Everyone Who Loved Me Ended Up Loving Her

Everyone Who Loved Me Ended Up Loving Her

Piper Hayes · Completed · 6.4k Words

319
Hot
326
Views
0
Added
Add to Shelf
Start Reading
Share:facebooktwitterpinterestwhatsappreddit

Introduction

Everyone who ever cared about me ended up choosing the same girl.

Her name was Margot Ellery. We’d shared a bunk bed at the orphanage.

For as long as I could remember, I’d been able to see a number above people’s heads. The higher it climbed, the more they favored her.

At the orphanage, there was one teacher who’d always been especially kind to me. The month her number reached 64, the extra almond cookie at the bottom of my bowl disappeared. She stopped reaching for my hand, too.

The day before our wedding, my fiancé’s number stood at 91. He hemmed and hawed, then said maybe we should put off the wedding a little longer. There was lipstick on his shirt collar.

“Okay,” I said. That night, I took my suitcase and left the city.

Not long after that, my birth family found me: Don Vincent of the Castellane family, his wife, Helena, and my brother, Matteo, who seemed ready to do anything for me.

Still, I couldn’t help testing them. Every time I praised Margot, the numbers above their heads dropped, until all three reached negative fifty thousand.

That was when I finally trusted them. They felt like family to me.

Then came my birthday party. The three chairs at the head table stayed empty.

They finally walked in as the party was winding down. Above each of their heads was the same number.

Chapter 1

Thea's POV

Everyone who ever cared about me ended up choosing the same girl.

Her name was Margot Ellery. We’d shared a bunk bed at the orphanage.

For as long as I could remember, I’d been able to see a number above people’s heads. The higher it climbed, the more they favored her.

At the orphanage, there was one teacher who’d always been especially kind to me. The month her number reached 64, the extra almond cookie at the bottom of my bowl disappeared. She stopped reaching for my hand, too.

The day before our wedding, my fiancé’s number stood at 91. He hemmed and hawed, then said maybe we should put off the wedding a little longer. There was lipstick on his shirt collar.

“Okay,” I said. That night, I took my suitcase and left the city.

Not long after that, my birth family found me: Don Vincent of the Castellane family, his wife, Helena, and my brother, Matteo, who seemed ready to do anything for me.

Still, I couldn’t help testing them. Every time I praised Margot, the numbers above their heads dropped, until all three reached negative fifty thousand.

That was when I finally trusted them. They felt like family to me.

Then came my birthday party. The three chairs at the head table stayed empty.

They finally walked in as the party was winding down. Above each of their heads was the same number.


“Thea, honey, we’re so late.”

Mom hurried across the half-empty banquet hall. Guests were already collecting their coats.

Dad followed, avoiding my eyes. Matteo said a shipment had been held up at the docks. They’d come straight from the negotiations.

My parents glanced at each other. I’d seen that look before. Each was waiting for the other to speak.

I checked the numbers above their heads.

I said nothing. I’d been through this too many times. I was already figuring out how to leave without making a scene.

Mom must have noticed how hard I was working to keep smiling, because her own smile faltered. Her fingers trembled a little as she tucked my hair behind my ear.

“We let you down. We won’t leave you waiting like this again.”

Dad nodded to a server, who wheeled a cart through a side door. On it sat a three-tier tower of lemon tarts. Dad fastened a small silver clip in my hair, studied it for a moment, then nodded.

“No tears tonight, birthday girl.”

They looked at me as though I were something precious they’d spent half their lives searching for.

I might have believed they’d simply gotten stuck in traffic, if I hadn’t seen those numbers go from negative fifty thousand to 12.

Matteo raised his instant camera.

The server lifted the cover.

The tower had collapsed. The icing flowers on top tilted to one side. The tart shells had caved in on one another, and lemon filling had seeped through the gaps and pooled on the cart.

No one spoke.

Someone had to clean it up. I got to my feet and picked up the platter. I’d been looking forward to this for months. I carried it over to the trash can in the corner.

“It’s fine,” I said. “I don’t eat sweets anymore anyway.”

Matteo came after me and lowered his voice.

“We’ll be up all night closing this deal. Once it’s done, we’re going to the cabin by the lake. A whole week, just like I promised.”

He had dark circles under his eyes, and his shirt collar was rumpled. None of them had gotten a full night’s sleep in weeks.

My throat tightened. I stared down at the edge of the platter.

Then the last voice I wanted to hear came from the doorway.

“Sorry to interrupt, Don. I just need your signature on the last page.”

Margot stood there in a navy suit, a Castellane Holdings pin on her lapel and a stack of papers in her hand.

My chest felt as if someone had reached inside and squeezed.

Matteo’s face lit up. “Margot? What are you doing here?”

My parents both broke into smiles before they had time to hide them.

Mom glanced at me and spoke gently.

“We almost got cheated on that deal today. Margot spotted a problem in the contract and saved us thirty million dollars.”

“The Brandt family set us up,” Dad added.

Margot came over and linked arms with Mom, a shy smile on her face.

“I just gave it another look. It was no big deal.”

Dad looked pleased.

“Well, that extra look was worth thirty million. No more working on the sidelines. From now on, you’ll work directly with me.”

They started talking business. I stood off to the side, empty-handed.

Just like at the orphanage. Wherever Margot went, I ended up in the background.

When I snapped out of it, she was standing between Dad and Matteo, with Mom’s hand on her shoulder.

The numbers above their heads had gone up again.

I clenched my fists and coughed twice, hard.

Matteo finally turned around. “Are you feeling okay?”

Mom immediately pressed a hand to my forehead. Dad pulled out his car keys and insisted on taking me to the hospital. Nothing I said would change his mind.

When we reached the car, Margot’s phone rang.

She checked the screen and said a few quiet words. By the time she hung up, her eyes were red.

Matteo let go of the car door.

“Was that the Brandts? Are they still giving you trouble?”

Margot shook her head, putting on a brave face. Her expression told a different story.

“It’s nothing. Just a little disagreement. I can handle it.”

“A little disagreement?” Mom said. “They think they can push you around because you’re a young woman.”

Dad was already typing a message, his jaw tight.

“I’ll meet with them myself tomorrow. They don’t get to touch my people.”

Mom turned to take Margot’s arm. I caught her sleeve.

“What about me?”

Mom had never looked at me with such impatience before.

She sighed, speaking to me as though I were a child refusing to get in the car.

“I know you and Margot have had your misunderstandings. But she saved us today.”

“Can’t you be a little more mature and follow her example?”

Last Chapters

You Might Like 😍

Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

2.9k Views · Ongoing · Sand Kastle
ARDEN: I always thought getting accepted into Elite Order Academy would finally make my family proud.
Perhaps then they would stop controlling my every move. Maybe my brothers would stop resenting me. Perhaps I wouldn’t feel so invisible anymore.
No one believed I could do it—not even my mate, Alpha Jaxon Trevane.
The night I planned to tell him... I found him tangled in bed with my best friend.
Heartbroken and humiliated, I left everything behind and went to Elite alone.
But the academy isn’t the fairytale I dreamed about.
Beneath the grand halls and traditions, a brutal game is being played.
The four ruling Alphas of the North, South, East, and West fight for power, dominance... and now, for me.
A virgin. Untouched. Unclaimed. The prize they all want.
There’s the mate who shattered my heart and swears he’ll win me back.
The brilliant strategist who wants me as his Luna.
The dangerous playboy who promises no one will ever touch me but him.
And the cold, possessive Alpha who watches from the shadows—and would destroy anyone who dares to take me from him.
But in a place where love is a battlefield and lust is a weapon... falling in love might be the most dangerous thing I ever do.
Welcome to Elite Order Academy—where every desire has a price, and my body is the ultimate trophy.
The Alpha King's Human Mate

The Alpha King's Human Mate

472k Views · Completed · HC Dolores
“You must understand something, little mate,” Griffin said, and his face softened,

“I have waited nine years for you. That’s nearly a decade since I’ve felt this emptiness inside me. Part of me began to wonder if you didn’t exist or you’d already died. And then I found you, right inside my own home.” 

He used one of his hands to stroke my cheek and tingles erupted everywhere. 

“I’ve spent enough time without you and I will not let anything else keep us apart. Not other wolves, not my drunken father who’s barely holding himself together the past twenty years, not your family  – and not even you.”


Clark Bellevue has spent her entire life as the only human in the wolf pack - literally. Eighteen years ago, Clark was the accidental result of a brief affair between one of the most powerful Alphas in the world and a human woman. Despite living with her father and her werewolf half-siblings, Clark has never felt like she really belonged in the werewolf world. But right as Clark plans to leave the werewolf world behind for good, her life gets flipped upside down by her mate: the next Alpha King, Griffin Bardot. Griffin has been waiting years for the chance to meet his mate, and he's not about to let her go anytime soon. It doesn't matter how far Clark tries to run from her destiny or her mate - Griffin intends to keep her, no matter what he has to do or who stands in his way.
Exchanging Vows: The Swapped Wife Is a Top Shaman

Exchanging Vows: The Swapped Wife Is a Top Shaman

8.1k Views · Ongoing · IdeaInk Six Cats
Ivy’s life fell apart in one night. The betrayal of being cheated on with her own cousin… it hit hard.On the night she was meant to become a wife, she was instead betrayed in the worst way possible. The man she was supposed to marry chose her own cousin over her… right in front of everyone. No shame, no regret. She was cast aside as if she meant nothing. By morning, everything changed.Instead of walking away, Ivy was forced into another marriage… this time to the Alpha heir, a man lying in a vegetative state. It wasn’t love or choice. It was simply where she found herself.The Alpha heir was originally her cousin’s husband-to-be, but not anymore. Now, she and her cousin have swapped places… and the men they were supposed to marry.People laughed, they mocked her. A beta’s daughter tied to a man who couldn’t even open his eyes.But that didn’t break Ivy. Because while everyone saw a weak, humiliated bride… she was secretly a top shaman.Disguised as someone else to keep her identity hidden, she became someone powerful, someone untouchable… a great healer, the most powerful and popular shaman anyone had ever heard of, and the only one capable of being Dominic’s cure.
Mating Moon

Mating Moon

218.6k Views · Completed · loreleidelacruz
Ashlynn had just graduated Veterinary School, excited to find a job. She was living with her parents on the edge of Pack Land, her father not wanting them to close to anyone. Her father was violent, and often abused her mother. Her mother refused to tell anyone and made Ashlynn keep it secret. Things changed as soon as Ashlynn's father attacked her. When the Alpha intervened, Ashlynn and her mother moved away to avoid embarrassment. Will this new Pack offer them comfort, or more danger?
Accardi

Accardi

1.3m Views · Completed · Allison Franklin
“I thought we discussed this earlier, Weakness? I warned you. His death is on your hands.”
“I thought you said you were done chasing me?” Gen mocked.
“I am done chasing you.”
Before she could formulate a witty remark, Matteo threw her down. She landed hard on her back atop his dining room table. She tried to sit up when she noticed what he was doing. His hands were working on his belt. It came free of his pants with a violent yank. She collapsed back on her elbows, her mouth gaping open at the display. His face was a mask of sheer determination, his eyes were a dark gold swimming with heat and desire. His hands wrapped around her thighs and pulled her to the edge of the table. He glided his fingers up her thighs and hooked several around the inside of her panties. His knuckles brushed her dripping sex.
“You’re soaking wet, Genevieve. Tell me, was it me that made you this way or him?” his voice told her to be careful with her answer. His knuckles slid down through her folds and she threw her head back as she moaned. “Weakness?”
“You…” she breathed.


Genevieve loses a bet she can’t afford to pay. In a compromise, she agrees to convince any man her opponent chooses to go home with her that night. What she doesn’t realize when her sister’s friend points out the brooding man sitting alone at the bar, is that man won’t be okay with just one night with her. No, Matteo Accardi, Don of one of the largest gangs in New York City doesn’t do one night stands. Not with her anyway.
Call me Mom :Mated to my EX's Alpha Father

Call me Mom :Mated to my EX's Alpha Father

5.5k Views · Ongoing · IdeaInk Six Cats
One more time?" ML's voice was hoarse as he gently nibbled on FL's earlobe. FL's cheeks flushed. "Don’t ”she said. ML smiled. "What? Don't stop?" FL was lost in the wonderful feeling. In a daze, she recalled days long ago when she had waited at her wedding for her husband, whom she had never met. The wedding had already begun, but the groom was nowhere to be seen. Her hands and feet were cold as she faced the whispers of the guests alone. Then came the news: her groom, the future Alpha, had eloped with a ROGUE! Facing everyone's ridicule, FL decisively decided to change husbands on the spot. After all, it was just a political marriage. If she had to choose one, she would choose the strongest man. Amidst the gasps of the crowd, she fixed her gaze on the handsome and mature man, the most powerful Alpha, who was also her fiancé's stepfather. The man, 13 years her senior, firmly took FL's hand, and the two completed the wedding ceremony. Their married life was blissful and sweet, the only flaw being the rumor that ML was infertile due to an injury. As their relationship deepened, FL discovered it was just a rumor. Every time FL tried to escape, clutching her back, the strong man behind her would pull her back to bed. FL gasped, snapping out of her reverie to find ML straining against her, looking at her with a wronged expression: "You're distracted."
This Time He Pursues Me With All

This Time He Pursues Me With All

77.6k Views · Completed · Sherry
Maya froze when the man who drew every eye in the room walked in. Her ex-boyfriend, who‘d vanished five years ago, was now one of Boston’s richest tycoons. Back then, he’d never hinted at his identity—then he’d disappeared without a trace. Seeing his cold gaze now, she could only assume he’d hidden the truth to test her, decided she was vain, and left in disappointment.

Outside the ballroom, she went to him as he smoked by the door, wanting to at least explain herself.

“Are you still angry with me?”

He flicked the cigarette away and looked at her with open contempt. “Angry? You think I’m angry? Let me guess—Maya finally finds out who I am and now she wants to ‘reconnect.’ Another chance now that she knows my last name comes with money.”

When she tried to deny it, he cut in. “You were a blip. A footnote. If you hadn’t shown up tonight, I wouldn’t have remembered you.”

Tears stung her eyes. She almost told him about his daughter, but stopped. He’d only think she was using the child to trap him and get his money.

Maya swallowed everything back and left, certain they would never cross paths again—only for him to keep appearing in her life, until he was the one lowering himself, humbly begging her to take him back.
His Tamed Wife, The Wild Heiress

His Tamed Wife, The Wild Heiress

2.5k Views · Ongoing · Audrey C Leilani
She married him out of desperation, becoming the perfect docile wife while he treated her like dirt beneath his shoes. But everything shattered the night she overheard him mocking her with his friends-and discovered the necklace she'd cherished, her only link to the boy who once saved her life, didn't even belong to him.
It was all a lie.

No longer the doormat he married, she discards her fake identity and reclaims her birthright as the hidden heiress of Salvadore City. Now she's on a mission: find the necklace's true owner among his circle of friends, no matter how many hearts she has to break along the way.

But her husband isn't ready to let go. Convinced she's playing games to make him jealous, he's blindsided when divorce papers land in his hands. By the time he realizes the woman he dismissed was never who he thought she was, she's already moved on-living her truth, chasing her destiny, and leaving him choking on regret.

Some cages, once opened, can never be closed again.
The Spy Who Left

The Spy Who Left

2.2k Views · Completed · Orion Vale
"She's naive. A pretty little socialite who got lucky marrying above her station."
"I still can't believe she actually did it. Aria Hart, filing for divorce. Who saw that coming?"
"How long do we think it'll take before she comes crawling back?" Another voice joins the conversation.
"Three days," Victoria declares. "Five at most. She has no money, no skills, no family. Where's she going to go?"
When Aria Chen divorced billionaire Leon Hart, New York's elite sneered, betting she'd crawl back within days. She never did.
Three years later, the world is rocked when Dr. Aria Vale, CEO of a revolutionary cybersecurity empire, steps into the spotlight. The mysterious genius who built a billion-dollar company from nothing is none other than Leon's discarded wife, the woman everyone thought was just a pretty ornament.
Now, every powerful man wants the queen Leon threw away a renowned scientist seeking partnership, a financial titan proposing an empire, and an actor offering devotion. Each sees the brilliance Leon ignored.
Then Leon discovers the truth: Aria's sacrifices, her secret double life, and the daughter she's been raising without him. For the first time, the man who once took her for granted must fight for her love. But can he compete with men who valued her from the beginning?
A story of love, betrayal, and power where the king must kneel before the queen who never needed saving.
Tango 2 the Alpha's Heart

Tango 2 the Alpha's Heart

3.5k Views · Completed · judels.lalita
"Eyes up here," he said.

My gaze snapped to his. He was smiling, causing my heart to skip a painful beat. Before I could respond, the music began, and my body instinctively reacted to the sweet melody.

I found myself molded to Lex's will, my feet irresistibly following the dance steps.

The crowd gasped as Lex pulled me into a more intimate position, his hands roaming over my body in a seductive manner.

The experience was both terrifying and magical, allowing me to feel every longing emotion through the dance.

I soon found myself lost in his arms.

When the music finally stopped, my arms were wrapped around his neck, his hands resting on my back, our noses almost touching. He gazed deeply into my eyes.

The ballroom fell silent.

Was he about to kiss me?


Lilly’s life was never easy; she lost her memory and family in a blazing fire. Angelica found and took her in—only to make her a slave to the household.

Years of torment and abuse left Lilly weak, vulnerable, and believing she was without a wolf, but that didn't mean that all hope was lost.

At night, in her dreams, he would patiently wait for her—the man who brought sunshine into her darkest moments.

They would dance the night away, but as dawn approached, he would vanish into the morning sun.

Lilly had given up hope of finding a mate, having a family, and leading a normal life.

But things are about to drastically change for her...

Secrets, lies, betrayal... and a baby on the way.

What if Lilly wasn't wolf-less? What if it was all a lie?

What if she had a living family? Would she stay and bond with them or make a run for freedom?
Tempted By The Enemy

Tempted By The Enemy

4.5k Views · Completed · rituparna darolia
Twenty-two-year-old Alyssa Van Every is in a dilemma. Her close friend, Sienna, is marrying billionaire, Lucas Donnelly who, along with his brothers, happens to be her older brother, Alex's sworn enemy.
She escapes to Preston Island to attend the wedding without informing him only to collide with Lucas’s hot, fiery and arrogant brother, the twenty-three-year-old, Nicholas Donnelly. Sparks immediately fly between them but Alyssa refuses to acknowledge them fearing her brother's wrath.
The wedding is over and Alyssa tries hard to forget the mysterious Nicholas Donnelly but can he forget her? Can he ignore the attraction he feels for her, feelings that have resurfaced after ten years?
What will Allyssa do when she is stalked by the man who has been invading her dreams since the day she met him? What will she do when she is whisked away to a deserted island by the unpredictable Nicholas Donnelly? Can she tame her heart or surrender to sinful temptations? Read to find out!
Part of the Temptation Series. Can be read as a standalone.
Ravens MC Series; Marlowe & Torin-Book 2 (Bad Boys Collections)

Ravens MC Series; Marlowe & Torin-Book 2 (Bad Boys Collections)

2.2k Views · Completed · Alisa Selby
Six months, twenty-nine days, three hours, and fourteen seconds. That's how long bliss lasts before reality rubs its big, fat ugly ass all over your happiness.
Marlowe Mills thought the hard part was surviving the enemies who wanted to destroy her. She was wrong.
The real damage came from the people she loved most. A buried secret. A devastating betrayal. A truth everyone knew except her.
Now the man she loves must prove that protecting someone isn't the same as lying to them, while she struggles to decide whether trust, once shattered, can ever truly be rebuilt. Because love was never the problem. Trust was.