
Fool Me Once...Shame On Me
Krystal Novitzke · Completed · 169.6k Words
Introduction
But the line becomes blurred when she catches the eye of Gabriel, a vampire with the name of angel. Suddenly, the boring life of a witch is filled with vampire drama and dark deeds. Forced into a blood oath, she doesn’t truly know how entangled she is until it’s too late. So deeply entangled that not even time will be able to separate them.
Can Hazel handle being torn between who she thought she was, who she wants to be and who she’s becoming.
Chapter 1
It only takes a second for the temperature in the room to drop. My breath turns into a little puff of visible fog. The once enticing aroma of lavender and lemon balm are quickly replaced with the rich smell of dirt. It thickens the air making it hard to breath, even swallow.
“You promised.” Suddenly, the small vial of herbs I clutch is ripped from my grasp. In slow motion I watch the glass drop to the floor. I see the vial burst before my ears hear the crack as it shatters into a million pieces.
“Really Jezmin.” My hands shoot up in frustration, but before I can turn around to face her the temperature goes back to normal and the shiver that started to creep up my back dissipates.
“It’s okay. I’ll clean up the mess.” I argue with myself as I retrieve the broom. “Just keep on popping in and making demands and messes.”
“Not talking to yourself again are you?”
Frantically, my hands grope my chest as if to catch my heart before it leaps into my throat. “Caleb. When...what-”
“You didn’t hear me come in? That gawd awful bell is still ringing in my ears.” His index finger pokes into his ear which is hidden behind a tuft of dark hair. When his deep brown eyes meet my green ones he gives me that side smile that I always adored.
I make my way behind the counter creating a barrier between us, representing our off-again relationship. “What brings you here?” I aimlessly fuss with the collar of my shirt.
“I think you know why I’m here.”
My heart picks up its pace. It hammers against my ribcage and I’m sure he can hear it. Werewolves are like dogs…or is it babies, they can sense your fear.
“Who was it Hazel?” He says in a low voice that at one point had had my heart racing for an entirely different reason.
“I have no idea what you're talking about.” I say trying to gather my composure. My outside self is calm, but my inside self is a quivering mess.
“You’re an awful liar.” He teases. The predator is starting to play cat and mouse.
“I didn’t realize this conversation was about pointing out each other's faults, because you have a long list of negative traits.” I cross my arms over my chest defiantly.
My words dig under his skin, but he does his best holding back a reply. We’ve had this conversation hundreds of times before. “Marcus is out for blood.” He barks at me. “Just tell me who the girl saw.”
I shrug my shoulders refusing to answer, but there’s no missing me flinch when he growls at me. “Why don’t you just ask her if it's that important?”
I’m pretty sure she would rat out a witch especially when it came to her saving her own hide.
“She’s not talking.” He clutches his hand into a fist but quickly shakes it out.
“I wonder why.” I mutter under my breath.
He clears his throat, the sound sets me on edge. “A friend of hers told us she came here for a reading and obviously it was implied that she had a choice, but we all know no one refuses Marcus.”
I know what he really wants to say. No one refuses the alpha.
“Who was it? Monty or Gretchen?” He asks blaming the other two, because I wouldn’t be so stupid to step on anyone’s paws.
My nervousness quickly is replaced with annoyance. “And I’m just supposed to throw one of them under the bus. One of my own under the bus to please a filthy werewolf.”
We both stare at each other. Eyes wide open in shock. Caleb and I were close, but after Marcus became alpha, Caleb’s loyalties were pulled in one direction. And my insults to his alpha, his pack leader could be grounds for punishment.
Thankfully, that deadly gleam in his eyes fades. “You’ve always been good at getting yourself into troublesome situations.”
“What can I say I like to dance with danger.” I joke.
“That’s considered being reckless.” He says in a flat annoyed tone.
“There’s nothing wrong with recklessness. Since vampires and werewolves try to dictate every single minute of everyone’s lives it’s actually quite easy. But this particular recklessness is out of your jurisdiction. You’ll just have to tell Marcus to come down here himself to put the fear into Monty....or Gretchen.” I quickly add, but I know I slipped up. Shit.
“Monty, huh?” He smiles at his detective skills. His lame detective skills. “She seems like the type.” He takes a couple steps back retreating to the door.
I take off at a run rounding the counter and grab a hold of his large muscly arm. It’s incredibly warm under my touch, but my grip doesn’t falter. “You have to promise me that Marcus will not do anything to her.” I shake his arm aggressively, but he barely moves and I’m the one with my head flopping back and forth from the gesture. “Promise me.”
“And what do I get in return for this promise? She’s interfering in werewolf business. You of all people know that’s a no-no.” He shakes his finger in my face as if I’m some child that could be scolded, I slap it away. The heat from his body attacks my chilled one as he leans down getting almost eye level with me. “You weren’t exactly forthcoming with the information and you did insult me along the way.”
“And since when haven’t I insulted you? It would be an insult not to insult you.” By the look on his face I know he’s not buying it. It’s the truth though. Our love hate relationship constantly swapping from hot to cold. Compliments to insults. “A favor for a favor. If you ever need something, cash it in.” I enunciate the word need, which is not to be mistaken for want.
A sneeze starts to tickle at my nose and burns my eyes. I try to hold it in, but a feeble achoo escapes my tense lips right into his chest. “Sorry. Dog allergies.” I sniffle.
Another growl rises from his chest up his throat. “Deal.” He breaks away from me, opening up the front door. The annoying bell rings loudly throughout the shop. “And promise me you’ll stop with the dog jokes.” There’s another flash of that sly smile.
“Is that your favor? A promise for a promise?”
“Not the slightest. Not calling a werewolf filthy or comparing them to pets is just common sense.”
“But I thought we said I was reckless…” I tease and instead of going away, he comes back, taking a large step back into the shop.
“Fair enough.” I quickly add giving him a little shove out. “Good night.” I wiggle my fingers at him while I shut the door. Once the lock clicks he finally starts to walk away.
I clean up the shattered glass and go through the tedious closing procedures. More than an hour later I’m finally able to lock up. I double check, triple check the front door before I leave. The bright neon ‘psychic’ sign and open palm with the words ‘palm reading’ light up the sidewalk.
The three blocks to my apartment seems long on my sore feet. Even though I can make this walk in my sleep my tired mind makes concentrating super hard. And it's only Tuesday.
The streets are bustling with demizens who quietly blend in with loud drunk humans. A group of werewolves circle each other ready to fight down an alley. Tipsy human girls stumble on their too high high heels, giggling at their own stupidity while vampires stalk their every move waiting for their meal to get home or pass out.
Both pathetic breeds. Both make my skin crawl, but both are higher on the social ladder than witches. Only because they demanded themselves to be there. If vampires and werewolves are anything, they’re pompous.
“Hazel, my favorite dealer.” The familiar man’s voice is slurred from too much tonic. He sits on a piece of dirty cardboard on the sidewalk, his clothes worn and stained.
I look down at Gary, the pitiful homeless human that I met on my walk home one night. He was being seduced by a female vamp, the very night he became a true believer that other people, other inhuman people occupy the Earth alongside the human race. He lifts his flask up in cheers.
I kneel down to be eye level with him, the stench that rolls off him hitches my breath. “You don’t go around telling people that do you?” I say through clenched teeth. I can just image the police arresting me for supposed drug trafficking.
He takes a heavy draw from his flask flashing me a ridiculous smile, his brown stained teeth shadowed in the moonlight. I fish out a few vials from the inside of my jacket, “here.” A mixture of holy water and moon bathed rose petals with a touch of homemade dead-wood. Harmless to humans, but can have deadly consequences to vampires.
He greedily takes them. He pours one into his flask and stashes the others in his own tattered jacket pocket. Mumbling under his breath, “damned vampires.”
“Stay safe Gary.” I whisper before walking away leaving him down the darkened alleyway.
A soft little beep from my pocket notifies me of a message on my phone the exact second I cross the threshold to my apartment. It can only be one person. My boss and owner of Mystic Moon, Gretchen.
Just checking in.
And over protective mother hen.
I survived if that’s what you’re asking.
See you tomorrow.
Tomorrow. It starts all over again. Tomorrow.
Last Chapters
#93 93: All Hail The King
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#92 92: I'll Do It For You
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#91 91: It's For The Best
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#90 90: Demizen Superiority
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#89 89: Bitten & Broken
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#88 88: You Want The Truth?
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#87 87: A Meal?
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#86 86: A Witch Is A Witch
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#85 85: That Is Feral
Last Updated: 1/10/2026#84 84: Muscle Memory
Last Updated: 1/10/2026
You Might Like 😍
After the Affair: Falling into a Billionaire's Arms
On my birthday, he took her on vacation. On our anniversary, he brought her to our home and made love to her in our bed...
Heartbroken, I tricked him into signing divorce papers.
George remained unconcerned, convinced I would never leave him.
His deceptions continued until the day the divorce was finalized. I threw the papers in his face: "George Capulet, from this moment on, get out of my life!"
Only then did panic flood his eyes as he begged me to stay.
When his calls bombarded my phone later that night, it wasn't me who answered, but my new boyfriend Julian.
"Don't you know," Julian chuckled into the receiver, "that a proper ex-boyfriend should be as quiet as the dead?"
George seethed through gritted teeth: "Put her on the phone!"
"I'm afraid that's impossible."
Julian dropped a gentle kiss on my sleeping form nestled against him. "She's exhausted. She just fell asleep."
Omega Bound
Thane Knight is the alpha of the Midnight Pack of the La Plata Mountain Range, the largest wolf shifter pack in the world. He is an alpha by day and hunts the shifter trafficking ring with his group of mercenaries by night. His hunt for vengeance leads to one raid that changes his life.
Tropes:
Touch her and die/Slow burn romance/Fated Mates/Found family twist/Close circle betrayal/Cinnamon roll for only her/Traumatized heroine/Rare wolf/Hidden powers/Knotting/Nesting/Heats/Luna/Attempted assassination
The Prison Project
Can love tame the untouchable? Or will it only fuel the fire and cause chaos amongst the inmates?
Fresh out of high school and suffocating in her dead-end hometown, Margot longs for her escape. Her reckless best friend, Cara, thinks she's found the perfect way out for them both - The Prisoner Project - a controversial program offering a life-changing sum of money in exchange for time spent with maximum-security inmates.
Without hesitation, Cara rushes to sign them up.
Their reward? A one-way ticket into the depths of a prison ruled by gang leaders, mob bosses, and men the guards wouldn't even dare to cross...
At the centre of it all, meets Coban Santorelli - a man colder than ice, darker than midnight, and as deadly as the fire that fuels his inner rage. He knows that the project may very well be his only ticket to freedom - his only ticket to revenge on the one who managed to lock him up and so he must prove that he can learn to love…
Will Margot be the lucky one chosen to help reform him?
Will Coban be capable of bringing something to the table other than just sex?
What starts off as denial may very well grow in to obsession which could then fester in to becoming true love…
A temperamental romance novel.
The mafia princess return
The Biker's Fate
I squeezed my eyes shut.
"Dani," he pressed. "Do you get me?"
"No, Austin, I don't," I admitted as I pulled my robe closed again and sat up. "You confuse me."
He dragged his hands down his face. "Tell me what's on your mind."
I sighed. "You're everything my parents warned me against. You're secretive, but you're also honest. I feel wholly protected by you, but then you scare me more than anyone I've ever known. You're a bad boy, but when I dated a so-called good one, he turned out to be the devil, so, yeah, I don't get you because you're not what I expected. You drive me crazier than anyone I've ever met, but then you make me feel complete. I'm feeling things I don't quite know how to process and that makes me want to run. I don't want to give up something that might be really, really good, but I also don't want to be stupid and fall for a boy just because he's super pretty and makes me come."
Danielle Harris is the daughter of an overprotective police chief and has led a sheltered life. As a kindergarten teacher, she's as far removed from the world of Harleys and bikers as you could get, but when she's rescued by the sexy and dangerous Austin Carver, her life is changed forever.
Although Austin 'Booker' Carver is enamored by the innocent Dani, he tries to keep the police chief's daughter at arm's length. But when a threat is made from an unexpected source, he finds himself falling hard and fast for the only woman who can tame his wild heart.
Will Booker be able to find the source of the threat before it's too late?
Will Dani finally give her heart to a man who's everything she's been warned about?
Alpha Nicholas's Little Mate
What? No—wait… oh Moon Goddess, no.
Please tell me you're joking, Lex.
But she's not. I can feel her excitement bubbling under my skin, while all I feel is dread.
We turn the corner, and the scent hits me like a punch to the chest—cinnamon and something impossibly warm. My eyes scan the room until they land on him. Tall. Commanding. Beautiful.
And then, just as quickly… he sees me.
His expression twists.
"Fuck no."
He turns—and runs.
My mate sees me and runs.
Bonnie has spent her entire life being broken down and abused by the people closest to her including her very own twin sister. Alongside her best friend Lilly who also lives a life of hell, they plan to run away while attending the biggest ball of the year while it's being hosted by another pack, only things don't quite go to plan leaving both girls feeling lost and unsure about their futures.
Alpha Nicholas is 28, mateless, and has no plans to change that. It's his turn to host the annual Blue Moon Ball this year and the last thing he expects is to find his mate. What he expects even less is for his mate to be 10 years younger than him and how his body reacts to her. While he tries to refuse to acknowledge that he has met his mate his world is turned upside down after guards catch two she-wolves running through his lands.
Once they are brought to him he finds himself once again facing his mate and discovers that she's hiding secrets that will make him want to kill more than one person.
Can he overcome his feelings towards having a mate and one that is so much younger than him? Will his mate want him after already feeling the sting of his unofficial rejection? Can they both work on letting go of the past and moving forward together or will fate have different plans and keep them apart?
The War God Alpha's Arranged Bride
Yet Alexander made his decision clear to the world: “Evelyn is the only woman I will ever marry.”
Falling for my boyfriend's Navy brother
"What is wrong with me?
Why does being near him make my skin feel too tight, like I’m wearing a sweater two sizes too small?
It’s just newness, I tell myself firmly.
He’s my boyfirend’s brother.
This is Tyler’s family.
I’m not going to let one cold stare undo that.
**
As a ballet dancer, My life looks perfect—scholarship, starring role, sweet boyfriend Tyler. Until Tyler shows his true colors and his older brother, Asher, comes home.
Asher is a Navy veteran with battle scars and zero patience. He calls me "princess" like it's an insult. I can't stand him.
When My ankle injury forces her to recover at the family lake house, I‘m stuck with both brothers. What starts as mutual hatred slowly turns into something forbidden.
I'm falling for my boyfriend's brother.
**
I hate girls like her.
Entitled.
Delicate.
And still—
Still.
The image of her standing in the doorway, clutching her cardigan tighter around her narrow shoulders, trying to smile through the awkwardness, won’t leave me.
Neither does the memory of Tyler. Leaving her here without a second thought.
I shouldn’t care.
I don’t care.
It’s not my problem if Tyler’s an idiot.
It’s not my business if some spoiled little princess has to walk home in the dark.
I’m not here to rescue anyone.
Especially not her.
Especially not someone like her.
She’s not my problem.
And I’ll make damn sure she never becomes one.
But when my eyes fell on her lips, I wanted her to be mine.
Invisible To Her Bully
Rise of the Banished She-Wolf
That roar stole my eighteenth birthday and shattered my world. My first shift should have been glory—blood turned blessing into shame. By dawn they'd branded me "cursed": cast out by my pack, abandoned by family, stripped of my nature. My father didn't defend me—he sent me to a forsaken island where wolfless outcasts were forged into weapons, forced to kill each other until only one could leave.
On that island I learned the darkest edges of humanity and how to bury terror in bone. Countless times I wanted to surrender—dive into the waves and never surface—but the accusing faces that haunted my dreams pushed me back toward something colder than survival: revenge. I escaped, and for three years I hid among humans, collecting secrets, learning to move like a shadow, sharpening patience into precision—becoming a blade.
Then, under a full moon, I touched a bleeding stranger—and my wolf returned with a violence that made me whole. Who was he? Why could he wake what I'd thought dead?
One thing I know: now is the time.
I have waited three years for this. I will make everyone who destroyed me pay—and take back everything that was stolen from me.
My Possessive Alpha Twins For Mate
My drunk stepfather remained indifferent, his weight suffocating, making it hard to breathe as my heart raced.
Suddenly, the door slammed open, and two figures burst in.
"Get off her!" a deafening roar echoed.
I didn't expect the twin brothers who'd bullied me at school to come charging in like gods to save me.
After my grandmother passed, I had to move in with my mom and stepdad, who treated me like a servant. I prayed every day for my 18th birthday to come, so l could leave and escape this broken home.
However, on my first day at my new school, l encountered the legendary twins everyone feared.
To make matters worse, the Moon Goddess revealed they were both my mates!
After helping me out with my stepdad, my twin mate cornered me, played with my hair, and whispered possessively, "You belong to us, our little mate..."
Thornhill Academy
A demon king who would burn realms to keep her safe.
A dragon-shifter whose fire bows to her skin.
A hellhound bound to her soul.
A professor who was never supposed to want her.
And the man who broke for her long before he ever touched her.
Five men. Five obsessions. Five hearts tethered to hers by magic older than the Wall itself.
Hunted, haunted, and newly awakened, Allison is dragged into a rebellion built on blood and belief, the same fight her parents died trying to protect. As enemies close in and desire sharpens into something dangerous, she must decide what kind of power she will become. The weapon the Council always wanted. Or the storm that tears their world apart. Because when Allison rises, kingdoms kneel and when she loves, she loves like war.
Dark Academia | Reverse Harem | Dark Romance | Dark Humour | Action-Packed | Steamy | Unputdownable












