Chapter 4
The next morning, I started packing.
I'd lived with Caleb for almost two years. Everything that actually belonged to me fit into two suitcases and a backpack.
Most of the things taking up space were things I'd bought for other people.
I cleared my half of the closet, packed my textbooks, and took down the photos on my side of the bedroom.
On the fridge was the weekly schedule I'd maintained for years.
Caleb's allergist. Mason's insurance renewal. Lucas's dentist. Paige's scholarship paperwork.
I'd added Paige three weeks ago, when she'd moved in. Caleb said she had too much going on and wanted me to keep track of her appointments.
I pulled the schedule off the fridge and threw it away.
The messages had started early.
Mason: Any luck finding us an apartment?
Lucas: Have you seen my enrollment folder? Did you move it?
Paige: Could you come to the bank with me tomorrow, Emma? I've never opened an account in another state.
Then Caleb called.
“So you're ignoring everyone now?”
I put him on speaker and continued folding my clothes.
“I'm busy.”
“Doing what?”
“Packing.”
He went quiet.
“What are you packing for?”
I looked at my open suitcase. “I'm moving out.”
He let out a sharp breath. “If this is about yesterday, you're taking it way too far.”
“It's not about yesterday.”
“Then what? The necklace?”
I didn't answer.
“Come on, Emma. Mom gave Paige a graduation gift. She's had a rough time. Mom wanted to do something nice. Does everything have to be a competition?”
“I didn't say it was.”
“Then stop acting like she stole from you.”
I glanced at my ring.
A promise must have been easy to dismiss when it hadn't been made to you.
“Look,” Caleb said, “we're going to New York. Things won't stay like this. You have to stop managing everybody. We're adults, not kids who need supervision.”
“I know.”
He paused. “You know what?”
“You're right. You can handle your own lives.”
My agreement seemed to irritate him more.
“Whatever. Paige wants to go out tonight. Seven. Try not to make everybody wait for you.”
I zipped the suitcase shut.
“I have other plans.”
“Change them.”
“I'm not going to—”
He'd already hung up.
I stood by the bed and looked at the ring for a while.
I'd worn it every day since my twentieth birthday.
We'd been sitting on the hood of his car when he gave it to me, fireworks lighting up the neighborhood we'd grown up in.
One day, he'd said, we'd be married.
I'd believed him so completely that I had never considered taking the ring off.
Now I slid it from my finger and put it in a little envelope with my key.
I added a note.
Caleb, our relationship is over. Please don't contact me again.
That was all I needed to say.
Over the next hour, I finished separating the practical parts of our lives. I paid my share of the rent to the landlord, removed my card from our shared accounts, and canceled the recurring payments I'd been covering.
Then I opened Splitwise.
Seven years of expenses were waiting there.
Concert tickets. Vacation rentals. Dinners. Deposits I'd paid and then stopped thinking about.
I exported the records and shared them with the others.
I removed Caleb as my emergency contact and turned off location sharing in Find My.
Without my things, the apartment hardly felt like somewhere I'd lived.
I left the envelope on the kitchen counter, where he'd see it when he came home.
Around three, a black SUV pulled up outside.
The driver checked my identification against my reporting documents, then helped load my bags.
“You'll hand over your personal phone when you check in,” he said. “You'll learn about approved communication during orientation.”
“Understood.”
I looked up at the building.
I'd imagined coming home to Caleb after work, night after night. Getting married. Maybe adopting that cat. Building the family I'd missed since my mother died.
I'd thought we both wanted that future.
But I was the only one arranging it.
My phone buzzed again.
The group chat.
Mason: Who's driving us to dinner?
Lucas: Emma can do it.
Paige: I hope she's feeling better. I'd hate for her to miss dinner because of me.
Caleb: She'll come. She always shows up.
I read his last sentence again.
She always shows up.
The same words he'd used in the conversation they hadn't let me see.
He wasn't wrong.
For twenty years, I'd followed along. I'd believed that if I worked hard enough, eventually we would all choose to stay together.
I remembered their guessing game.
Nobody offered a clue or talked things through. We were all supposed to make our own choices.
And somehow, mine was the choice that never matched.
I opened our five-person iMessage chat and wrote a message to send at eight that evening. They'd be at the restaurant by then, expecting me to arrive.
Remember our guessing game? No one was supposed to tell anyone else their choice.
Year after year, you four ended up together, and I ended up on my own.
I've made a choice of my own this time. Now you're the ones I'm leaving behind.
Go ahead. Guess where I am.
I smiled as I read it back.
Thinking about their bewilderment didn't make me feel guilty for once.
It was almost funny.
After twenty years of trying to stay beside them, I was going somewhere they couldn't follow.
I scheduled the message for 8:00 p.m.
Then I muted my phone and handed it to the driver for safekeeping until check-in.
“Ready?” he asked.
I gave the building one last look.
“Ready.”
I climbed into the back seat. As the SUV pulled away, I looked straight ahead.
