hour, I followed them around campus with their jackets over my arm, taking pictures while they laughed together.
At the fountain, Paige reached up to straighten Caleb's collar. He rested a hand at her waist and smiled down at her.
I paused before pressing the button.
The image came out blurry.
Caleb frowned at the screen. “Emma, seriously. Can't you keep it steady for one shot?”
“Sorry.”
Paige gave a little laugh. “Don't worry about it. She's probably exhausted.”
I took another picture.
That one was sharp.
Paige scrolled through the photos, then smiled and thanked me.
I looked at the screen before returning her phone.
Dozens of nice photos. The same four people in each.
Not one with me in it.
Later, I opened the pictures on my own phone. Birthdays, football games, weekends away, graduation events—hundreds of images from four years of college.
Over and over, those four faces.
I'd been at almost every event.
I'd just been holding the phone.
“Who's hungry?” Mason asked as we headed for the parking lot.
“There's a new barbecue restaurant downtown,” Paige said. “I've heard the smoked ribs are amazing. I've wanted to try it.”
I looked at Caleb. “Someone told me there's peanut butter in their house sauce. You should ask.”
He let out a sigh. “I know I have an allergy, Emma.”
“I was only reminding you.”
“You don't have to remind me of absolutely everything.”
Paige touched his arm. “We can go somewhere else if it's a problem for you.”
“It's not,” he said. “You wanted barbecue. That's where we're going.”
Mason tossed me my keys. “You drive? I'm beat.”
I caught them automatically.
I'd bought the secondhand SUV during sophomore year. I paid for the gas, insurance, and repairs. At some point, everyone else had decided it belonged to all of us.
When we got there, Paige was already sitting up front.
Caleb stood beside the open passenger door.
“She gets carsick in the back.” He held out his hand. “I'll drive. You can take the third row.”
I glanced at the cramped seat behind Mason and Lucas.
Then I handed over my keys.
As we pulled out, Paige brought up pet-friendly rentals in New York.
“I've always wanted a kitten. Maybe I could adopt one after we move.”
Caleb smiled at her. “We'll go to the shelters together.”
“Really?”
“Of course.”
I turned toward the window.
Two years earlier, I'd asked whether we could get a cat after graduation. Caleb said we'd have enough on our plates without me giving us another job to do.
Apparently, getting a cat wasn't always too much trouble.
It depended on whose cat it would be.
Outside, graduates stood with their families in the spring sunshine, laughing and holding bouquets.
I watched them for a moment, then looked away.
Six more days.
After that, I wouldn't have to squeeze myself into the spaces they left me—not even in the car I'd paid for.
