Chapter 3

By the time we reached the barbecue place, Mason was making sure everyone knew how hungry he was.

Paige ordered the smoked ribs she'd talked about all morning. Caleb asked our server about peanuts and chose a burger without the house sauce.

For once, he hadn't needed reminding twice.

When we were nearly done, the server brought over the bill.

“Together or separate?”

“Together,” Mason said, pointing at me. “She'll take care of it.”

I didn't reach for my wallet.

The server hesitated.

“Separate checks, please,” I told her.

Mason stared at me. “Since when? We put it on your card, then Venmo you. That's how we always do it.”

Except the Venmo payments almost never came.

Concert tickets, vacation houses, birthday dinners, the deposit for spring break—I had stopped keeping a running total of everything I'd covered.

I hadn't wanted to know how much it was.

“We can all pay for what we ordered.”

Mason leaned back. “It's forty bucks, Emma. Is that really worth making a fuss?”

Paige reached for her bag. “I'll pay. I said I'd treat everyone.”

Caleb stopped her. “Your scholarship money isn't even here yet.”

He handed the server his own card, then turned to me.

“Happy now?”

I looked at my untouched glass of water.

Asking four adults to buy their own lunch was apparently asking too much.

Caleb barely spoke to me on the drive back. Paige, sitting beside him, occasionally suggested that graduation might be stressing me out.

Eventually, he looked at me in the rearview mirror. “We're all stressed. Emma just has to make everything into an assignment. Every trip needs a spreadsheet. Every cent needs a record.”

Lucas laughed. “That's why hanging out with Paige is easier. She knows how to relax.”

Paige lowered her eyes. “I'd love to be as organized as Emma.”

“You don't have to be,” Caleb said. “Just enjoy yourself.”

I looked out the window.

On my twentieth birthday, he'd given me a ring and promised that someday we'd marry. He said he'd take care of me, that I wouldn't have to be the responsible one all the time.

Two years later, I was still tracking anniversaries, arranging dates, and checking on his parents.

Paige only had to smile.

When we pulled into the Whitmores' driveway, balloons decorated the porch.

“What are we celebrating?” I asked.

Caleb seemed surprised. “Mom's throwing a graduation party. Didn't I tell you?”

He hadn't.

Blue and silver streamers hung in the dining room. A large cake sat on the table among framed pictures from our childhood.

Diane Whitmore hurried out of the kitchen.

“There you four are! I've been waiting.” Then she noticed me. “Oh, Emma. I didn't realize you were coming.”

I looked over her shoulder.

Four names were written on the cake.

Caleb. Mason. Lucas. Paige.

Mine wasn't there.

Diane followed my gaze and gave an awkward laugh. “We didn't know your plans for after graduation, honey. I didn't want to assume.”

“I get it.”

She took Paige by both hands. “Just think—all four of you off to New York together. You must be so excited.”

Paige smiled shyly. “I still can't quite believe it.”

“You have nothing to worry about. Caleb will take good care of you.”

In the living room, Diane presented her with a small velvet box.

Inside was a sapphire pendant on a delicate gold chain.

I caught my breath.

I'd known that necklace since I was little. It had belonged to Caleb's grandmother. Diane had always told me it would be mine when Caleb and I got married.

She'd even let me try it on once.

Now she fastened it around Paige's neck.

“A little something for your new beginning,” she said warmly.

Paige touched the sapphire. “Mrs. Whitmore, it's too much. I can't accept this.”

“Nonsense. You're practically family.” Diane looked at me. “Emma won't mind. She's never been jealous.”

Everyone turned to look at me.

Caleb stood beside his mother, watching Paige admire the stone.

He didn't object.

I touched the ring on my finger.

For years, I'd imagined wearing that sapphire at my wedding.

Now I wondered how I'd let myself trust that promise so completely.

“I don't mind,” I said.

Diane relaxed. “That's our Emma. Always so understanding.”

I looked at the cake again.

My phone vibrated in my pocket. I took it out.

PROJECT NORTHSTAR — URGENT REPORTING SCHEDULE UPDATE

Due to an unexpected change in the program schedule, your arrival has been moved forward. Finish in-person check-in by 5:00 p.m. tomorrow.

Tomorrow.

Instead of six days, I had less than twenty-four hours.

I slipped the phone away and looked around the room one last time.

That was fine with me.

One day was more than enough to leave a life I no longer wanted.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter