He Married My Sister, Now He Wants Me Back

He Married My Sister, Now He Wants Me Back

Zara Thorne · Completed · 9.6k Words

261
Hot
261
Views
0
Added
Add to Shelf
Start Reading
Share:facebooktwitterpinterestwhatsappreddit

Introduction

In my first life, my husband blamed me for my sister’s death, and my family never defended me. Then we both woke up in the past. This time, Julian chose my sister. My parents shipped me off to Chicago to marry an aging mafia Don. They waited for me to beg. Instead, I packed my bags. On his wedding day, Julian realized I was leaving for good. I was done explaining. Done chasing their approval. He got the second chance he begged for. I got something far better — a life that was mine.

Chapter 1

I died carrying blame that was never mine.

They laid every one of Camila's misfortunes at my feet.

Julian's hatred, my parents' cold bargain, crushed down heavy on my bones.

Then I woke up. Back to this night, the night they sealed my fate. I only had three days. Three days before I was sent to Chicago, traded as a bride to a dying man for an alliance.

Julian carried the same memories as me. This time, he would choose Camila without hesitation.

He would say my suffering should not be a weight on her happiness. Once, I begged him to see me, hoping someone would choose me. Not this time. I would take the path they set for me.

I would go to Chicago. But I would not break. I would not beg. I would never come back to them.


As the banquet drew to a close, Mother cornered me. The moisture glistening in her eyes was orchestrated to perfection.

"Elena, I knew you'd understand," she said. "You've always known how to see the bigger picture."

I said nothing. In my previous life, as I lay bleeding out on the cold floor, a messenger had come to tell her I couldn't hold on much longer. Instead of rushing to the hospital, she had chosen to stay at this exact kind of family gala, never once stepping away to see me.

Camila approached. Across the grand hall, Julian was engaged in a hushed conversation with Father.

"I'm so sorry, Elena," she murmured, her voice dialed down to a whisper as the corners of her eyes instantly flushed red. "Mom told me about the Chicago arrangement. If you didn't have to take my place, you wouldn't be forced to suffer like this."

Eighteen years ago, a rival syndicate attempted to assassinate the Valenti family. During the desperate flight, my parents grabbed Camila and rushed into a safe house, leaving me entirely forgotten in the backseat of the car. The enemy snatched me, realized I held no ransom value, and tossed me into the most vicious, crime-ridden slums of Brooklyn. An Asian woman who washed dishes in Chinatown found me and raised me as her own.

Five years ago, as the Valenti empire suffered a string of crushing losses, they suddenly needed two daughters to secure underground alliances across two cities. Only then did they remember I existed. Had it not been for their own greed and survival, they would have happily left me for dead.

Camila covered her mouth, letting out a delicate, wounded sob.

Hearing her distress, Julian crossed the room and pulled her protectively into his arms.

"What's wrong?"

She leaned against his expensive tailored suit, shaking her head. "I just don't want Elena to hate me because of this."

"Don't cry, baby. This isn't your fault." He pressed a kiss to her hair. But when his gaze shifted to me, every ounce of that tenderness vanished, replaced by a chilling disgust. "I've made my choice. Don't force your misfortune to become Camila's burden."

Mother approached with a flute of champagne, dabbing at the corner of her eye.

"Today should be a celebration. Camila finally gets to marry the man she loves, and our families will be united."

Father and Julian began discussing the wedding date. Only moments later did Father spare a glance in my direction, looking at me as if he had just realized I was standing there.

"Julian, regarding Elena's arrangement—"

"Julian, you promised to help me pick out my wedding band." Camila slipped her hand into his, her voice honey-sweet. "The jeweler is already waiting on the terrace."

Julian's expression instantly melted into warmth. "Alright. Let's go."

Without waiting for Father to finish, she pulled Julian away. The heavy glass doors of the terrace clicked shut behind them.

Father turned back to me. "Camila's wedding is set for three days from now. Elena, you will leave for Chicago on that exact same day. The old Don of the Morettis has given his nod. You'll be married to him by nightfall."

Mother feigned hesitation. "Won't that be a bit too harsh on Elena?"

Father let out a low chuckle, rolling a thick cigar between his fingers. "Her future husband is the Don of the Chicago Moretti family. He's riddled with sickness and barely has long to live, but the territory, dirty money, and raw power in his grip are beyond imagination." He looked at me, forcing a sickeningly sweet smile. "Elena, Daddy is truly happy for you."

The murmurs of family elders and guests drifted into my ears.

"The one in Chicago? Word is, his hands are soaked in blood debts."

"He's nearly seventy, clinging to life on a ventilator."

"Poor Elena. Barely back home for five years, and she's already being used as a bargaining chip."

In my past life, hearing those whispers would have sent me hiding in the bathroom, breaking down into uncontrollable sobs.

This time, my face remained perfectly blank. I picked up my glass of red wine and took a slow, deliberate sip.

As it was time to leave, Julian and Camila walked ahead. My parents followed closely behind them, excitedly discussing the lavish arrangements for the upcoming wedding. No one noticed that I had fallen far behind.

Julian pulled open the heavy door of the bulletproof Rolls-Royce, leaning down to smooth out Camila's dress before gently shielding her as she climbed in. Camila tilted her head back and pressed a lingering kiss to his cheek.

"Seeing how much Julian dotes on her, we can finally rest easy," Father said, patting Mother's hand before sliding into the pristine leather seats.

It played out exactly like my past life. Not a single person looked back at me.

I glanced down at the evening gown I wore. The hem was far too long, dragging heavily against the rough asphalt—it was an old, out-of-season piece that Camila had grown tired of. Mother had claimed that altering it would be a waste of money, insisting I should just wear her hand-me-downs. Throughout the banquet, every socialite had praised Camila for her generosity in lending such expensive gowns to her older sister. Naturally, no one ever bothered to ask if I actually wanted to wear someone else's discarded clothes.

Julian shut the car door and finally noticed me lingering in the shadows. He frowned and strode over, his posture dripping with condescension.

"Elena, there's no need to put on that face," he said coldly. "Even if I marry Camila, it's not like no one will accept you. Once the marriage is settled, the drama will blow over. You'll get used to it."

He was absolutely certain I would stay, quietly swallowing down every ounce of my humiliation.

"I understand," I replied, my voice deadpan.

Julian studied me, a fleeting shadow of unease crossing his eyes. The old Elena would have cried. She would have fought. She would have begged.

After a brief, loaded silence, he turned around and got into the car. The motorcade pulled out in sequence, quickly swallowed by the pitch-black night.

My phone buzzed in my clutch. A text message lit up the screen:

[We forgot you weren't in the car. Just call an Uber back.]

The 'me' from my past life had long grown accustomed to being abandoned.

Arriving back at the family estate alone, I found Camila waiting for me in the grand living room, a massive diamond gleaming heavily on her ring finger.

"Elena, right after you walked away, Julian officially proposed to me. He said he was so grateful that fate gave him the chance to choose again." She rubbed the face of the diamond, entirely unable to hide the triumphant gleam in her eyes. "Thank you for letting us be together."

I offered a faint, hollow smile, said nothing, and turned to head upstairs to my room.

Camila's triumphant words only confirmed what I already knew. Julian had chosen her, exactly as he had in our past life.

The bedroom door clicked shut behind me. My eyes drifted to the half-packed suitcase sitting in the corner.

I only had three days left before I could escape this blood-soaked cage.

This time, I would go to Chicago exactly as they wished. And I would never come back.

Last Chapters

You Might Like 😍

OUR NEW BEGINNING

OUR NEW BEGINNING

3.1k Views · Completed · Thalimaedaalicia
Olivia spent years loving Brian in silence, trapped in a relationship with no promises, no certainties, and no future. Whilst she waited to be chosen, he always found a way to slip away.

Until the day she left.

Determined to start afresh, far from everything that hurt her, Olivia decides to leave the past behind. But some ties cannot be severed so easily.

Months later, an unexpected reunion brings the two face to face once more — and Brian realises, too late, that he has lost far more than he ever imagined.

Now, amidst hurt, secrets, and feelings that never truly faded, they must discover whether the love they destroyed in the past is still strong enough to deserve a second chance.

Because some stories end.
Others simply wait for the right moment to begin again.
Cue the Dark

Cue the Dark

1.5k Views · Ongoing · lanre23231
Wren Castellane takes the stage manager job at the Regatta Playhouse to outrun a failed marriage and a stalled career, not to reopen a cold case. But the theater hasn't staged “The Drowning Room” since 1994, the night its leading lady walked into the tide and never came back. Reviving the play for the theater's centenary means working under Julian Voss, the owner's grandson, a man who canceled every production of that script for thirty years and won't say why. As opening night approaches, someone starts leaving Wren notes in the dead woman's handwriting, moving props between rehearsals, humming her exact vocal warm-up in the wings when the building's empty. Julian knows more than he's telling. So does the theater's aging costumer, who flinches every time the drowned actress's name comes up. Wren has three weeks to get the show up — and to find out whether she's staging a play or walking into someone else's unfinished ending
Call me Mom :Mated to my EX's Alpha Father

Call me Mom :Mated to my EX's Alpha Father

5.5k Views · Ongoing · IdeaInk Six Cats
One more time?" ML's voice was hoarse as he gently nibbled on FL's earlobe. FL's cheeks flushed. "Don’t ”she said. ML smiled. "What? Don't stop?" FL was lost in the wonderful feeling. In a daze, she recalled days long ago when she had waited at her wedding for her husband, whom she had never met. The wedding had already begun, but the groom was nowhere to be seen. Her hands and feet were cold as she faced the whispers of the guests alone. Then came the news: her groom, the future Alpha, had eloped with a ROGUE! Facing everyone's ridicule, FL decisively decided to change husbands on the spot. After all, it was just a political marriage. If she had to choose one, she would choose the strongest man. Amidst the gasps of the crowd, she fixed her gaze on the handsome and mature man, the most powerful Alpha, who was also her fiancé's stepfather. The man, 13 years her senior, firmly took FL's hand, and the two completed the wedding ceremony. Their married life was blissful and sweet, the only flaw being the rumor that ML was infertile due to an injury. As their relationship deepened, FL discovered it was just a rumor. Every time FL tried to escape, clutching her back, the strong man behind her would pull her back to bed. FL gasped, snapping out of her reverie to find ML straining against her, looking at her with a wronged expression: "You're distracted."
Tempted By The Enemy

Tempted By The Enemy

4.5k Views · Completed · rituparna darolia
Twenty-two-year-old Alyssa Van Every is in a dilemma. Her close friend, Sienna, is marrying billionaire, Lucas Donnelly who, along with his brothers, happens to be her older brother, Alex's sworn enemy.
She escapes to Preston Island to attend the wedding without informing him only to collide with Lucas’s hot, fiery and arrogant brother, the twenty-three-year-old, Nicholas Donnelly. Sparks immediately fly between them but Alyssa refuses to acknowledge them fearing her brother's wrath.
The wedding is over and Alyssa tries hard to forget the mysterious Nicholas Donnelly but can he forget her? Can he ignore the attraction he feels for her, feelings that have resurfaced after ten years?
What will Allyssa do when she is stalked by the man who has been invading her dreams since the day she met him? What will she do when she is whisked away to a deserted island by the unpredictable Nicholas Donnelly? Can she tame her heart or surrender to sinful temptations? Read to find out!
Part of the Temptation Series. Can be read as a standalone.
The Family Books 1-3 (A Mafia romance)

The Family Books 1-3 (A Mafia romance)

3.1k Views · Completed · Emma Mountford
Saints and Sinners- She was the light to my dark.
The saint to my sinner. with her innocent eyes and devilish curves.
A Madonna that was meant to be admired but never touched.
Until someone took that innocence from her.
She left.
The darkness in my heart was finally complete.
I avenged her, I killed for her, but she never came back.
Until I saw her again. An angel dancing around a pole for money.
She didn’t know I owned that club. She didn’t know I was watching.
This time I won’t let her escape.
I will make her back into the girl I knew.
Whether she likes it or not.
2/ Judge and Jury- I can’t stop watching her.

I’m not even sure I want to.

Taylor Lawson, blonde, beautiful, and totally oblivious to how much dangers she’s in.

She’s also the one juror in my upcoming murder trial that hasn’t been bought.

The one who can put me behind bars for a very long time.

I know I should execute her.
After all that’s what I do.

I am the Judge.
I eliminate threats to The Family.
And Taylor is a threat.
But I don’t want to kill her.
Possessing her, making her love me seems like a much better plan for this particular Juror.

3/ Rags and Ritches-
Omega Bound

Omega Bound

2.9m Views · Completed · Veronica White
Ayla Frost is a beautiful, rare omega. Kidnapped, tortured, and trafficked to rogue clans and corrupt alphas to do with as they pleased.  Kept alive in her cage, broken and abandoned by her wolf, she becomes mute and has given up on hope for a better life until one explosion changes everything. 

Thane Knight is the alpha of the Midnight Pack of the La Plata Mountain Range, the largest wolf shifter pack in the world. He is an alpha by day and hunts the shifter trafficking ring with his group of mercenaries by night. His hunt for vengeance leads to one raid that changes his life. 

Tropes:
Touch her and die/Slow burn romance/Fated Mates/Found family twist/Close circle betrayal/Cinnamon roll for only her/Traumatized heroine/Rare wolf/Hidden powers/Knotting/Nesting/Heats/Luna/Attempted assassination
The CEO's Midnight Remedy

The CEO's Midnight Remedy

216.5k Views · Completed · CalebWhite
They thought they could destroy me. They were wrong.

My name is Aria Harper, and I just caught my fiancé Ethan screwing my stepsister Scarlett in our bed. While my world crumbled, they were planning to steal everything—my inheritance, my mother's legacy, even the company that should be mine.

But I'm not the naive girl they think I am.

Enter Devon Kane—eleven years older, dangerously powerful, and exactly the weapon I need. One month. One secret deal. Use his influence to save my company while I uncover the truth about my mother Elizabeth's "death" and the fortune they stole from me.

The plan was simple: fake my engagement, seduce information from my enemies, and walk away clean.

What I didn't expect? This insomniac billionaire who can only sleep when I'm in his arms. What he didn't expect? That his convenient arrangement would become his obsession.

In daylight, he's a master of indifference—his gaze sliding past me like I don't exist. But when darkness falls, he's pushing up my lace dress, his hands claiming my breasts through the sheer material, his mouth finding the small mole on my collarbone.

"That's it," he breathes against my skin, voice strained and gravelly. "God, you feel amazing."

Now the lines are blurred, the stakes are higher, and everyone who betrayed me is about to learn what happens when you underestimate Aria Harper.

Revenge never felt so good.
Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

2.9k Views · Ongoing · Sand Kastle
ARDEN: I always thought getting accepted into Elite Order Academy would finally make my family proud.
Perhaps then they would stop controlling my every move. Maybe my brothers would stop resenting me. Perhaps I wouldn’t feel so invisible anymore.
No one believed I could do it—not even my mate, Alpha Jaxon Trevane.
The night I planned to tell him... I found him tangled in bed with my best friend.
Heartbroken and humiliated, I left everything behind and went to Elite alone.
But the academy isn’t the fairytale I dreamed about.
Beneath the grand halls and traditions, a brutal game is being played.
The four ruling Alphas of the North, South, East, and West fight for power, dominance... and now, for me.
A virgin. Untouched. Unclaimed. The prize they all want.
There’s the mate who shattered my heart and swears he’ll win me back.
The brilliant strategist who wants me as his Luna.
The dangerous playboy who promises no one will ever touch me but him.
And the cold, possessive Alpha who watches from the shadows—and would destroy anyone who dares to take me from him.
But in a place where love is a battlefield and lust is a weapon... falling in love might be the most dangerous thing I ever do.
Welcome to Elite Order Academy—where every desire has a price, and my body is the ultimate trophy.
Mating Moon

Mating Moon

218.6k Views · Completed · loreleidelacruz
Ashlynn had just graduated Veterinary School, excited to find a job. She was living with her parents on the edge of Pack Land, her father not wanting them to close to anyone. Her father was violent, and often abused her mother. Her mother refused to tell anyone and made Ashlynn keep it secret. Things changed as soon as Ashlynn's father attacked her. When the Alpha intervened, Ashlynn and her mother moved away to avoid embarrassment. Will this new Pack offer them comfort, or more danger?
Off Limits On Purpose

Off Limits On Purpose

3.5k Views · Completed · Mercy Charles
Star Davis stopped letting people in at fourteen, the year her father left without a fight or an explanation — just a quiet withdrawal that taught her exactly what happened when you trusted someone with the real version of yourself.
So she built rules. Four of them. Written in the front of a notebook she carries everywhere.
Alex Carter was never supposed to get past the first one.
But he did. Slowly, without asking permission, in libraries and coffee carts and late nights that ran longer than either of them planned. He got past all of them. And somewhere in the middle of a semester Star didn't expect, she stopped guarding herself so carefully around him.
What she doesn't know is that he has a secret. A bet made in September, a deadline in December, and teammates who were watching from the beginning.
What he didn't expect is that it would stop mattering — and that by the time he understood why, it might already be too late.
She gave him everything she never gives anyone.
He just hasn't told her what it cost.
Werewolf's Heartsong

Werewolf's Heartsong

21.2k Views · Completed · DizzyIzzyN
The LCD screen in the arena showed pictures of the seven fighters in the Alpha Class. There I was, with my new name.
I looked strong, and my wolf was absolutely gorgeous.
I looked to where my sister is sitting and her and the rest of her posse have jealous fury on their faces. I then look up to where my parents are and they're glaring at my picture, if looks alone could set shit on fire.
I smirk at them then I turn away to face my opponent, everything else falling away but what was here on this platform. I take my skirt and cardigan off. Standing in just my tank and capris, I move into a fighting position and wait for the signal to start -- To fight, to prove, and not hide myself anymore.
This was going to be fun. I thought, a grin on my face.

Mature Audience Only: Contains mature luangege, sex, abuse and violence
The Wolfless Girl He Marked

The Wolfless Girl He Marked

8k Views · Completed · Lunarve
"You have no wolf."

In a world where your wolf determines your power, your rank, and your worth, those four words are a death sentence.

Vivienne Frost was born to inherit the most ancient Pack in the North. Silver wolf bloodline. Destined for power.

But on the night of her Awakening Ceremony, nothing answered.

Her father stopped seeing her as his daughter. She became a bargaining chip — traded into a political marriage with an Alpha she never chose.

So she runs.

Under a fake identity, Vivienne enters Thornfield Academy to uncover who is being groomed to replace her. But the most dangerous thing at Thornfield isn't the conspiracy.

It's Kael Thorne.

The most feared Alpha in the academy. A man raised to be a weapon, who has never let anyone close enough to see what that cost him.

Vivienne breaks that rule on day one.

She notices his scars. Challenges his dominance. Refuses to fear him.

And his wolf responds to her.

When danger closes in, Kael makes a choice no one expects — he marks her. Not because he trusts her. Because protecting her becomes the one instinct he can't fight.

But the girl they called wolfless was never truly empty.

Something ancient is waking inside her blood.

And the Alpha who marked her will have to choose — protect the bond, or let them both burn.