
Not Supposed To Love You
nicolemaygibbonsak · Completed · 201.9k Words
Introduction
Gage Ryker. Her brother's best friend, her lifelong tormentor, and the crush she never outgrew. Now he’s a six-foot-four problem in a hockey jersey-bigger, hotter, bossier than ever. And he’s looking at her like she’s not Brads baby sister anymore.
Their banter still bites. Their chemistry still burns. And the rule that’s always kept them apart? Hanging by a thread.
As Nicky rebuilds her life piece by piece-new room, new routine, new courage-Gage is always there. At her lowest moments. Her most vulnerable ones. And when he kisses her, everything they’ve buried comes roaring to the surface.
But falling for Gage means risking their friendship.
And Gage knows one wrong move could cost him everything he’s worked for.
She’s starting over
He’s losing control
And the line they swore they’d never cross is the only thing left between them.
Not Supposed To Love You is a slow-burn, brothers-best-friend romance filled with heat, humor, family, and the kind of tension that refuses to stay buried.
Chapter 1
“Kitten.” The voice was deep and suggestive from behind her. Making her stomach clinch and body heat in ways it hadn’t in years. Nicky let her eyes close for just a moment, a sigh rolling through her on a warm wave before she turned to face him.
Sexy as fuck in his black Denver Avalanche hoodie and worn blue jeans that wrapped around powerful thighs. Tall, every inch of him rippled with mouth watering muscles. His sweatshirt didn’t disguise his broad shoulders and ripped chest. A strong jaw covered in stubble, short cropped brown hair that she was sure was still long enough to tangle her fingers in. Hazel eyes that had always had women melting in a puddle at his feet.
Gage Ryker.
Her brothers’ best friend. The boy she wanted in ways that were not allowed. Her bantering partner. Sounding board. Mirror. Bully. They’d spent their childhood pushing each others’ buttons ignoring the one thing that had always lived and breathed between them. It wasn’t hate. An attraction that neither of them wanted but couldn’t completely walk away from either.
He’d always been confident, dominating every room he walked into without even trying. He carried himself easily like the world didn’t matter to him, he was just in it. A leader, people looked up to him. Followed him without question. He stood in-front of her his thumbs hooked into his front pockets a familiar smirk on his face, eyes sparkling.
“Ryker.” She didn’t saw his name. She breathed it. Like a stupid little girl crush. Nicky kicked herself. Fucking dumb. Pull yourself together.
“Heard trouble was coming back into town.” Gage said a smile pulling at his mouth. His eyes dropped, running over her critically, making her self conscious in only a way he had ever been able to. “You look good.”
“I know.” Nicky said. Hiding the excited drop in her stomach with a confident smile, sassily tossing her hair back over her shoulder.
She looked fucking amazing. Five years and she’d turned from a cute teenager into a freaking goddess. Curvy and soft in all the right places. Her crop top revealed an impressive amount of cleavage, tight waist and a belly button ring she hadn’t had when she’d left. Her jeans were fitted hugging her thighs and rear, sitting low on her hips. Her dark brown hair hung down her back in a mess of waves and curls, that looked like she hadn’t even tried to tame them. Her green eyes, deep and expressive. Filled with sass and attitude exactly how he remembered them.
He’d been obsessed with her for as long as he could remember. His best friends baby sister. Off limits. Younger by four years she’d pretty much followed them around all through childhood. Gage and Brad had rarely gone anywhere without Nicky close behind. An annoying little narrator to their activities with her snarky sass. Completely oblivious to the effect she had on him. Not that he had ever let on about it. He’d spent most of his life trying to ignore it.
When she’d left home for college, they’d kept up their banter via text, unable to let each other completely go. Meme, videos, jokes. Little things. He’d tell her about a game. She’d tell him about a class. He told her about his latest bed partner. When she’d moved in with Jeremy, he’d thought he’d lost her. Lost anything that could have been. But now she was back. Moving into the house he shared with his best friend Brad, Brads girlfriend Cia and their little girl Remy.
“Where’s Brad?” Nicky asked.
“Right here kid.” Brad said swooping in around Gage to wrap her in a hug, lifting her feet off the floor. Nicky wrapped her arms around his neck taking a deep breath of his cologne, sweet and earthy. Brad was goofy, stupid and relentlessly annoying. But no matter how much she fucked up. How much she’d pissed off their mother. He was always there backing her up. Her safe space.
Two days ago, she’d caught her boyfriend in bed with another woman. Nicky had been furious. She’d gotten loud and in his face. He’d gone from contrite and apologetic to angry and threatening in a split second. Before she’d known what was going on he’d had her by the hair slamming her into the wall. He’d pressed her face against it leaning in close behind her, mouth brushing her ear telling her she didn’t get to dictate their relationship.
He’d fuck who he wanted, when he wanted, how he wanted. And that had included her. He’d groped her squeezing her breasts, humping her through her clothes. His breath hot in her ear he’d latched his teeth around her shoulder. He’d been pulling at her clothes, groaning when the woman on the bed had whined his name. He’d shoved Nicky into a chair and gone back to where the other woman was waiting on the bed.
Nicky had been stunned. Terrified. She’d never been treated that way. It took her a minute to pull herself together and snap out of it. She managed to slip out of the room without being noticed. Grabbing her dance bag and her purse she’d ran, leaving everything else behind. With only a hundred dollars in her pocket she’d gone to a dirty motel. Two a.m. she’d called him and Brad had answered without irritation or accusations. He’d got her on a flight home the next day.
With his arms around her now the tears pushed back into her eyes, tightening her throat. She’d kept it together over the ten hours of traveling. Even when her phone had started blowing up with texts, calls and facetimes from Jeremy. She’d ridden high on the anger at his gall. Nicky wasn’t a wilting flower. She wasn’t the type of girl to be controlled. Who did he think he was? She’d blocked him, building high walls around the fear he had caused. The feeling of helplessness. They crumpled now. Her breath catching on a sob and she tucked her face into Brads neck.
Last Chapters
#174 Chapter 174 Clarity
Last Updated: 9/1/2026#173 Chapter 173 Suspended
Last Updated: 8/31/2026#172 Chapter 172 Complications
Last Updated: 8/31/2026#171 Chapter 171 The Lift
Last Updated: 8/31/2026#170 Chapter 170 Opening Night
Last Updated: 8/31/2026#169 Chapter 169 Backstage
Last Updated: 8/30/2026#168 Chapter 168 Trauma Drama
Last Updated: 8/30/2026#167 Chapter 167 I’m Pregnant
Last Updated: 8/30/2026#166 Chapter 166 Nicky
Last Updated: 8/30/2026#165 Chapter 165 Leaving the Team
Last Updated: 8/29/2026
You Might Like 😍
Cue the Dark
Rejected By My Family, Desired By The Mafia
While the real heiress struggled to survive, the nanny’s daughter, Talia, was raised in luxury as the beloved jewel of the Laurent family, pampered by Camille’s parents, adored by her three brothers, and even promised to the prestigious Matteo Devereux through a childhood engagement arranged by their grandparents.
Then the truth came out.
Six months ago, Camille was finally brought back to the Laurent family. To protect the family reputation and prove their devotion to their bloodline, the Laurent patriarch transferred 35% of his personal shares into Camille’s name overnight, instantly making her one of the wealthiest heiresses in the country.
It brought anxiety to all the Laurent family. But what they don’t know…is that Camille never needed them.
Behind her elegant smile lies a woman filled with secrets powerful enough to shake the whole family. She's a miraculous healer capable of curing the incurable poisons.
Yet despite everything, her family still chooses Talia.
Every accusation against Talia is forgiven. Every scheme against Camille is brushed aside. Even Matteo, the man who was supposed to be Camille’s fiancé—cannot let go of the woman he always believed belonged by his side.
But while the Laurent family underestimates Camille, another man begins to see exactly who she is.
Dante Moretti.
The ruthless heir of an old-money dynasty. A billionaire CEO worshipped by the public…and the merciless king of a criminal empire hidden beneath the city’s glittering surface. When Dante is poisoned by a rival syndicate with a deadly toxin no doctor can cure, he offers a fortune for anyone who can save him.
Only Camille can. Their deal is simple: she becomes his personal physician, and he gives her anything she wants.
After Divorce,I Became His Only Love
Then, on their wedding anniversary, she walked into his private club and heard him whisper to another woman: "Take care of our baby."
The woman was his brother's wife.
Everything—the gentleness, the restraint, the so-called love—had been an elaborate performance. And when Serena demanded a divorce, Leo didn't beg. He didn't apologize. He smiled and said: "Your grandmother wouldn't want that."
Now Serena must fight her way out of a marriage designed to cage her, a family that wants her silent, and a past that still has teeth. But the man who appears from the shadows to help her… is the same one who abandoned her years ago.
And he has secrets of his own.
Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine
Perhaps then they would stop controlling my every move. Maybe my brothers would stop resenting me. Perhaps I wouldn’t feel so invisible anymore.
No one believed I could do it—not even my mate, Alpha Jaxon Trevane.
The night I planned to tell him... I found him tangled in bed with my best friend.
Heartbroken and humiliated, I left everything behind and went to Elite alone.
But the academy isn’t the fairytale I dreamed about.
Beneath the grand halls and traditions, a brutal game is being played.
The four ruling Alphas of the North, South, East, and West fight for power, dominance... and now, for me.
A virgin. Untouched. Unclaimed. The prize they all want.
There’s the mate who shattered my heart and swears he’ll win me back.
The brilliant strategist who wants me as his Luna.
The dangerous playboy who promises no one will ever touch me but him.
And the cold, possessive Alpha who watches from the shadows—and would destroy anyone who dares to take me from him.
But in a place where love is a battlefield and lust is a weapon... falling in love might be the most dangerous thing I ever do.
Welcome to Elite Order Academy—where every desire has a price, and my body is the ultimate trophy.
Everybody is Guilty Here
Middlesbrough's underworld is a dangerous game, and Matthew Smith finds himself right in the middle of it. A once-feared gang leader, he is now forced to be a pawn in a deadly cat-and-mouse game. Matthew's only shot at freedom is helping the police bring down Mr. K, the elusive mafia boss of the city. The only problem is that the detective he is forced to work with is the same man who arrested him years ago.
Masahiro Payne is everything Matthew hates: cold, calculating, and relentless. But their only hope for survival is by pretending to be a happy couple, blending in amidst dangerous crime, deceit, and power struggles. The closer they find themselves to taking down Mr. K's empire, the more they are attracted to one another, an affair too potent to turn from.
As their undercover mission spirals into a web of lies and hidden desires, they face a growing threat from all sides. But the greatest risk is the one they can't control-their own feelings. With every touch, every stolen kiss, the line between their fake relationship and real emotions blurs.
In a world of betrayal, trust is a luxury, and falling for each other may be the deadliest mistake of all. Can they survive the deadly mafia games or will their passion be their demise?
The Family Books 1-3 (A Mafia romance)
The saint to my sinner. with her innocent eyes and devilish curves.
A Madonna that was meant to be admired but never touched.
Until someone took that innocence from her.
She left.
The darkness in my heart was finally complete.
I avenged her, I killed for her, but she never came back.
Until I saw her again. An angel dancing around a pole for money.
She didn’t know I owned that club. She didn’t know I was watching.
This time I won’t let her escape.
I will make her back into the girl I knew.
Whether she likes it or not.
2/ Judge and Jury- I can’t stop watching her.
I’m not even sure I want to.
Taylor Lawson, blonde, beautiful, and totally oblivious to how much dangers she’s in.
She’s also the one juror in my upcoming murder trial that hasn’t been bought.
The one who can put me behind bars for a very long time.
I know I should execute her.
After all that’s what I do.
I am the Judge.
I eliminate threats to The Family.
And Taylor is a threat.
But I don’t want to kill her.
Possessing her, making her love me seems like a much better plan for this particular Juror.
3/ Rags and Ritches-
Tempted By The Enemy
She escapes to Preston Island to attend the wedding without informing him only to collide with Lucas’s hot, fiery and arrogant brother, the twenty-three-year-old, Nicholas Donnelly. Sparks immediately fly between them but Alyssa refuses to acknowledge them fearing her brother's wrath.
The wedding is over and Alyssa tries hard to forget the mysterious Nicholas Donnelly but can he forget her? Can he ignore the attraction he feels for her, feelings that have resurfaced after ten years?
What will Allyssa do when she is stalked by the man who has been invading her dreams since the day she met him? What will she do when she is whisked away to a deserted island by the unpredictable Nicholas Donnelly? Can she tame her heart or surrender to sinful temptations? Read to find out!
Part of the Temptation Series. Can be read as a standalone.
Reborn and Unleashed: The Boss Lady Takes No Prisoners
Now reborn, Vivian refuses to hide her strength. She's revealing her true identity, claiming her power, and rewriting her fate. No more submission, no more misunderstandings—this time, she'll take control of her life and her love.
As regretful brothers beg for forgiveness and powerful enemies fall at her feet, Vivian has one goal: to rise without mercy and make the man she once loved fall for her all over again—on her terms.
The rejected white luna
Let Them Kneel
Cast out by her pack. Forgotten by the Lycans.
She lived among humans—quiet, invisible, tucked away in a town no one looked at twice.
But when her first heat comes without warning, everything changes.
Her body ignites. Her instincts scream. And something primal stirs beneath her skin—
summoning a big, bad Alpha who knows exactly how to quench her fire.
When he claims her, it’s ecstasy and ruin.
For the first time, she believes she’s been accepted.
Seen.
Chosen.
Until he leaves her the next morning—
like a secret never to be spoken.
But Kaelani is not what they thought.
Not wolfless. Not weak.
There is something ancient inside her. Something powerful. And it’s waking.
And when it does—
they’ll all remember the girl they tried to erase.
Especially him.
She’ll be the dream he keeps chasing… the one thing that ever made him feel alive.
Because secrets never stay buried.
And neither do dreams.
Luna Rising
They were wrong.
Seren was stolen as a newborn and raised in a pack that treated her as disposable. Beaten and imprisoned, she survives by hiding her strength—until a mating ball brings fate crashing into her life.
With enemies willing to sell lives and a past tied to the throne, Seren must rise…or die.
A dark werewolf romance of power, fate, and vengeance.
Luna On The Run- I stole The Alpha's Sons
But Axton is more than just a rival, he's her fated mate. And he's been searching for her not for love, but for revenge and a chance to destroy her father's pack. The next morning, Elena rejects him, walking away before he can trap her in his ruthless schemes.
But Axton does not take rejection lightly, and his retaliation is brutal: a leaked video, a ruined reputation, and a family that turns their backs on her drive her to flee the city in disgrace.
But when Elena disappears, she takes something Alpha Axton never planned to lose - his sons. Now, he'll stop at nothing to get them back. He wants his heirs, he wants his mate, and Elena will learn that no one runs from the Alpha.












