From Lies To Loyalty

Chapter 1: The Conditional Feminist 

Lizzie

“When I’m entertaining colleagues,” Kenneth Greene said, folding his napkin with ceremonial precision, “I expect my wife to stay out of sight unless she’s serving something.”

I blinked.

Not because I hadn’t heard him. Because I wanted to confirm that the sentence had indeed existed outside a Victorian etiquette manual and inside my present reality.

“What?”

Kenneth smiled across the table with the benevolent patience of a man who had never, in his entire life, been contradicted. “You strike me as someone who understands her place. I’m certain we won’t encounter any difficulties in that department.”

“Oh… I see.”

I nodded politely and returned my attention to the salmon on my plate, slicing it into exact, geometric pieces while calmly calculating the legal consequences of stabbing someone with a salad fork during a first date. 

Was it attempted murder if one aimed carefully? Or just aggravated frustration?

Date number ten this month. Ten men. Ten restaurants. Ten carefully curated introductions arranged by my mother. Ten variations of the same conversation delivered with different accents, different watches, different bank accounts — but identical expectations.

Ten reminders that my mother loved the idea of me married far more than she loved me happy. She loved the idea of a wealthy son-in-law and a powerful last name. 

Across from me, Kenneth was speaking again. He had been speaking continuously, in fact. I suspected he would continue speaking even if oxygen were removed from the room.

“…of course my mother insists on proper standards,” he was saying, adjusting his cufflinks with a delicate flourish that suggested a lifelong appreciation for mirrors. “A wife should understand that a husband’s reputation reflects on her behavior. It’s simply… structure.”

Structure.

I lifted my wineglass, examining the deep red liquid. “Fascinating,” I said mildly. “And in this dystopian universe you exist in, do women also lose the right to oxygen?”

He paused, visibly startled — less by my words, I suspected, than by the novelty of encountering resistance.

His gaze flicked discreetly around the restaurant, perhaps checking whether witnesses had observed this unexpected rebellion from his potential bride.

The restaurant itself was dimly lit in the particular way expensive places believed made people look better than they were. Personally, I suspected it primarily existed to help men like Kenneth Greene appear less like the human equivalent of expired mayonnaise.

He leaned closer, lowering his voice. “I prefer a woman who doesn’t challenge her husband publicly,” he murmured. “It’s unattractive when women try to appear… argumentative.”

From a distance, we probably looked like a couple sharing secrets over candlelight. Up close, however, it felt more like a business negotiation in which I was both product and purchase.

I smiled pleasantly. “You don’t like intelligent women? Or do you simply dislike losing arguments to them, Kenneth?”

He did not flinch. “I admire intelligent women, Lizzie. As long as they know when not to use it.”

Ah. A rare specimen. The Conditional Feminist.

“I don’t believe in restricting women,” he continued smoothly. “I simply prefer they don’t contradict me. Openly.”

My mother had described him as traditional. Apparently, that meant he intended to marry me, silence me, and store me neatly beside the cookware.

I took another sip of wine and mentally opened a filing cabinet labeled ‘Historical Artifacts’. Kenneth was carefully placed inside a folder marked Obsolete, Misogynistic, Potentially Flammable.

“Your mother mentioned you enjoy writing,” he said, clearly encouraged by what he mistook for receptive silence. “A charming hobby. But naturally, after marriage, my wife wouldn’t need to concern herself with career ambitions. My income is more than sufficient. Domestic focus creates harmony.”

Domestic focus. I pictured gently placing his head inside the bread basket and closing the lid. Harmony indeed.

Smile. Sip. Breathe. Just a little longer, Lizzie.

He straightened slightly, as though preparing to deliver a particularly impressive revelation. “Our mothers spoke again this morning.”

I set my glass down carefully. “Yes?”

“She mentioned something admirable about you.”

My spine went rigid. I had learned through long experience that nothing my mother described as admirable benefited me.

Kenneth’s expression softened into what he clearly considered reverence. “She said you’ve preserved yourself for me. That you’re a virgin.”

The words settled on the table like something unpleasant and sticky.

He watched me expectantly, eyes gleaming with satisfaction—the look of a collector who had just confirmed the authenticity of a prized acquisition.

“I’ve always intended to marry a chaste woman,” he said proudly. “The idea of a wife who has been with other men is… revolting, frankly. One expects purity because experience in a wife suggests poor judgment. I find it difficult to respect women who arrive with history.” 

Something inside my chest went very still. Not explosive. Not dramatic. Simply cold and precise, like a door closing quietly.

I lifted my glass again, studying the wine as though evaluating a scientific specimen.

“How interesting,” I said calmly. “Are you a virgin, Kenneth?”

He blinked. Then he laughed — not nervously, but confidently. The laugh of a man who had never once imagined his own standards might apply to him.

“Of course not,” he scoffed. “I’m a man.”

I nodded once as I took a sip from my glass, as though he had just confirmed a minor detail on a form.

Then I spat the wine directly into his face.

The reaction was immediate and spectacular.

“What the hell, Lizzie!” he shouted, half rising from his chair. “Are you crazy?!”

Before he could recover, I lifted the glass again and emptied the remaining wine over his head. Red droplets clung to his eyelashes. A thin line of Cabernet slid down the bridge of his nose with tragic dignity. 

The restaurant fell silent. Conversations dissolved mid-sentence. A fork clinked somewhere in the distance.

Kenneth stared at me, stunned, blinking through the wine. 

I placed the empty glass gently on the table. “You,” I said evenly, “are a pig. A remarkably confident, spectacularly self-righteous pig.”

His mouth opened and closed without sound.

“For someone so concerned with purity,” I continued, rising from my chair and smoothing my dress, “it’s remarkable how comfortable you are with hypocrisy. You want ownership, not partnership. You want obedience, not respect. And you want standards that apply to women but evaporate the moment they inconvenience you.”

My voice managed to remain calm throughout and it actually surprised me. 

“I would rather marry a houseplant,” I added thoughtfully. “At least a fern contributes oxygen.”

I picked up my bag.

“Oh, and for future reference,” I said, meeting his eyes, “my personal history is not a commodity for your approval. Nor is it my mother’s bargaining chip.”

I leaned slightly closer, offering him the courtesy of clarity.

“But if you must know,” I whispered, “I am not a virgin. So yes—by your standards, I’m revolting. And as such, this won’t work out.”

Color flooded his face beneath the wine. His hands clenched on the table, knuckles whitening.

“Your mother speaks about a traditional woman for her son,” I added softly, “but she’s also the woman who wears turtlenecks in summer to hide what your father does to her.”

“Shut your mouth,” he hissed, voice low and trembling with fury.

I smiled pleasantly. “Have a lovely evening, Mr. Greene.”

Then I turned and walked toward the exit.

Behind me, his voice rose in indignant outrage. A waiter hurried forward. Someone gasped. Glassware rattled.

I laughed.

Outside, the night air struck my face and I inhaled deeply, feeling tension unwind from my shoulders. 

Nine terrible dates had been endurance. Ten had been education.

“I'm never doing this again.” I muttered to myself. 

I pulled out my phone and opened my messages to my mother. My thumbs hovered over the screen, ready to deliver a masterpiece of righteous fury.

Then I paused. Deleted the draft. Switched off the phone.

Why inform her when she would soon be informed by an outraged network of mothers who believed matrimony was a competitive sport?

Somewhere in this city, I decided, there had to be at least one man who did not require basic humanity explained to him like a household appliance manual.

I began walking home and I did not look back. Each step toward home felt like walking towards what was out to get me. The quiet stretched as the city seemed to hold its breath with me.

When I reached my street, the house stood at the end like a verdict. Every light was on. Even from the gate, I could see her silhouette through the curtains—still, upright, clearly waiting for me.

My pulse quickened. 

This wasn’t over. This was the beginning. I reached for the door handle. But something shifted inside…

And then… the door opened before I could touch it.